Black Hole Search by a Set of Scattered Agents in Dynamic Rings
0
🌀
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper examines the problem of searching for a "black hole" in a dynamic graph by a set of scattered agents.
- The black hole is a node that silently destroys any agent visiting it, modeling network failures like a crashed host or a virus.
- The researchers consider a dynamic 1-interval connected ring graph, where at most one edge can be missing per round.
- They show that the problem cannot be solved if agents can only communicate face-to-face, but it can be solved using movable pebbles as a communication mechanism.
- With three agents and pebbles, the black hole can be localized in O(n^2) moves, which is shown to be optimal.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers in this paper are studying a problem where a group of agents (like software programs or robots) are trying to find a "black hole" in a dynamic network. The black hole is a problematic node in the network that secretly destroys any agent that visits it, similar to a computer crashing or a virus erasing data.
The network they're looking at is a ring shape, where the connections between nodes (the "edges") can change over time, with at most one edge being missing in each round. The agents start from random locations on the ring and need to work together to find the black hole and map out the entire network.
The researchers first show that if the agents can only communicate by directly meeting each other, they cannot solve this problem no matter how many agents there are. However, if the agents are able to leave behind special markers (called "pebbles") on the nodes as a way to communicate, then a team of three agents can locate the black hole in a reasonable amount of time (a square of the size of the network).
The researchers also prove that this number of agents (three) and this time complexity (a square of the network size) are the best that can be achieved, even if the agents have access to more powerful communication tools. This is the first time this specific black hole search problem has been studied in a dynamic network environment with scattered agents.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the problem of searching for a "black hole" in a dynamic graph using a set of scattered agents. A black hole is a node in the graph that silently destroys any agent that visits it, modeling network failures like a crashed host or a virus. The researchers consider a dynamic 1-interval connected ring graph, where at most one edge can be missing per round.
They first show that the problem cannot be solved if the agents can only communicate using a face-to-face mechanism, for any constant-sized set of agents relative to the size n of the ring. To overcome this impossibility, the researchers equip the agents with movable pebbles that can be left on nodes as a form of communication.
With this pebble-based communication, the researchers demonstrate that three agents can localize the black hole in O(n^2) moves. They also prove that this number of agents and this time complexity are optimal - that is, any algorithm solving the problem with three agents requires Ω(n^2) moves, even with stronger communication mechanisms like a whiteboard on each node.
To the best of the authors' knowledge, this is the first paper examining the problem of black hole search in a dynamic environment with scattered agents.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a thorough and rigorous analysis of the black hole search problem in a dynamic ring network, carefully considering the constraints of the problem and the capabilities of the agents. The researchers' proofs of the impossibility result without pebbles and the optimality of the three-agent solution with pebbles are technically sound.
One potential limitation is the focus on a ring network topology, which may not reflect the full complexity of real-world dynamic networks. Extending this research to other graph structures, such as highly connected networks or bipartite graphs, could provide additional insights.
Additionally, the paper does not consider scenarios with multiple black holes or the possibility of agents failing or being unreliable. Incorporating these elements could make the problem more realistic and challenging, as seen in research on equilibrium-seeking search algorithms and distributed autonomous swarm formation.
Overall, this paper presents a valuable contribution to the understanding of black hole search in dynamic environments, and the techniques and insights developed could be relevant to a wider range of distributed computing and multi-agent coordination problems.
Conclusion
This paper investigates the challenging problem of searching for a "black hole" in a dynamic ring network using a team of scattered agents. The researchers show that the problem cannot be solved if agents can only communicate face-to-face, but it can be solved using movable pebbles as a communication mechanism. They demonstrate that three agents can localize the black hole in a tight O(n^2) time complexity, which is proven to be optimal.
This work provides important insights into the capabilities and limitations of distributed agents in dynamic environments, with potential applications in areas like distributed computing, network management, and multi-robot coordination. The techniques and findings could also inspire further research on more complex network topologies, failure scenarios, and communication models to advance the state of the art in this field.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌀
0
Black Hole Search by a Set of Scattered Agents in Dynamic Rings
Giuseppe Antonio Di Luna, Paola Flocchini, Giuseppe Prencipe, Nicola Santoro
In this paper we investigate the problem of searching for a black hole in a dynamic graph by a set of scattered agents (i.e., the agents start from arbitrary locations of the graph). The black hole is a node that silently destroys any agent visiting it. This kind of malicious node nicely models network failures such as a crashed host or a virus that erases the visiting agents. The black hole search problem is solved when at least one agent survives, and it has the entire map of the graph with the location of the black hole. We consider the case in which the underlining graph is a dynamic 1-interval connected ring: a ring graph in which at each round at most one edge can be missing. We first show that the problem cannot be solved if the agents can only communicate by using a face-to-face mechanism: this holds for any set of agents of constant size, with respect to the size $n$ of the ring. To circumvent this impossibility we consider agents equipped with movable pebbles that can be left on nodes as a form of communication with other agents. When pebbles are available, three agents can localize the black hole in $O(n^2)$ moves. We show that such a number of agents is optimal. We also show that the complexity is tight, that is $Omega(n^2)$ moves are required for any algorithm solving the problem with three agents, even with stronger communication mechanisms (e.g., a whiteboard on each node on which agents can write messages of unlimited size). To the best of our knowledge this is the first paper examining the problem of searching a black hole in a dynamic environment with scattered agents.
