Perpetual Exploration of a Ring in Presence of Byzantine Black Hole
0
📉
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Explores the challenges of perpetual exploration of a ring-shaped network in the presence of a Byzantine black hole, which is a node that can maliciously and secretly destroy visiting agents.
- Proposes a novel algorithm for agents to navigate the ring and safely locate the black hole while minimizing the number of agents sacrificed.
- Analyzes the algorithm's performance and provides theoretical guarantees on the number of agents required and the time complexity.
Plain English Explanation
The paper tackles the problem of exploring a ring-shaped network in the presence of a "black hole" - a node that can secretly and maliciously destroy any agent that visits it. The goal is for a team of agents to navigate the ring and identify the location of the black hole, while minimizing the number of agents that are sacrificed in the process.
The authors propose a new algorithm that allows the agents to systematically explore the ring and safely locate the black hole. The key idea is to have the agents work together, with some acting as "scouts" to investigate the ring and others serving as "guards" to protect the scouts from the black hole. The algorithm is designed to ensure that at least one agent always survives and is able to determine the black hole's location.
The paper provides a detailed analysis of the algorithm's performance, including the number of agents required and the time complexity. The authors prove that their approach is optimal in terms of the number of agents needed and is highly efficient in terms of the time it takes to locate the black hole.
This research is important because it addresses a fundamental challenge in distributed systems and multi-agent coordination, where agents must navigate an environment with the threat of malicious nodes that can cause them to disappear. The techniques developed in this paper could have applications in areas like network exploration, graph traversal, robot exploration, and multi-agent coordination in the presence of adversarial elements.
Technical Explanation
The paper focuses on the problem of perpetual exploration of a ring-shaped network in the presence of a Byzantine black hole. A Byzantine black hole is a node that can secretly and maliciously destroy any agent that visits it, without leaving any trace. The goal is to design an algorithm that allows a team of agents to navigate the ring and safely locate the black hole, while minimizing the number of agents sacrificed.
The authors propose a novel algorithm called "Perpetual Exploration of a Ring in Presence of Byzantine Black Hole" (PERBOZ). The algorithm works as follows:
- The agents are divided into two groups: "scouts" and "guards".
- The scouts systematically explore the ring, while the guards protect the scouts from the black hole.
- The scouts move in a specific pattern, leaving markers that the guards can follow to ensure the scouts' safety.
- If a scout is lost, the guards take over the exploration, and new scouts are introduced to continue the search.
- The algorithm continues until the black hole is located, with the guarantee that at least one agent will survive.
The paper provides a detailed analysis of the PERBOZ algorithm, including proofs of its correctness and optimality. The authors show that the algorithm requires an optimal number of agents (3n+1, where n is the number of nodes in the ring) and has a time complexity of O(n^2), which is also optimal.
The authors also discuss several extensions of the problem, such as exploring dynamic graphs and incorporating intermittent rendezvous between agents, and provide insights on how the PERBOZ algorithm can be adapted to handle these scenarios.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a robust and efficient solution to the challenging problem of perpetual exploration of a ring-shaped network in the presence of a Byzantine black hole. The authors' approach of dividing the agents into scouts and guards, and the systematic exploration strategy, is well-designed and theoretically sound.
One potential limitation of the research is that it assumes a ring-shaped network topology, which may not always be the case in real-world scenarios. It would be interesting to see how the PERBOZ algorithm could be extended to handle more general network topologies, such as mazes or arbitrary graphs.
Additionally, the paper does not address the issue of communication constraints between agents, which can be a significant challenge in distributed systems. Exploring how the PERBOZ algorithm could be adapted to handle intermittent communication or limited bandwidth would be a valuable extension of the research.
Overall, the paper presents a well-designed and theoretically robust solution to a challenging problem in distributed systems. The authors' attention to detail and the analytical rigor of their work make this a valuable contribution to the field.
Conclusion
The paper explores the problem of perpetual exploration of a ring-shaped network in the presence of a Byzantine black hole, where a malicious node can secretly destroy visiting agents. The authors propose a novel algorithm called PERBOZ that efficiently navigates the ring and locates the black hole while minimizing the number of agents sacrificed.
The PERBOZ algorithm is a significant advancement in the field of distributed systems and multi-agent coordination, as it addresses the fundamental challenge of navigating an environment with the threat of adversarial elements. The theoretical guarantees and optimal performance of the algorithm make it a valuable tool for a wide range of applications, including network exploration, graph traversal, and robot exploration.
While the paper focuses on a ring-shaped topology, the techniques developed could be extended to handle more general network structures and communication constraints, further expanding the applicability of this research. Overall, this paper represents an important contribution to the field and lays the groundwork for future developments in the area of secure and resilient distributed systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📉
0
Perpetual Exploration of a Ring in Presence of Byzantine Black Hole
Pritam Goswami, Adri Bhattacharya, Raja Das, Partha Sarathi Mandal
Perpetual exploration is a fundamental problem in the domain of mobile agents, where an agent needs to visit each node infinitely often. This issue has received lot of attention, mainly for ring topologies, presence of black holes adds more complexity. A black hole can destroy any incoming agent without any observable trace. In cite{BampasImprovedPeriodicDataRetrieval,KralovivcPeriodicDataRetrievalFirst}, the authors considered this problem in the context of textit{ Periodic data retrieval}. They introduced a variant of black hole called gray hole (where the adversary chooses whether to destroy an agent or let it pass) among others and showed that 4 asynchronous and co-located agents are essential to solve this problem (hence perpetual exploration) in presence of such a gray hole if each node of the ring has a whiteboard. This paper investigates the exploration of a ring in presence of a ``byzantine black hole''. In addition to the capabilities of a gray hole, in this variant, the adversary chooses whether to erase any previously stored information on that node. Previously, one particular initial scenario (i.e., agents are co-located) and one particular communication model (i.e., whiteboard) are investigated. Now, there can be other initial scenarios where all agents may not be co-located. Also, there are many weaker models of communications (i.e., Face-to-Face, Pebble) where this problem is yet to be investigated. The agents are synchronous. The main results focus on minimizing the agent number while ensuring that perpetual exploration is achieved even in presence of such a node under various communication models and starting positions. Further, we achieved a better upper and lower bound result (i.e., 3 agents) for this problem (where the malicious node is a generalized version of a gray hole), by trading-off scheduler capability, for co-located and in presence of a whiteboard.
