Positive Text Reframing under Multi-strategy Optimization
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Investigates a new approach for "positive text reframing" - transforming negative text into more positive and constructive language.
- Introduces a multi-strategy optimization framework to jointly optimize multiple rewriting strategies.
- Evaluates the method on benchmark datasets and compares it to previous techniques.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a novel way to take negative or critical text and rewrite it in a more positive and constructive manner. The key idea is to use an optimization-based approach that can simultaneously apply multiple different rewriting strategies to achieve the best overall transformation.
For example, say the text reframing method was applied to a negative product review. Rather than just rephrasing the critique, the method would try to identify opportunities to highlight the positives, rephrase aspects in a more constructive way, and promote a more receptive mindset - all within a unified optimization framework.
The researchers evaluate this approach on benchmark datasets and compare it to previous text rewriting techniques. The results suggest this multi-strategy optimization can produce more nuanced and effective positive transformations compared to single-strategy methods. This has potential applications in areas like customer service, social media moderation, and mental health support.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel "positive text reframing" approach that uses a multi-strategy optimization framework. The key insight is that effective positive rewriting often requires applying a combination of different transformation strategies - e.g. highlighting positives, rephrasing negatives constructively, and promoting a receptive mindset.
To capture this, the authors formulate the rewriting task as a multi-objective optimization problem. The objective functions encode various rewriting strategies as separate terms, which are then jointly optimized to produce the final transformed text. This allows the method to balance tradeoffs between the different strategies and generate more nuanced positive rewrites.
Experiments on benchmark datasets show this multi-strategy approach outperforms previous single-strategy text rewriting techniques. The authors also provide detailed ablation studies to analyze the contributions of the different optimization terms. Overall, the results suggest this framework is a promising direction for developing more sophisticated positive text transformation capabilities.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for the value of a multi-strategy approach to positive text reframing. The key insight - that effective rewriting often requires applying a combination of complementary transformation strategies - seems well-justified and the proposed optimization framework provides a principled way to realize this.
That said, the evaluation is still relatively limited in scope. While the benchmark datasets provide a good starting point, it would be helpful to see the method applied to a wider range of real-world use cases, such as customer service interactions or online discussions. This could uncover additional challenges or tradeoffs that the current framework may not fully address.
Additionally, the paper does not delve into the potential biases or ethical considerations of automated text rewriting. There are valid concerns around maintaining fidelity to the original voice, avoiding manipulation, and ensuring fairness and inclusivity. The authors could have engaged with these issues more directly.
Overall, though, this work represents an important advance in positive text reframing capabilities. With further research and careful consideration of the societal implications, the multi-strategy optimization approach could lead to impactful applications in various domains.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel multi-strategy optimization framework for positive text reframing. By jointly optimizing multiple rewriting objectives, the method is able to generate more nuanced and effective positive transformations compared to previous single-strategy techniques.
The results demonstrate the value of this approach on benchmark datasets, and suggest promising application areas in customer service, social media moderation, and mental health support. While the evaluation is still limited, this work represents an important step forward in developing sophisticated text rewriting capabilities with real-world impact.
As the field continues to advance, it will be crucial to also consider the ethical implications of automated text transformation and ensure these technologies are developed and deployed responsibly. With thoughtful research and responsible implementation, the positive reframing approach outlined in this paper could contribute to more constructive and empowering online discourse.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Positive Text Reframing under Multi-strategy Optimization
Shutong Jia, Biwei Cao, Qingqing Gao, Jiuxin Cao, Bo Liu
Differing from sentiment transfer, positive reframing seeks to substitute negative perspectives with positive expressions while preserving the original meaning. With the emergence of pre-trained language models (PLMs), it is possible to achieve acceptable results by fine-tuning PLMs. Nevertheless, generating fluent, diverse and task-constrained reframing text remains a significant challenge. To tackle this issue, a textbf{m}ulti-textbf{s}trategy textbf{o}ptimization textbf{f}ramework (MSOF) is proposed in this paper. Starting from the objective of positive reframing, we first design positive sentiment reward and content preservation reward to encourage the model to transform the negative expressions of the original text while ensuring the integrity and consistency of the semantics. Then, different decoding optimization approaches are introduced to improve the quality of text generation. Finally, based on the modeling formula of positive reframing, we propose a multi-dimensional re-ranking method that further selects candidate sentences from three dimensions: strategy consistency, text similarity and fluency. Extensive experiments on two Seq2Seq PLMs, BART and T5, demonstrate our framework achieves significant improvements on unconstrained and controlled positive reframing tasks.
Read more7/30/2024
0
Change My Frame: Reframing in the Wild in r/ChangeMyView
Arturo Mart'inez Peguero, Taro Watanabe
Recent work in reframing, within the scope of text style transfer, has so far made use of out-of-context, task-prompted utterances in order to produce neutralizing or optimistic reframes. Our work aims to generalize reframing based on the subreddit r/ChangeMyView (CMV). We build a dataset that leverages CMV's community's interactions and conventions to identify high-value, community-recognized utterances that produce changes of perspective. With this data, we widen the scope of the direction of reframing since the changes in perspective do not only occur in neutral or positive directions. We fine tune transformer-based models, make use of a modern LLM to refine our dataset, and explore challenges in the dataset creation and evaluation around this type of reframing.
Read more7/4/2024
0
Detection and Positive Reconstruction of Cognitive Distortion sentences: Mandarin Dataset and Evaluation
Shuya Lin, Yuxiong Wang, Jonathan Dong, Shiguang Ni
This research introduces a Positive Reconstruction Framework based on positive psychology theory. Overcoming negative thoughts can be challenging, our objective is to address and reframe them through a positive reinterpretation. To tackle this challenge, a two-fold approach is necessary: identifying cognitive distortions and suggesting a positively reframed alternative while preserving the original thought's meaning. Recent studies have investigated the application of Natural Language Processing (NLP) models in English for each stage of this process. In this study, we emphasize the theoretical foundation for the Positive Reconstruction Framework, grounded in broaden-and-build theory. We provide a shared corpus containing 4001 instances for detecting cognitive distortions and 1900 instances for positive reconstruction in Mandarin. Leveraging recent NLP techniques, including transfer learning, fine-tuning pretrained networks, and prompt engineering, we demonstrate the effectiveness of automated tools for both tasks. In summary, our study contributes to multilingual positive reconstruction, highlighting the effectiveness of NLP in cognitive distortion detection and positive reconstruction.
Read more9/9/2024
0
Style Transfer with Multi-iteration Preference Optimization
Shuai Liu, Jonathan May
Numerous recent techniques for text style transfer characterize their approaches as variants of reinforcement learning and preference optimization. In this work, we consider the relationship between these approaches and a class of optimization approaches developed primarily for (non-neural) statistical machine translation, formerly known as `tuning'. Inspired by these techniques from the past, we improve upon established preference optimization approaches, incorporating multiple iterations of exploration and optimization, and choosing contrastive examples by following a `hope' vs `fear' sampling strategy. Cognizant of the difference between machine translation and style transfer, however, we further tailor our framework with a new pseudo-parallel generation method and a dynamic weighted reward aggregation method to tackle the lack of parallel data and the need for a multi-objective reward. We evaluate our model on two commonly used text style transfer datasets. Through automatic and human evaluation results we show the effectiveness and the superiority of our model compared to state-of-the-art baselines.
Read more7/30/2024