Read more4/24/2024
0
Black Hole Search in Dynamic Graphs
Tanvir Kaur, Ashish Saxena, Partha Sarathi Mandal, Kaushik Mondal
A black hole in a graph is a dangerous site that disposes any incoming agent into that node without leaving any trace of its existence. In the Black Hole Search (BHS) problem, the goal is for at least one agent to survive, locate the position of the black hole, and then terminate. This problem has been extensively studied for static graphs, where the edges do not disappear with time. In dynamic graphs, where the edges may disappear and reappear with time, the problem has only been studied for specific graphs such as rings and cactuses. In this work, we investigate the problem of BHS for general graphs with a much weaker model with respect to the one used for the cases of rings and cactus graphscite{bhattacharya_2023, Paola_2024}. We consider two cases: (a) where the adversary can remove at most one edge in each round, and (b) where the adversary can remove at most $f$ edges in each round. In both scenarios, we consider rooted configuration. In the case when the adversary can remove at most one edge from the graph, we provide an algorithm that uses 9 agents to solve the BHS problem in $O(m^2)$ time given that each node $v$ is equipped with $O(log delta_v)$ storage in the form of a whiteboard, where $m$ is the number of edges in $G$ and $delta_v$ is the degree of node $v$. We also prove that it is impossible for $2delta_{BH}$ many agents with $O(log n)$ memory to locate the black hole where $delta_{BH}$ is the degree of the black hole even if the nodes are equipped with whiteboards of $O(log delta_v)$ storage. In a scenario where the adversary can remove at most $f$ edges and the initial configuration is rooted, we present an algorithm that uses $6f$ agents to solve the BHS problem. We also prove that solving BHS using $2f+1$ agents starting from a rooted configuration on a general graph is impossible, even with unlimited node storage and infinite agent memory.
Read more5/29/2024
📉
0
Perpetual Exploration of a Ring in Presence of Byzantine Black Hole
Pritam Goswami, Adri Bhattacharya, Raja Das, Partha Sarathi Mandal
Perpetual exploration is a fundamental problem in the domain of mobile agents, where an agent needs to visit each node infinitely often. This issue has received lot of attention, mainly for ring topologies, presence of black holes adds more complexity. A black hole can destroy any incoming agent without any observable trace. In cite{BampasImprovedPeriodicDataRetrieval,KralovivcPeriodicDataRetrievalFirst}, the authors considered this problem in the context of textit{ Periodic data retrieval}. They introduced a variant of black hole called gray hole (where the adversary chooses whether to destroy an agent or let it pass) among others and showed that 4 asynchronous and co-located agents are essential to solve this problem (hence perpetual exploration) in presence of such a gray hole if each node of the ring has a whiteboard. This paper investigates the exploration of a ring in presence of a ``byzantine black hole''. In addition to the capabilities of a gray hole, in this variant, the adversary chooses whether to erase any previously stored information on that node. Previously, one particular initial scenario (i.e., agents are co-located) and one particular communication model (i.e., whiteboard) are investigated. Now, there can be other initial scenarios where all agents may not be co-located. Also, there are many weaker models of communications (i.e., Face-to-Face, Pebble) where this problem is yet to be investigated. The agents are synchronous. The main results focus on minimizing the agent number while ensuring that perpetual exploration is achieved even in presence of such a node under various communication models and starting positions. Further, we achieved a better upper and lower bound result (i.e., 3 agents) for this problem (where the malicious node is a generalized version of a gray hole), by trading-off scheduler capability, for co-located and in presence of a whiteboard.
Read more7/9/2024
🔍
0
Partial gathering of mobile agents in dynamic rings
Masahiro Shibata, Yuichi Sudo, Junya Nakamura, Yonghwan Kim
In this paper, we consider the partial gathering problem of mobile agents in synchronous dynamic bidirectional ring networks. When k agents are distributed in the network, the partial gathering problem requires, for a given positive integer g (= 8g - 3. These results mean that the partial gathering problem can be solved also in dynamic rings when k >= 2g + 1. In addition, agents require a total number of Omega(gn) moves to solve the partial (resp., total) gathering problem. Thus, when k >= 3g - 1, agents can solve the partial gathering problem with the asymptotically optimal total number of O(gn) moves.
Read more5/21/2024