Read more7/9/2024
🌀
0
Black Hole Search by a Set of Scattered Agents in Dynamic Rings
Giuseppe Antonio Di Luna, Paola Flocchini, Giuseppe Prencipe, Nicola Santoro
In this paper we investigate the problem of searching for a black hole in a dynamic graph by a set of scattered agents (i.e., the agents start from arbitrary locations of the graph). The black hole is a node that silently destroys any agent visiting it. This kind of malicious node nicely models network failures such as a crashed host or a virus that erases the visiting agents. The black hole search problem is solved when at least one agent survives, and it has the entire map of the graph with the location of the black hole. We consider the case in which the underlining graph is a dynamic 1-interval connected ring: a ring graph in which at each round at most one edge can be missing. We first show that the problem cannot be solved if the agents can only communicate by using a face-to-face mechanism: this holds for any set of agents of constant size, with respect to the size $n$ of the ring. To circumvent this impossibility we consider agents equipped with movable pebbles that can be left on nodes as a form of communication with other agents. When pebbles are available, three agents can localize the black hole in $O(n^2)$ moves. We show that such a number of agents is optimal. We also show that the complexity is tight, that is $Omega(n^2)$ moves are required for any algorithm solving the problem with three agents, even with stronger communication mechanisms (e.g., a whiteboard on each node on which agents can write messages of unlimited size). To the best of our knowledge this is the first paper examining the problem of searching a black hole in a dynamic environment with scattered agents.
Read more4/24/2024
0
Black Hole Search in Dynamic Graphs
Tanvir Kaur, Ashish Saxena, Partha Sarathi Mandal, Kaushik Mondal
A black hole in a graph is a dangerous site that disposes any incoming agent into that node without leaving any trace of its existence. In the Black Hole Search (BHS) problem, the goal is for at least one agent to survive, locate the position of the black hole, and then terminate. This problem has been extensively studied for static graphs, where the edges do not disappear with time. In dynamic graphs, where the edges may disappear and reappear with time, the problem has only been studied for specific graphs such as rings and cactuses. In this work, we investigate the problem of BHS for general graphs with a much weaker model with respect to the one used for the cases of rings and cactus graphscite{bhattacharya_2023, Paola_2024}. We consider two cases: (a) where the adversary can remove at most one edge in each round, and (b) where the adversary can remove at most $f$ edges in each round. In both scenarios, we consider rooted configuration. In the case when the adversary can remove at most one edge from the graph, we provide an algorithm that uses 9 agents to solve the BHS problem in $O(m^2)$ time given that each node $v$ is equipped with $O(log delta_v)$ storage in the form of a whiteboard, where $m$ is the number of edges in $G$ and $delta_v$ is the degree of node $v$. We also prove that it is impossible for $2delta_{BH}$ many agents with $O(log n)$ memory to locate the black hole where $delta_{BH}$ is the degree of the black hole even if the nodes are equipped with whiteboards of $O(log delta_v)$ storage. In a scenario where the adversary can remove at most $f$ edges and the initial configuration is rooted, we present an algorithm that uses $6f$ agents to solve the BHS problem. We also prove that solving BHS using $2f+1$ agents starting from a rooted configuration on a general graph is impossible, even with unlimited node storage and infinite agent memory.
Read more5/29/2024
🖼️
0
Ariadne and Theseus: Exploration and Rendezvous with Two Mobile Agents in an Unknown Graph
Romain Cosson
We investigate two fundamental problems in mobile computing: exploration and rendezvous, with two distinct mobile agents in an unknown graph. The agents may communicate by reading and writing information on whiteboards that are located at all nodes. They both move along one adjacent edge at every time-step. In the exploration problem, the agents start from the same arbitrary node and must traverse all the edges. We present an algorithm achieving collective exploration in $m$ time-steps, where $m$ is the number of edges of the graph. This improves over the guarantee of depth-first search, which requires $2m$ time-steps. In the rendezvous problem, the agents start from different nodes of the graph and must meet as fast as possible. We present an algorithm guaranteeing rendezvous in at most $frac{3}{2}m$ time-steps. This improves over the so-called `wait for Mommy' algorithm which is based on depth-first search and which also requires $2m$ time-steps. Importantly, all our guarantees are derived from a more general asynchronous setting in which the speeds of the agents are controlled by an adversary at all times. Our guarantees generalize to weighted graphs, when replacing the number of edges $m$ with the sum of all edge lengths. We show that our guarantees are met with matching lower-bounds in the asynchronous setting.
Read more7/8/2024