Bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacian: convergence to manifold Laplacian and robustness to outlier noise

Read original: arXiv:2206.11386 - Published 7/19/2024 by Xiuyuan Cheng, Boris Landa

🏋️

Overview

This paper analyzes the convergence properties of bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacians, which are used in various graph-based data analysis tasks.
The authors prove the point-wise convergence of the graph Laplacian to the manifold Laplacian, with rates that depend on the intrinsic dimensionality of the manifold and the number of data points.
They also show that the bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacian is robust to outlier noise in the data.
Motivated by their analysis, the authors propose an approximate and constrained matrix scaling problem that can be solved efficiently using Sinkhorn-Knopp iterations.

Plain English Explanation

The paper is about a particular way of normalizing graph Laplacians, which are mathematical objects used in many graph-based data analysis techniques. Graph-based data analysis is a way of analyzing data that is organized in the form of a graph, where data points are represented as nodes and the relationships between them are represented as edges.

The authors show that this bi-stochastic normalization of the graph Laplacian has some nice mathematical properties. Specifically, they prove that as the number of data points increases and the way the data is embedded in the high-dimensional space becomes more accurate, the bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacian converges to the "true" Laplacian of the underlying manifold that the data is assumed to lie on. Manifold fitting under unbounded noise is an important problem in this area.

This convergence result holds even when the data is contaminated by outliers, which are data points that don't really belong to the manifold. The authors show that the bi-stochastic normalization makes the graph Laplacian robust to these outliers.

Motivated by their analysis, the authors also propose a more efficient way of computing the bi-stochastic normalization, using an approximate and constrained matrix scaling problem that can be solved quickly. Convergence rates of stochastic approximation with biased noise is a relevant concept here.

Overall, this work provides theoretical insights into the properties of bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacians and suggests ways to make their computation more efficient, which can be useful in manifold perspective on statistical generalization of graph neural networks and other graph-based machine learning tasks.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on the mathematical analysis of bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacians, which are widely used in graph-based data analysis and machine learning tasks. The authors prove the point-wise convergence of the bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacian to the manifold (weighted-)Laplacian, as the number of data points (n) goes to infinity and the kernel bandwidth (ε) goes to 0, at a rate of O(n^(-1/(d/2+3))), where d is the intrinsic dimensionality of the manifold.

The authors also show that this convergence result holds even when the data is corrupted by outlier noise. Specifically, they prove that the graph Laplacian is point-wise consistent, with an additional term that depends on the boundedness of the inner products of the noise vectors and the data vectors.

Motivated by these theoretical insights, the authors propose an approximate and constrained matrix scaling problem that can be solved efficiently using Sinkhorn-Knopp iterations with early termination. This approach allows for a more computationally efficient way of computing the bi-stochastic normalization, while still maintaining the desirable convergence and robustness properties.

The paper includes numerical experiments that support the theoretical results and demonstrate the robustness of the bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacian to high-dimensional outlier noise.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a rigorous mathematical analysis of the convergence and robustness properties of bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacians, which is a valuable contribution to the field of graph-based data analysis. The authors' insights suggest that the bi-stochastic normalization can be a powerful tool for handling noisy and high-dimensional data, which is an important challenge in many real-world applications.

One potential limitation of the work is that the analysis is largely theoretical, and the proposed approximate matrix scaling approach has not been extensively tested on large-scale, real-world datasets. It would be interesting to see how the method performs in practice, especially in scenarios with complex, high-dimensional data and diverse types of noise and outliers.

Additionally, the paper does not discuss the computational complexity of the Sinkhorn-Knopp iterations used in the proposed approach. While the authors claim that the method is more efficient than exact bi-stochastic normalization, a more detailed analysis of the computational costs and scalability of the algorithm would be helpful for assessing its practical usefulness.

Overall, this paper makes an important contribution to the theoretical understanding of graph Laplacians and suggests promising directions for developing robust and efficient graph-based data analysis techniques. Manifold perspective on statistical generalization of graph neural networks is a related area where these insights could be useful.

Conclusion

This paper provides a comprehensive analysis of bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacians, proving their convergence to the manifold Laplacian and their robustness to outlier noise. The authors' theoretical insights lead to the development of an efficient approximation method for computing the bi-stochastic normalization, which could have significant practical implications for a wide range of graph-based data analysis and machine learning tasks. While the paper focuses on the theoretical aspects, the proposed approach shows promise and warrants further investigation, particularly in the context of real-world, large-scale applications.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🏋️

Bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacian: convergence to manifold Laplacian and robustness to outlier noise

