Change My Frame: Reframing in the Wild in r/ChangeMyView
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores the phenomenon of "reframing" in online discussions, particularly in the r/ChangeMyView subreddit.
- Reframing involves shifting the perspective or framing of an argument to change its meaning or impact.
- The researchers analyzed a large dataset of discussions from r/ChangeMyView to understand the patterns and dynamics of reframing in the wild.
Plain English Explanation
The paper examines how people change the way they look at or "frame" arguments in online discussions, particularly on the r/ChangeMyView subreddit. Reframing involves shifting the perspective or focus of an argument to alter its meaning or impact. For example, someone might reframe an argument about gun control from a public safety issue to one about individual rights. The researchers analyzed a large dataset of discussions from r/ChangeMyView to understand how this reframing process plays out in real-world online conversations.
Technical Explanation
The paper analyzes reframing in online discussions by focusing on the r/ChangeMyView subreddit. Reframing involves "shifting the perspective or framing of an argument to change its meaning or impact." The researchers built a dataset of over 1 million comments from r/ChangeMyView to study the patterns and dynamics of reframing in this online community. They used various computational techniques, such as sentiment analysis and frame detection, to identify instances of reframing and how they impacted the discussion.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides valuable insights into the role of reframing in online discussions, but it also has some limitations. The analysis is confined to a single online forum, r/ChangeMyView, which may not fully capture the diversity of reframing dynamics across the internet. Additionally, the automated methods used to detect reframing may miss more nuanced or contextual instances. Further research could expand the analysis to other platforms and explore more [advanced techniques for narrative analysis of reframing.
Conclusion
This paper offers a unique perspective on the role of reframing in online discussions, particularly in the context of the r/ChangeMyView subreddit. By analyzing a large dataset of real-world conversations, the researchers have shed light on how people shift the framing of arguments to change their meaning and impact. This work has implications for understanding and potentially guiding more constructive online deliberation, though further research is needed to fully capture the complexities of reframing in digital spaces.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Change My Frame: Reframing in the Wild in r/ChangeMyView
Arturo Mart'inez Peguero, Taro Watanabe
Recent work in reframing, within the scope of text style transfer, has so far made use of out-of-context, task-prompted utterances in order to produce neutralizing or optimistic reframes. Our work aims to generalize reframing based on the subreddit r/ChangeMyView (CMV). We build a dataset that leverages CMV's community's interactions and conventions to identify high-value, community-recognized utterances that produce changes of perspective. With this data, we widen the scope of the direction of reframing since the changes in perspective do not only occur in neutral or positive directions. We fine tune transformer-based models, make use of a modern LLM to refine our dataset, and explore challenges in the dataset creation and evaluation around this type of reframing.
Read more7/4/2024
0
Positive Text Reframing under Multi-strategy Optimization
Shutong Jia, Biwei Cao, Qingqing Gao, Jiuxin Cao, Bo Liu
Differing from sentiment transfer, positive reframing seeks to substitute negative perspectives with positive expressions while preserving the original meaning. With the emergence of pre-trained language models (PLMs), it is possible to achieve acceptable results by fine-tuning PLMs. Nevertheless, generating fluent, diverse and task-constrained reframing text remains a significant challenge. To tackle this issue, a textbf{m}ulti-textbf{s}trategy textbf{o}ptimization textbf{f}ramework (MSOF) is proposed in this paper. Starting from the objective of positive reframing, we first design positive sentiment reward and content preservation reward to encourage the model to transform the negative expressions of the original text while ensuring the integrity and consistency of the semantics. Then, different decoding optimization approaches are introduced to improve the quality of text generation. Finally, based on the modeling formula of positive reframing, we propose a multi-dimensional re-ranking method that further selects candidate sentences from three dimensions: strategy consistency, text similarity and fluency. Extensive experiments on two Seq2Seq PLMs, BART and T5, demonstrate our framework achieves significant improvements on unconstrained and controlled positive reframing tasks.
Read more7/30/2024
0
Promoting Constructive Deliberation: Reframing for Receptiveness
Gauri Kambhatla, Matthew Lease, Ashwin Rajadesingan
To promote constructive discussion of controversial topics online, we propose automatic reframing of disagreeing responses to signal receptiveness to a preceding comment. Drawing on research from psychology, communications, and linguistics, we identify six strategies for reframing. We automatically reframe replies to comments according to each strategy, using a Reddit dataset. Through human-centered experiments, we find that the replies generated with our framework are perceived to be significantly more receptive than the original replies and a generic receptiveness baseline. We illustrate how transforming receptiveness, a particular social science construct, into a computational framework, can make LLM generations more aligned with human perceptions. We analyze and discuss the implications of our results, and highlight how a tool based on our framework might be used for more teachable and creative content moderation.
Read more6/26/2024
🔎
0
Finding frames with BERT: A transformer-based approach to generic news frame detection
Vihang Jumle, Mykola Makhortykh, Maryna Sydorova, Victoria Vziatysheva
Framing is among the most extensively used concepts in the field of communication science. The availability of digital data offers new possibilities for studying how specific aspects of social reality are made more salient in online communication but also raises challenges related to the scaling of framing analysis and its adoption to new research areas (e.g. studying the impact of artificial intelligence-powered systems on representation of societally relevant issues). To address these challenges, we introduce a transformer-based approach for generic news frame detection in Anglophone online content. While doing so, we discuss the composition of the training and test datasets, the model architecture, and the validation of the approach and reflect on the possibilities and limitations of the automated detection of generic news frames.
Read more9/4/2024