Benchmarking Large Language Models on Communicative Medical Coaching: a Novel System and Dataset
2402.05547
0
0
💬
Abstract
Traditional applications of natural language processing (NLP) in healthcare have predominantly focused on patient-centered services, enhancing patient interactions and care delivery, such as through medical dialogue systems. However, the potential of NLP to benefit inexperienced doctors, particularly in areas such as communicative medical coaching, remains largely unexplored. We introduce ChatCoach, a human-AI cooperative framework designed to assist medical learners in practicing their communication skills during patient consultations. ChatCoach (Our data and code are available online: https://github.com/zerowst/Chatcoach)differentiates itself from conventional dialogue systems by offering a simulated environment where medical learners can practice dialogues with a patient agent, while a coach agent provides immediate, structured feedback. This is facilitated by our proposed Generalized Chain-of-Thought (GCoT) approach, which fosters the generation of structured feedback and enhances the utilization of external knowledge sources. Additionally, we have developed a dataset specifically for evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) within the ChatCoach framework on communicative medical coaching tasks. Our empirical results validate the effectiveness of ChatCoach.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper introduces ChatCoach, a human-AI cooperative framework designed to assist medical learners in practicing their communication skills during patient consultations.
- ChatCoach differs from conventional dialogue systems by offering a simulated environment where medical learners can practice dialogues with a patient agent, while a coach agent provides immediate, structured feedback.
- The framework leverages a Generalized Chain-of-Thought (GCoT) approach to generate structured feedback and enhance the utilization of external knowledge sources.
- The researchers have also developed a dataset specifically for evaluating Large Language Models (LLMs) within the ChatCoach framework on communicative medical coaching tasks.
Plain English Explanation
The paper introduces a new system called ChatCoach that is designed to help medical students practice their communication skills when talking to patients. Unlike traditional dialogue systems that focus on improving patient interactions, ChatCoach offers a simulated environment where students can practice having conversations with a virtual patient. While the student is talking to the patient, a "coach" agent provides immediate feedback to help the student improve their communication skills.
The key innovation in ChatCoach is the use of a Generalized Chain-of-Thought (GCoT) approach, which helps the coach agent generate more structured and useful feedback. This approach also allows ChatCoach to better utilize external knowledge sources, such as medical information, to provide more relevant and informed feedback to the students.
Additionally, the researchers have created a new dataset specifically for evaluating how well large language models (LLMs) can perform on the task of providing communication coaching within the ChatCoach framework. This dataset will help researchers and developers improve the performance of LLMs in this important medical education application.
The key goal of ChatCoach is to give medical students a safe and supportive environment to practice their communication skills with patients, while receiving real-time feedback to help them improve. This could be particularly valuable for students who are still developing their bedside manner and need to practice having empathetic, informative conversations with patients.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel human-AI cooperative framework called ChatCoach, which is designed to assist medical learners in practicing their communication skills during patient consultations. Unlike traditional dialogue systems that focus on enhancing patient interactions, ChatCoach offers a simulated environment where medical learners can engage in dialogues with a patient agent, while a coach agent provides immediate, structured feedback.
The core innovation of ChatCoach is the Generalized Chain-of-Thought (GCoT) approach, which fosters the generation of structured feedback and enhances the utilization of external knowledge sources. This allows the coach agent to provide more comprehensive and relevant feedback to the learners, addressing not only the content of the dialogue but also aspects of communication, such as empathy and information delivery.
To evaluate the performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) within the ChatCoach framework, the researchers have developed a dataset specifically designed for communicative medical coaching tasks. This dataset enables the assessment of LLMs' ability to provide empathetic and informative feedback to medical learners, which is a crucial aspect of improving their communication skills.
The empirical results presented in the paper validate the effectiveness of the ChatCoach framework in enhancing medical learners' communication skills through the human-AI collaborative approach. This work contributes to the growing body of research on the applications of large language models in the medical domain.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to leveraging AI technology to improve the communication skills of medical learners. The key strengths of the ChatCoach framework include the use of a simulated environment for practice, the integration of a coach agent to provide structured feedback, and the innovative Generalized Chain-of-Thought (GCoT) approach to enhance the feedback generation process.
However, the paper does not extensively discuss the potential limitations or challenges of the ChatCoach system. For example, the fidelity and realism of the simulated patient interactions could impact the transfer of learning to real-world clinical settings. Additionally, the effectiveness of the feedback provided by the coach agent, and the ability of medical learners to incorporate that feedback into their communication skills, warrants further investigation.
Moreover, the paper focuses on the development and evaluation of the ChatCoach framework, but does not provide a detailed analysis of the specific communication skills that are being targeted or the long-term impact on learners' professional development. Exploring these aspects could help to better understand the broader implications and potential of the ChatCoach system.
Overall, the ChatCoach framework presents an innovative approach to leveraging AI technology to assist medical learners in developing their communication skills. Further research and refinement of the system, as well as a more comprehensive evaluation of its impact, could strengthen the potential of this technology to contribute to the advancement of medical education and healthcare.
