Coarse-to-Fine Concept Bottleneck Models
2310.02116
0
0
🌿
Abstract
Deep learning algorithms have recently gained significant attention due to their impressive performance. However, their high complexity and un-interpretable mode of operation hinders their confident deployment in real-world safety-critical tasks. This work targets ante hoc interpretability, and specifically Concept Bottleneck Models (CBMs). Our goal is to design a framework that admits a highly interpretable decision making process with respect to human understandable concepts, on two levels of granularity. To this end, we propose a novel two-level concept discovery formulation leveraging: (i) recent advances in vision-language models, and (ii) an innovative formulation for coarse-to-fine concept selection via data-driven and sparsity-inducing Bayesian arguments. Within this framework, concept information does not solely rely on the similarity between the whole image and general unstructured concepts; instead, we introduce the notion of concept hierarchy to uncover and exploit more granular concept information residing in patch-specific regions of the image scene. As we experimentally show, the proposed construction not only outperforms recent CBM approaches, but also yields a principled framework towards interpetability.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Deep learning algorithms have become increasingly popular due to their impressive performance
- However, their high complexity and opaque decision-making process hinders their deployment in safety-critical real-world applications
- This work focuses on ante hoc interpretability and Concept Bottleneck Models (CBMs)
- The goal is to design a framework that provides a highly interpretable decision-making process based on human-understandable concepts at different levels of granularity
Plain English Explanation
Deep learning models have become incredibly powerful, but they can also be very complex and difficult to understand. This makes it hard to trust them in important real-world applications where safety and reliability are critical, like self-driving cars or medical diagnosis.
The researchers in this study wanted to tackle this problem by creating a new type of deep learning model that is more interpretable and transparent. Instead of just outputting a final prediction, their model would explain its decision-making process in terms of high-level "concepts" that humans can understand.
The key idea is to have the model learn to identify these concepts, not just from the overall image, but by looking at specific regions or patches within the image. This gives the model a more nuanced understanding of the scene, allowing it to make more granular and interpretable decisions.
By leveraging recent advances in vision-language models and using a novel Bayesian approach, the researchers were able to create a framework that outperforms other interpretable models while providing a principled way to uncover and utilize these important concept-level insights.
Technical Explanation
The researchers propose a novel two-level concept discovery framework that combines:
- Recent advancements in vision-language models to extract meaningful concept information from images
- An innovative Bayesian formulation for coarse-to-fine concept selection that leverages data-driven and sparsity-inducing principles
Unlike previous Concept Bottleneck Models, the proposed framework does not solely rely on the similarity between the whole image and general unstructured concepts. Instead, it introduces the notion of a concept hierarchy to uncover and exploit more granular concept information residing in patch-specific regions of the image scene.
The experimental results show that this approach not only outperforms recent CBM methods, but also provides a principled framework for achieving interpretability in deep learning models.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to improving the interpretability of deep learning models, but there are a few potential limitations and areas for further research:
- The concept discovery process relies on vision-language models, which may introduce biases or errors from the underlying language data. Exploring alternative concept extraction methods could be beneficial.
- The Bayesian formulation for concept selection, while principled, may be computationally intensive and require careful tuning of hyperparameters. Investigating more efficient optimization strategies could make the framework more scalable.
- The experiments focus on image classification tasks, but the applicability of the approach to other domains, such as natural language processing or time series analysis, is not yet clear. Evaluating the framework on a broader range of tasks would be valuable.
Overall, the research represents an important step towards bridging the gap between the powerful but opaque nature of deep learning and the need for interpretable, trustworthy AI systems in safety-critical applications.
Conclusion
This study proposes a novel framework for Concept Bottleneck Models that aims to provide a highly interpretable decision-making process. By leveraging advancements in vision-language models and introducing a Bayesian approach for coarse-to-fine concept selection, the researchers have developed a principled way to uncover and utilize granular concept-level information in deep learning models.
