Collective Innovation in Groups of Large Language Models

Read original: arXiv:2407.05377 - Published 7/9/2024 by Eleni Nisioti, Sebastian Risi, Ida Momennejad, Pierre-Yves Oudeyer, Cl'ement Moulin-Frier
Total Score

0

Collective Innovation in Groups of Large Language Models

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • Presents a collective innovation test-bed for large language models (LLMs)
  • Explores how LLMs can be used to enhance human creativity and diversity
  • Investigates mechanisms for organizing and coordinating the collective intelligence of LLMs

Plain English Explanation

This paper explores how large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3 could be used to enhance human creativity and diversity. The researchers propose a "collective innovation test-bed" - a framework for organizing and coordinating the collective intelligence of multiple LLMs to tackle complex problems.

The key idea is that by having LLMs collaborate, they could generate more diverse and creative solutions than a single model working alone. The paper investigates different mechanisms for organizing LLM collectives, such as iterated learning and social identity biases. The goal is to harness the divergent creativity of these language models in service of human innovation and problem-solving.

Technical Explanation

The paper outlines a "collective innovation test-bed" framework for organizing and coordinating multiple LLMs to tackle complex problems. The researchers investigate different mechanisms for structuring LLM collectives, such as:

The paper also discusses potential architectures for these LLM collectives, such as centralized versus decentralized coordination, and the trade-offs involved. Overall, the goal is to evolve AI collectives that can enhance human creativity and problem-solving.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a compelling vision for how LLMs could be leveraged to enhance human innovation and diversity. However, it also acknowledges several caveats and areas for further research:

  • The specific mechanisms for structuring and coordinating LLM collectives are still largely theoretical and would require extensive empirical validation.
  • There are potential risks and ethical concerns around the use of LLMs, such as the spread of misinformation or the perpetuation of harmful biases, that would need to be carefully addressed.
  • The long-term implications of tightly integrating LLMs into human problem-solving and decision-making processes are not fully understood and warrant further exploration.

Overall, the paper offers an intriguing glimpse into a future where the collective intelligence of LLMs could be harnessed to augment and enhance human capabilities. However, significant further research and real-world testing would be needed to turn this vision into a practical reality.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel framework for leveraging the collective intelligence of large language models (LLMs) to enhance human creativity and problem-solving. By exploring mechanisms for organizing and coordinating multiple LLMs, the researchers aim to harness the divergent creativity of these models to tackle complex challenges.

While the ideas presented are still largely theoretical, the paper offers an exciting glimpse into a future where AI collectives could work alongside humans to drive innovation and tackle the world's most pressing problems. As the field of AI continues to evolve, further research and real-world experimentation in this area could have profound implications for the future of human-AI collaboration.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Collective Innovation in Groups of Large Language Models
Total Score

0

Collective Innovation in Groups of Large Language Models

Eleni Nisioti, Sebastian Risi, Ida Momennejad, Pierre-Yves Oudeyer, Cl'ement Moulin-Frier

Human culture relies on collective innovation: our ability to continuously explore how existing elements in our environment can be combined to create new ones. Language is hypothesized to play a key role in human culture, driving individual cognitive capacities and shaping communication. Yet the majority of models of collective innovation assign no cognitive capacities or language abilities to agents. Here, we contribute a computational study of collective innovation where agents are Large Language Models (LLMs) that play Little Alchemy 2, a creative video game originally developed for humans that, as we argue, captures useful aspects of innovation landscapes not present in previous test-beds. We, first, study an LLM in isolation and discover that it exhibits both useful skills and crucial limitations. We, then, study groups of LLMs that share information related to their behaviour and focus on the effect of social connectivity on collective performance. In agreement with previous human and computational studies, we observe that groups with dynamic connectivity out-compete fully-connected groups. Our work reveals opportunities and challenges for future studies of collective innovation that are becoming increasingly relevant as Generative Artificial Intelligence algorithms and humans innovate alongside each other.

