Characterizing and Classifying Developer Forum Posts with their Intentions
2312.14279
2
0
🚀
Abstract
With the rapid growth of the developer community, the amount of posts on online technical forums has been growing rapidly, which poses difficulties for users to filter useful posts and find important information. Tags provide a concise feature dimension for users to locate their interested posts and for search engines to index the most relevant posts according to the queries. However, most tags are only focused on the technical perspective (e.g., program language, platform, tool). In most cases, forum posts in online developer communities reveal the author's intentions to solve a problem, ask for advice, share information, etc. The modeling of the intentions of posts can provide an extra dimension to the current tag taxonomy. By referencing previous studies and learning from industrial perspectives, we create a refined taxonomy for the intentions of technical forum posts. Through manual labeling and analysis on a sampled post dataset extracted from online forums, we understand the relevance between the constitution of posts (code, error messages) and their intentions. Furthermore, inspired by our manual study, we design a pre-trained transformer-based model to automatically predict post intentions. The best variant of our intention prediction framework, which achieves a Micro F1-score of 0.589, Top 1-3 accuracy of 62.6% to 87.8%, and an average AUC of 0.787, outperforms the state-of-the-art baseline approach. Our characterization and automated classification of forum posts regarding their intentions may help forum maintainers or third-party tool developers improve the organization and retrieval of posts on technical forums. We have released our annotated dataset and codes in our supplementary material package.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The rapid growth of online technical forums has made it difficult for users to find relevant and important information.
- Tags help users locate posts of interest and search engines index relevant content, but they often focus only on technical aspects.
- By analyzing the intentions behind forum posts (e.g., problem-solving, advice-seeking, information-sharing), an additional dimension can be added to tag taxonomies.
- The researchers created a refined taxonomy of post intentions and developed a transformer-based model to automatically predict post intentions, outperforming state-of-the-art baselines.
Plain English Explanation
As the number of online communities for developers has grown, the amount of content posted on these forums has increased dramatically. This makes it challenging for users to sift through all the information and find the most useful and relevant posts.
Tags are often used to help users find the posts they're interested in and to help search engines index the most relevant content based on a user's query. However, most tags focus only on the technical aspects of the posts, such as the programming language or tool being used.
In this research, the authors recognized that forum posts often reveal the author's underlying intention, such as trying to solve a problem, asking for advice, or sharing information. By understanding these intentions, an additional layer of context can be added to the existing tag system, making it easier for users to find the content they need.
The researchers first created a refined taxonomy of post intentions by drawing on previous studies and industry perspectives. They then manually analyzed a sample of forum posts to understand how the content of the posts (e.g., code snippets, error messages) relates to the author's intentions.
Inspired by this manual analysis, the researchers developed a transformer-based machine learning model that can automatically predict the intentions behind forum posts. This model outperformed state-of-the-art approaches, demonstrating the value of understanding post intentions in addition to the technical details.
By characterizing and automatically classifying forum posts based on their intentions, the researchers believe this work could help forum administrators and tool developers improve the organization and retrieval of content on technical forums. The annotated dataset and code have been made publicly available for further research and development.
Technical Explanation
The researchers first created a refined taxonomy of post intentions by drawing on previous studies and industry perspectives. This taxonomy includes categories such as problem-solving, advice-seeking, information-sharing, and tool/platform discussion.
They then manually analyzed a sample of forum posts from online developer communities, looking at the content of the posts (e.g., code snippets, error messages) and how it related to the author's underlying intentions. This manual analysis provided insights that informed the development of an automated intention prediction model.
The researchers designed a pre-trained transformer-based model to automatically classify forum posts according to the intention taxonomy. This model takes the full text of a post as input and outputs a probability distribution across the intention categories.
The best variant of the intention prediction model achieved a Micro F1-score of 0.589, Top 1-3 accuracy of 62.6% to 87.8%, and an average AUC of 0.787. This outperformed the state-of-the-art baseline approach, demonstrating the value of the intention-based taxonomy and the effectiveness of the transformer-based architecture.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge several limitations of their work. First, the manual labeling of post intentions was conducted on a relatively small sample of posts, which may not capture the full diversity of intentions present in online forums. Expanding the annotated dataset could help improve the robustness of the intention taxonomy and the predictive model.
Additionally, the researchers note that their intention prediction model does not currently account for the context of a post within a larger conversation thread. Incorporating thread-level information could potentially improve the model's understanding of the author's intentions.
The researchers also suggest that incorporating other signals, such as user profiles or platform-specific metadata, could further enhance the intention prediction capabilities. Exploring these avenues for model improvement could be fruitful areas for future research.
While the researchers have made their annotated dataset and code publicly available, the generalizability of their findings to other online forums or developer communities remains to be seen. Evaluating the intention prediction model on a broader range of platforms could provide valuable insights into the broader applicability of this approach.
Conclusion
This research presents a novel approach to understanding and automatically predicting the intentions behind forum posts in online developer communities. By creating a refined taxonomy of post intentions and developing a transformer-based predictive model, the researchers have demonstrated the potential to enhance the organization and retrieval of technical content on forums.
The intention-based classification of posts could enable more effective content filtering and recommendation systems, helping users quickly find the information they need. Additionally, this work could inform the design of better tagging and search functionalities for technical forums, ultimately improving the overall user experience.
