Causal structure learning with momentum: Sampling distributions over Markov Equivalence Classes of DAGs

Overview

• Researchers propose a new method called the "Causal Zig-Zag sampler" to infer the structure of Bayesian networks, represented as directed acyclic graphs (DAGs).
• The method targets a probability distribution over classes of observationally equivalent (Markov equivalent) DAGs, represented as completed partially directed acyclic graphs (CPDAGs).
• The Markov chain used in this method is non-reversible and includes a momentum variable, which improves mixing.
• The researchers provide an efficient implementation with new algorithms for key operations, improving upon the state-of-the-art run-time.

Plain English Explanation

Bayesian networks are a way of representing relationships between different variables in a system. These relationships can be shown as a directed acyclic graph (DAG), where the nodes represent variables and the arrows represent how they are connected.

However, sometimes there can be multiple DAGs that are "observationally equivalent" - they have the same statistical properties and cannot be distinguished from the observed data. The researchers wanted to find a way to efficiently sample from the set of all possible observationally equivalent DAGs.

They developed a new method called the "Causal Zig-Zag sampler" that uses a non-reversible Markov chain to explore this space of equivalent DAGs. The key innovation is the addition of a "momentum" variable, which helps the sampler move more efficiently between different equivalent DAGs.

The researchers also provide new algorithms to speed up the core operations required by their sampling method, such as listing, counting, and uniformly sampling the possible changes to the DAG structure. This allows their method to run much faster than previous approaches.

Technical Explanation

The researchers devised a non-reversible continuous time Markov chain, called the "Causal Zig-Zag sampler", that targets a probability distribution over classes of observationally equivalent (Markov equivalent) DAGs. These equivalence classes are represented as completed partially directed acyclic graphs (CPDAGs).

The non-reversible Markov chain relies on the operators used in Chickering's Greedy Equivalence Search (GES) and is endowed with a momentum variable, which empirically improves mixing significantly.

The possible target distributions include posterior distributions based on a prior over DAGs and a Markov equivalent likelihood. The researchers offer an efficient implementation where they develop new algorithms for listing, counting, uniformly sampling, and applying possible moves of the GES operators, all of which significantly improve upon the state-of-the-art run-time.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and efficient approach for sampling from the space of observationally equivalent Bayesian network structures. The addition of the momentum variable to the Markov chain is a clever idea that helps the sampler explore the space more effectively.

However, the paper does not provide a thorough theoretical analysis of the convergence properties of the Causal Zig-Zag sampler. While the empirical results demonstrate improved mixing compared to previous methods, a more rigorous mathematical treatment of the sampler's convergence would strengthen the claims.

Additionally, the paper focuses on the computational aspects of the problem and does not delve deep into the implications of this approach for causal discovery or causal reasoning. Further research is needed to understand how the sampled equivalence classes can be leveraged for downstream causal analysis tasks.

Conclusion

The Causal Zig-Zag sampler proposed in this paper is a significant advancement in the field of Bayesian network structure learning. By efficiently sampling from the space of observationally equivalent DAGs, it opens up new possibilities for understanding the causal relationships in complex systems. The researchers' novel algorithmic contributions also make this method practically feasible for real-world applications. While some theoretical questions remain, this work represents an important step towards more robust and scalable causal discovery techniques.