Read more

7/9/2024

💬

Total Score

0

Organizing a Society of Language Models: Structures and Mechanisms for Enhanced Collective Intelligence

Silvan Ferreira, Ivanovitch Silva, Allan Martins

Recent developments in Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly expanded their applications across various domains. However, the effectiveness of LLMs is often constrained when operating individually in complex environments. This paper introduces a transformative approach by organizing LLMs into community-based structures, aimed at enhancing their collective intelligence and problem-solving capabilities. We investigate different organizational models-hierarchical, flat, dynamic, and federated-each presenting unique benefits and challenges for collaborative AI systems. Within these structured communities, LLMs are designed to specialize in distinct cognitive tasks, employ advanced interaction mechanisms such as direct communication, voting systems, and market-based approaches, and dynamically adjust their governance structures to meet changing demands. The implementation of such communities holds substantial promise for improve problem-solving capabilities in AI, prompting an in-depth examination of their ethical considerations, management strategies, and scalability potential. This position paper seeks to lay the groundwork for future research, advocating a paradigm shift from isolated to synergistic operational frameworks in AI research and application.

Read more

5/8/2024

💬

Total Score

0

Divergent Creativity in Humans and Large Language Models

Antoine Bellemare-Pepin (CoCo Lab, Psychology department, Universit'e de Montr'eal, Montreal, QC, Canada, Music department, Concordia University, Montreal, QC, Canada), Franc{c}ois Lespinasse (Sociology and Anthropology department, Concordia University, Montreal, QC, Canada), Philipp Tholke (CoCo Lab, Psychology department, Universit'e de Montr'eal, Montreal, QC, Canada), Yann Harel (CoCo Lab, Psychology department, Universit'e de Montr'eal, Montreal, QC, Canada), Kory Mathewson (Mila), Jay A. Olson (Department of Psychology, University of Toronto Mississauga, Mississauga, ON, Canada), Yoshua Bengio (Mila, Department of Computer Science and Operations Research, Universit'e de Montr'eal, Montreal, QC, Canada), Karim Jerbi (CoCo Lab, Psychology department, Universit'e de Montr'eal, Montreal, QC, Canada, UNIQUE Center)

The recent surge in the capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) has led to claims that they are approaching a level of creativity akin to human capabilities. This idea has sparked a blend of excitement and apprehension. However, a critical piece that has been missing in this discourse is a systematic evaluation of LLM creativity, particularly in comparison to human divergent thinking. To bridge this gap, we leverage recent advances in creativity science to build a framework for in-depth analysis of divergent creativity in both state-of-the-art LLMs and a substantial dataset of 100,000 humans. We found evidence suggesting that LLMs can indeed surpass human capabilities in specific creative tasks such as divergent association and creative writing. Our quantitative benchmarking framework opens up new paths for the development of more creative LLMs, but it also encourages more granular inquiries into the distinctive elements that constitute human inventive thought processes, compared to those that can be artificially generated.

Read more

5/24/2024

Coalitions of Large Language Models Increase the Robustness of AI Agents
Total Score

0

Coalitions of Large Language Models Increase the Robustness of AI Agents

Prattyush Mangal, Carol Mak, Theo Kanakis, Timothy Donovan, Dave Braines, Edward Pyzer-Knapp

The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) have fundamentally altered the way we interact with digital systems and have led to the pursuit of LLM powered AI agents to assist in daily workflows. LLMs, whilst powerful and capable of demonstrating some emergent properties, are not logical reasoners and often struggle to perform well at all sub-tasks carried out by an AI agent to plan and execute a workflow. While existing studies tackle this lack of proficiency by generalised pretraining at a huge scale or by specialised fine-tuning for tool use, we assess if a system comprising of a coalition of pretrained LLMs, each exhibiting specialised performance at individual sub-tasks, can match the performance of single model agents. The coalition of models approach showcases its potential for building robustness and reducing the operational costs of these AI agents by leveraging traits exhibited by specific models. Our findings demonstrate that fine-tuning can be mitigated by considering a coalition of pretrained models and believe that this approach can be applied to other non-agentic systems which utilise LLMs.

Read more

8/6/2024