The publicly released dataset and code provide a valuable resource for further research and development in this area. As online communities continue to grow, the ability to understand and leverage the underlying intentions behind user-generated content will become increasingly important for improving information access and knowledge sharing.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
The Unappreciated Role of Intent in Algorithmic Moderation of Social Media Content
Xinyu Wang, Sai Koneru, Pranav Narayanan Venkit, Brett Frischmann, Sarah Rajtmajer
0
0
As social media has become a predominant mode of communication globally, the rise of abusive content threatens to undermine civil discourse. Recognizing the critical nature of this issue, a significant body of research has been dedicated to developing language models that can detect various types of online abuse, e.g., hate speech, cyberbullying. However, there exists a notable disconnect between platform policies, which often consider the author's intention as a criterion for content moderation, and the current capabilities of detection models, which typically lack efforts to capture intent. This paper examines the role of intent in content moderation systems. We review state of the art detection models and benchmark training datasets for online abuse to assess their awareness and ability to capture intent. We propose strategic changes to the design and development of automated detection and moderation systems to improve alignment with ethical and policy conceptualizations of abuse.
5/21/2024
IntentionQA: A Benchmark for Evaluating Purchase Intention Comprehension Abilities of Language Models in E-commerce
Wenxuan Ding, Weiqi Wang, Sze Heng Douglas Kwok, Minghao Liu, Tianqing Fang, Jiaxin Bai, Junxian He, Yangqiu Song
0
0
Enhancing Language Models' (LMs) ability to understand purchase intentions in E-commerce scenarios is crucial for their effective assistance in various downstream tasks. However, previous approaches that distill intentions from LMs often fail to generate meaningful and human-centric intentions applicable in real-world E-commerce contexts. This raises concerns about the true comprehension and utilization of purchase intentions by LMs. In this paper, we present IntentionQA, a double-task multiple-choice question answering benchmark to evaluate LMs' comprehension of purchase intentions in E-commerce. Specifically, LMs are tasked to infer intentions based on purchased products and utilize them to predict additional purchases. IntentionQA consists of 4,360 carefully curated problems across three difficulty levels, constructed using an automated pipeline to ensure scalability on large E-commerce platforms. Human evaluations demonstrate the high quality and low false-negative rate of our benchmark. Extensive experiments across 19 language models show that they still struggle with certain scenarios, such as understanding products and intentions accurately, jointly reasoning with products and intentions, and more, in which they fall far behind human performances. Our code and data are publicly available at https://github.com/HKUST-KnowComp/IntentionQA.
6/17/2024
💬
Using Large Language Models to Generate, Validate, and Apply User Intent Taxonomies
Chirag Shah, Ryen W. White, Reid Andersen, Georg Buscher, Scott Counts, Sarkar Snigdha Sarathi Das, Ali Montazer, Sathish Manivannan, Jennifer Neville, Xiaochuan Ni, Nagu Rangan, Tara Safavi, Siddharth Suri, Mengting Wan, Leijie Wang, Longqi Yang
0
0
Log data can reveal valuable information about how users interact with Web search services, what they want, and how satisfied they are. However, analyzing user intents in log data is not easy, especially for emerging forms of Web search such as AI-driven chat. To understand user intents from log data, we need a way to label them with meaningful categories that capture their diversity and dynamics. Existing methods rely on manual or machine-learned labeling, which are either expensive or inflexible for large and dynamic datasets. We propose a novel solution using large language models (LLMs), which can generate rich and relevant concepts, descriptions, and examples for user intents. However, using LLMs to generate a user intent taxonomy and apply it for log analysis can be problematic for two main reasons: (1) such a taxonomy is not externally validated; and (2) there may be an undesirable feedback loop. To address this, we propose a new methodology with human experts and assessors to verify the quality of the LLM-generated taxonomy. We also present an end-to-end pipeline that uses an LLM with human-in-the-loop to produce, refine, and apply labels for user intent analysis in log data. We demonstrate its effectiveness by uncovering new insights into user intents from search and chat logs from the Microsoft Bing commercial search engine. The proposed work's novelty stems from the method for generating purpose-driven user intent taxonomies with strong validation. This method not only helps remove methodological and practical bottlenecks from intent-focused research, but also provides a new framework for generating, validating, and applying other kinds of taxonomies in a scalable and adaptable way with reasonable human effort.
5/13/2024
Inferring Discussion Topics about Exploitation of Vulnerabilities from Underground Hacking Forums
Felipe Moreno-Vera
0
0
The increasing sophistication of cyber threats necessitates proactive measures to identify vulnerabilities and potential exploits. Underground hacking forums serve as breeding grounds for the exchange of hacking techniques and discussions related to exploitation. In this research, we propose an innovative approach using topic modeling to analyze and uncover key themes in vulnerabilities discussed within these forums. The objective of our study is to develop a machine learning-based model that can automatically detect and classify vulnerability-related discussions in underground hacking forums. By monitoring and analyzing the content of these forums, we aim to identify emerging vulnerabilities, exploit techniques, and potential threat actors. To achieve this, we collect a large-scale dataset consisting of posts and threads from multiple underground forums. We preprocess and clean the data to ensure accuracy and reliability. Leveraging topic modeling techniques, specifically Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA), we uncover latent topics and their associated keywords within the dataset. This enables us to identify recurring themes and prevalent discussions related to vulnerabilities, exploits, and potential targets.
5/9/2024