Beyond Check-in Counts: Redefining Popularity for POI Recommendation with Users and Recency
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a new approach to Point-of-Interest (POI) recommendation that goes beyond simply counting check-ins to define popularity.
- It incorporates user-specific and temporal factors to better capture the evolving nature of POI popularity.
- The research aims to improve the accuracy and relevance of POI recommendations for users.
Plain English Explanation
When recommending places for people to visit, such as restaurants or attractions, the traditional approach has been to simply look at how many times a location has been "checked into" by users. The more check-ins a POI has, the more "popular" it is considered to be, and the more likely it will be recommended.
However, this study argues that this method is too simplistic. It fails to account for important factors like who is checking in and how recently they did so. The paper introduces a new way to define and measure POI popularity that incorporates both user-specific and temporal information.
By considering factors like the diversity of users visiting a POI and how recently it has been popular, the researchers believe they can develop more accurate and relevant POI recommendations for individuals. This could help users discover new places they're more likely to enjoy, rather than just the most broadly popular options.
Technical Explanation
The key innovations in this paper are:
-
User-specific Popularity: Rather than just counting total check-ins, the researchers calculate a POI's popularity based on the diversity of users who have visited it. POIs frequented by a wider range of users are considered more popular.
-
Temporal Popularity: In addition to user diversity, the paper also factors in how recently a POI has been popular. POIs that have seen a spike in check-ins more recently are weighted more heavily.
-
Hybrid Popularity Model: The user-specific and temporal popularity measures are combined into a hybrid model that aims to better capture evolving POI trends and preferences.
The authors test their approach on real-world location data and show that it outperforms traditional check-in count-based popularity metrics in terms of recommendation accuracy and relevance. This suggests their redefined notion of POI "popularity" can lead to more useful recommendations for users.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for moving beyond simple check-in counts when modeling POI popularity. Incorporating user diversity and temporal recency are reasonable extensions that could lead to more personalized and up-to-date recommendations.
However, the authors acknowledge several limitations in their approach. For example, the user-specific popularity metric may be biased towards POIs frequented by more prolific or influential users. There are also open questions about how to best combine the user and temporal factors into a single hybrid score.
Additionally, while the experiments demonstrate improved recommendation performance, the real-world impacts and potential unintended consequences are not thoroughly explored. There may be privacy or fairness concerns around using individual user behavior to infer POI popularity.
Overall, the research represents a thoughtful step forward in POI recommendation, but further work is needed to fully understand the implications and limitations of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper challenges the standard check-in count-based definition of POI popularity, arguing that a more nuanced model incorporating user-specific and temporal factors can lead to better recommendations. By redefining popularity in this way, the authors demonstrate improvements in recommendation accuracy and relevance.
While the technical approach is sound, there are still open questions and potential concerns that warrant further investigation. Nevertheless, this research represents an important advance in the field of POI recommendation, with the potential to deliver more personalized and up-to-date suggestions for users exploring new places.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Beyond Check-in Counts: Redefining Popularity for POI Recommendation with Users and Recency
Alif Al Hasan, Md Musfique Anwar
The next POI (point of interest) recommendation aims to predict users' immediate future movements based on their prior records and present circumstances, which will be very beneficial to service providers as well as users. The popularity of the POI over time is one of the primary deciding factors for choosing the next POI to visit. The majority of research in recent times has paid more attention to the number of check-ins to define the popularity of a point of interest, disregarding the temporal impact or number of people checking in for a particular POI. In this paper, we propose a recency-oriented definition of popularity that takes into account the temporal effect on POI's popularity, the number of check-ins, as well as the number of people who registered those check-ins. Thus, recent check-ins get prioritized with more weight compared to the older ones. Experimental results demonstrate that performance is better with recency-aware popularity definitions for POIs than with solely check-in count-based popularity definitions.
Read more7/9/2024
0
Popular News Always Compete for the User's Attention! POPK: Mitigating Popularity Bias via a Temporal-Counterfactual
Igor L. R. Azevedo, Toyotaro Suzumura, Yuichiro Yasui
In news recommendation systems, reducing popularity bias is essential for delivering accurate and diverse recommendations. This paper presents POPK, a new method that uses temporal-counterfactual analysis to mitigate the influence of popular news articles. By asking, What if, at a given time $t$, a set of popular news articles were competing for the user's attention to be clicked?, POPK aims to improve recommendation accuracy and diversity. We tested POPK on three different language datasets (Japanese, English, and Norwegian) and found that it successfully enhances traditional methods. POPK offers flexibility for customization to enhance either accuracy or diversity, alongside providing distinct ways of measuring popularity. We argue that popular news articles always compete for attention, even if they are not explicitly present in the user's impression list. POPK systematically eliminates the implicit influence of popular news articles during each training step. We combine counterfactual reasoning with a temporal approach to adjust the negative sample space, refining understanding of user interests. Our findings underscore how POPK effectively enhances the accuracy and diversity of recommended articles while also tailoring the approach to specific needs.
Read more7/16/2024
0
CAPRI-FAIR: Integration of Multi-sided Fairness in Contextual POI Recommendation Framework
Francis Zac dela Cruz, Flora D. Salim, Yonchanok Khaokaew, Jeffrey Chan
Point-of-interest (POI) recommendation considers spatio-temporal factors like distance, peak hours, and user check-ins. Given their influence on both consumer experience and POI business, it's crucial to consider fairness from multiple perspectives. Unfortunately, these systems often provide less accurate recommendations to inactive users and less exposure to unpopular POIs. This paper develops a post-filter method that includes provider and consumer fairness in existing models, aiming to balance fairness metrics like item exposure with performance metrics such as precision and distance. Experiments show that a linear scoring model for provider fairness in re-scoring items offers the best balance between performance and long-tail exposure, sometimes without much precision loss. Addressing consumer fairness by recommending more popular POIs to inactive users increased precision in some models and datasets. However, combinations that reached the Pareto front of consumer and provider fairness resulted in the lowest precision values, highlighting that tradeoffs depend greatly on the model and dataset.
Read more8/15/2024
0
Large Language Models for Next Point-of-Interest Recommendation
Peibo Li, Maarten de Rijke, Hao Xue, Shuang Ao, Yang Song, Flora D. Salim
The next Point of Interest (POI) recommendation task is to predict users' immediate next POI visit given their historical data. Location-Based Social Network (LBSN) data, which is often used for the next POI recommendation task, comes with challenges. One frequently disregarded challenge is how to effectively use the abundant contextual information present in LBSN data. Previous methods are limited by their numerical nature and fail to address this challenge. In this paper, we propose a framework that uses pretrained Large Language Models (LLMs) to tackle this challenge. Our framework allows us to preserve heterogeneous LBSN data in its original format, hence avoiding the loss of contextual information. Furthermore, our framework is capable of comprehending the inherent meaning of contextual information due to the inclusion of commonsense knowledge. In experiments, we test our framework on three real-world LBSN datasets. Our results show that the proposed framework outperforms the state-of-the-art models in all three datasets. Our analysis demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed framework in using contextual information as well as alleviating the commonly encountered cold-start and short trajectory problems.
Read more8/2/2024