Xiuyuan Cheng, Boris Landa

Bi-stochastic normalization provides an alternative normalization of graph Laplacians in graph-based data analysis and can be computed efficiently by Sinkhorn-Knopp (SK) iterations. This paper proves the convergence of bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacian to manifold (weighted-)Laplacian with rates, when $n$ data points are i.i.d. sampled from a general $d$-dimensional manifold embedded in a possibly high-dimensional space. Under certain joint limit of $n to infty$ and kernel bandwidth $epsilon to 0$, the point-wise convergence rate of the graph Laplacian operator (under 2-norm) is proved to be $ O( n^{-1/(d/2+3)})$ at finite large $n$ up to log factors, achieved at the scaling of $epsilon sim n^{-1/(d/2+3)} $. When the manifold data are corrupted by outlier noise, we theoretically prove the graph Laplacian point-wise consistency which matches the rate for clean manifold data plus an additional term proportional to the boundedness of the inner-products of the noise vectors among themselves and with data vectors. Motivated by our analysis, which suggests that not exact bi-stochastic normalization but an approximate one will achieve the same consistency rate, we propose an approximate and constrained matrix scaling problem that can be solved by SK iterations with early termination. Numerical experiments support our theoretical results and show the robustness of bi-stochastically normalized graph Laplacian to high-dimensional outlier noise.

7/19/2024

📈

The G-invariant graph Laplacian

Eitan Rosen, Paulina Hoyos, Xiuyuan Cheng, Joe Kileel, Yoel Shkolnisky

Graph Laplacian based algorithms for data lying on a manifold have been proven effective for tasks such as dimensionality reduction, clustering, and denoising. In this work, we consider data sets whose data points lie on a manifold that is closed under the action of a known unitary matrix Lie group G. We propose to construct the graph Laplacian by incorporating the distances between all the pairs of points generated by the action of G on the data set. We deem the latter construction the ``G-invariant Graph Laplacian'' (G-GL). We show that the G-GL converges to the Laplace-Beltrami operator on the data manifold, while enjoying a significantly improved convergence rate compared to the standard graph Laplacian which only utilizes the distances between the points in the given data set. Furthermore, we show that the G-GL admits a set of eigenfunctions that have the form of certain products between the group elements and eigenvectors of certain matrices, which can be estimated from the data efficiently using FFT-type algorithms. We demonstrate our construction and its advantages on the problem of filtering data on a noisy manifold closed under the action of the special unitary group SU(2).

7/1/2024

❗

Manifold Fitting under Unbounded Noise

Zhigang Yao, Yuqing Xia

There has been an emerging trend in non-Euclidean statistical analysis of aiming to recover a low dimensional structure, namely a manifold, underlying the high dimensional data. Recovering the manifold requires the noise to be of certain concentration. Existing methods address this problem by constructing an approximated manifold based on the tangent space estimation at each sample point. Although theoretical convergence for these methods is guaranteed, either the samples are noiseless or the noise is bounded. However, if the noise is unbounded, which is a common scenario, the tangent space estimation at the noisy samples will be blurred. Fitting a manifold from the blurred tangent space might increase the inaccuracy. In this paper, we introduce a new manifold-fitting method, by which the output manifold is constructed by directly estimating the tangent spaces at the projected points on the underlying manifold, rather than at the sample points, to decrease the error caused by the noise. Assuming the noise is unbounded, our new method provides theoretical convergence in high probability, in terms of the upper bound of the distance between the estimated and underlying manifold. The smoothness of the estimated manifold is also evaluated by bounding the supremum of twice difference above. Numerical simulations are provided to validate our theoretical findings and demonstrate the advantages of our method over other relevant manifold fitting methods. Finally, our method is applied to real data examples.

6/11/2024

📊

Chernoff Bounds for Tensor Expanders on Riemannian Manifolds Using Graph Laplacian Approximation

Shih-Yu Chang

This paper addresses the advancement of probability tail bound analysis, a crucial statistical tool for assessing the probability of large deviations of random variables from their expected values. Traditional tail bounds, such as Markov's, Chebyshev's, and Chernoff bounds, have proven valuable across numerous scientific and engineering fields. However, as data complexity grows, there is a pressing need to extend tail bound estimation from scalar variables to high-dimensional random objects. Existing studies often rely on the assumption of independence among high-dimensional random objects, an assumption that may not always be valid. Building on the work of researchers like Garg et al. and Chang, who employed random walks to model high-dimensional ensembles, this study introduces a more generalized approach by exploring random walks over manifolds. To address the challenges of constructing an appropriate underlying graph for a manifold, we propose a novel method that enhances random walks on graphs approximating the manifold. This approach ensures spectral similarity between the original manifold and the approximated graph, including matching eigenvalues, eigenvectors, and eigenfunctions. Leveraging graph approximation technique proposed by Burago et al. for manifolds, we derive the tensor Chernoff bound and establish its range for random walks on a Riemannian manifold according to the underlying manifold's spectral characteristics.

8/22/2024