Conclusion
The paper introduces ChatCoach, a human-AI cooperative framework designed to assist medical learners in practicing and improving their communication skills during patient consultations. The key innovations of ChatCoach include the use of a simulated environment for practice, the integration of a coach agent that provides structured feedback using a Generalized Chain-of-Thought (GCoT) approach, and the development of a dataset for evaluating the performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the context of communicative medical coaching.
The empirical results presented in the paper validate the effectiveness of the ChatCoach framework, suggesting that this technology has the potential to significantly enhance the communication skills of medical learners. By providing a safe and supportive environment for practice, along with real-time feedback and guidance, ChatCoach can help bridge the gap between classroom learning and real-world patient interactions.
As the medical field continues to emphasize the importance of effective communication in patient care, the development of systems like ChatCoach could have far-reaching implications for the quality of healthcare delivery and the overall well-being of both patients and healthcare providers.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Towards Enhancing Health Coaching Dialogue in Low-Resource Settings
Yue Zhou, Barbara Di Eugenio, Brian Ziebart, Lisa Sharp, Bing Liu, Ben Gerber, Nikolaos Agadakos, Shweta Yadav
0
0
Health coaching helps patients identify and accomplish lifestyle-related goals, effectively improving the control of chronic diseases and mitigating mental health conditions. However, health coaching is cost-prohibitive due to its highly personalized and labor-intensive nature. In this paper, we propose to build a dialogue system that converses with the patients, helps them create and accomplish specific goals, and can address their emotions with empathy. However, building such a system is challenging since real-world health coaching datasets are limited and empathy is subtle. Thus, we propose a modularized health coaching dialogue system with simplified NLU and NLG frameworks combined with mechanism-conditioned empathetic response generation. Through automatic and human evaluation, we show that our system generates more empathetic, fluent, and coherent responses and outperforms the state-of-the-art in NLU tasks while requiring less annotation. We view our approach as a key step towards building automated and more accessible health coaching systems.
4/16/2024
Conversational Disease Diagnosis via External Planner-Controlled Large Language Models
Zhoujian Sun, Cheng Luo, Ziyi Liu, Zhengxing Huang
0
0
The development of large language models (LLMs) has brought unprecedented possibilities for artificial intelligence (AI) based medical diagnosis. However, the application perspective of LLMs in real diagnostic scenarios is still unclear because they are not adept at collecting patient data proactively. This study presents a LLM-based diagnostic system that enhances planning capabilities by emulating doctors. Our system involves two external planners to handle planning tasks. The first planner employs a reinforcement learning approach to formulate disease screening questions and conduct initial diagnoses. The second planner uses LLMs to parse medical guidelines and conduct differential diagnoses. By utilizing real patient electronic medical record data, we constructed simulated dialogues between virtual patients and doctors and evaluated the diagnostic abilities of our system. We demonstrated that our system obtained impressive performance in both disease screening and differential diagnoses tasks. This research represents a step towards more seamlessly integrating AI into clinical settings, potentially enhancing the accuracy and accessibility of medical diagnostics.
5/21/2024
A Survey on Large Language Models from General Purpose to Medical Applications: Datasets, Methodologies, and Evaluations
Jinqiang Wang, Huansheng Ning, Yi Peng, Qikai Wei, Daniel Tesfai, Wenwei Mao, Tao Zhu, Runhe Huang
0
0
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated surprising performance across various natural language processing tasks. Recently, medical LLMs enhanced with domain-specific knowledge have exhibited excellent capabilities in medical consultation and diagnosis. These models can smoothly simulate doctor-patient dialogues and provide professional medical advice. Most medical LLMs are developed through continued training of open-source general LLMs, which require significantly fewer computational resources than training LLMs from scratch. Additionally, this approach offers better protection of patient privacy compared to API-based solutions. This survey systematically explores how to train medical LLMs based on general LLMs. It covers: (a) how to acquire training corpus and construct customized medical training sets, (b) how to choose a appropriate training paradigm, (c) how to choose a suitable evaluation benchmark, and (d) existing challenges and promising future research directions are discussed. This survey can provide guidance for the development of LLMs focused on various medical applications, such as medical education, diagnostic planning, and clinical assistants.
6/18/2024
Assessing Empathy in Large Language Models with Real-World Physician-Patient Interactions
Man Luo, Christopher J. Warren, Lu Cheng, Haidar M. Abdul-Muhsin, Imon Banerjee
0
0
The integration of Large Language Models (LLMs) into the healthcare domain has the potential to significantly enhance patient care and support through the development of empathetic, patient-facing chatbots. This study investigates an intriguing question Can ChatGPT respond with a greater degree of empathy than those typically offered by physicians? To answer this question, we collect a de-identified dataset of patient messages and physician responses from Mayo Clinic and generate alternative replies using ChatGPT. Our analyses incorporate novel empathy ranking evaluation (EMRank) involving both automated metrics and human assessments to gauge the empathy level of responses. Our findings indicate that LLM-powered chatbots have the potential to surpass human physicians in delivering empathetic communication, suggesting a promising avenue for enhancing patient care and reducing professional burnout. The study not only highlights the importance of empathy in patient interactions but also proposes a set of effective automatic empathy ranking metrics, paving the way for the broader adoption of LLMs in healthcare.
5/28/2024