The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of this approach, which outperforms recent CBM methods and offers a promising path towards interpretable AI systems. While there are some potential limitations, this research represents an important step forward in addressing the interpretability challenges that have hindered the widespread adoption of deep learning in safety-critical real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Stochastic Concept Bottleneck Models
Moritz Vandenhirtz, Sonia Laguna, Riv{c}ards Marcinkeviv{c}s, Julia E. Vogt
0
0
Concept Bottleneck Models (CBMs) have emerged as a promising interpretable method whose final prediction is based on intermediate, human-understandable concepts rather than the raw input. Through time-consuming manual interventions, a user can correct wrongly predicted concept values to enhance the model's downstream performance. We propose Stochastic Concept Bottleneck Models (SCBMs), a novel approach that models concept dependencies. In SCBMs, a single-concept intervention affects all correlated concepts, thereby improving intervention effectiveness. Unlike previous approaches that model the concept relations via an autoregressive structure, we introduce an explicit, distributional parameterization that allows SCBMs to retain the CBMs' efficient training and inference procedure. Additionally, we leverage the parameterization to derive an effective intervention strategy based on the confidence region. We show empirically on synthetic tabular and natural image datasets that our approach improves intervention effectiveness significantly. Notably, we showcase the versatility and usability of SCBMs by examining a setting with CLIP-inferred concepts, alleviating the need for manual concept annotations.
6/28/2024
AnyCBMs: How to Turn Any Black Box into a Concept Bottleneck Model
Gabriele Dominici, Pietro Barbiero, Francesco Giannini, Martin Gjoreski, Marc Langhenirich
0
0
Interpretable deep learning aims at developing neural architectures whose decision-making processes could be understood by their users. Among these techniqes, Concept Bottleneck Models enhance the interpretability of neural networks by integrating a layer of human-understandable concepts. These models, however, necessitate training a new model from the beginning, consuming significant resources and failing to utilize already trained large models. To address this issue, we introduce AnyCBM, a method that transforms any existing trained model into a Concept Bottleneck Model with minimal impact on computational resources. We provide both theoretical and experimental insights showing the effectiveness of AnyCBMs in terms of classification performances and effectivenss of concept-based interventions on downstream tasks.
5/28/2024
Incremental Residual Concept Bottleneck Models
Chenming Shang, Shiji Zhou, Yujiu Yang, Hengyuan Zhang, Xinzhe Ni, Yuwang Wang
0
0
Concept Bottleneck Models (CBMs) map the black-box visual representations extracted by deep neural networks onto a set of interpretable concepts and use the concepts to make predictions, enhancing the transparency of the decision-making process. Multimodal pre-trained models can match visual representations with textual concept embeddings, allowing for obtaining the interpretable concept bottleneck without the expertise concept annotations. Recent research has focused on the concept bank establishment and the high-quality concept selection. However, it is challenging to construct a comprehensive concept bank through humans or large language models, which severely limits the performance of CBMs. In this work, we propose the Incremental Residual Concept Bottleneck Model (Res-CBM) to address the challenge of concept completeness. Specifically, the residual concept bottleneck model employs a set of optimizable vectors to complete missing concepts, then the incremental concept discovery module converts the complemented vectors with unclear meanings into potential concepts in the candidate concept bank. Our approach can be applied to any user-defined concept bank, as a post-hoc processing method to enhance the performance of any CBMs. Furthermore, to measure the descriptive efficiency of CBMs, the Concept Utilization Efficiency (CUE) metric is proposed. Experiments show that the Res-CBM outperforms the current state-of-the-art methods in terms of both accuracy and efficiency and achieves comparable performance to black-box models across multiple datasets.
4/16/2024
🔄
Learning to Intervene on Concept Bottlenecks
David Steinmann, Wolfgang Stammer, Felix Friedrich, Kristian Kersting
0
0
While deep learning models often lack interpretability, concept bottleneck models (CBMs) provide inherent explanations via their concept representations. Moreover, they allow users to perform interventional interactions on these concepts by updating the concept values and thus correcting the predictive output of the model. Up to this point, these interventions were typically applied to the model just once and then discarded. To rectify this, we present concept bottleneck memory models (CB2Ms), which keep a memory of past interventions. Specifically, CB2Ms leverage a two-fold memory to generalize interventions to appropriate novel situations, enabling the model to identify errors and reapply previous interventions. This way, a CB2M learns to automatically improve model performance from a few initially obtained interventions. If no prior human interventions are available, a CB2M can detect potential mistakes of the CBM bottleneck and request targeted interventions. Our experimental evaluations on challenging scenarios like handling distribution shifts and confounded data demonstrate that CB2Ms are able to successfully generalize interventions to unseen data and can indeed identify wrongly inferred concepts. Hence, CB2Ms are a valuable tool for users to provide interactive feedback on CBMs, by guiding a user's interaction and requiring fewer interventions.
6/5/2024