A Comparative Study of Variational Autoencoders, Normalizing Flows, and Score-based Diffusion Models for Electrical Impedance Tomography
2310.15831
0
0
🎲
Abstract
Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) is a widely employed imaging technique in industrial inspection, geophysical prospecting, and medical imaging. However, the inherent nonlinearity and ill-posedness of EIT image reconstruction present challenges for classical regularization techniques, such as the critical selection of regularization terms and the lack of prior knowledge. Deep generative models (DGMs) have been shown to play a crucial role in learning implicit regularizers and prior knowledge. This study aims to investigate the potential of three DGMs-variational autoencoder networks, normalizing flow, and score-based diffusion model-to learn implicit regularizers in learning-based EIT imaging. We first introduce background information on EIT imaging and its inverse problem formulation. Next, we propose three algorithms for performing EIT inverse problems based on corresponding DGMs. Finally, we present numerical and visual experiments, which reveal that (1) no single method consistently outperforms the others across all settings, and (2) when reconstructing an object with 2 anomalies using a well-trained model based on a training dataset containing 4 anomalies, the conditional normalizing flow model (CNF) exhibits the best generalization in low-level noise, while the conditional score-based diffusion model (CSD*) demonstrates the best generalization in high-level noise settings. We hope our preliminary efforts will encourage other researchers to assess their DGMs in EIT and other nonlinear inverse problems.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) is a widely used imaging technique in various fields, including industrial inspection, geophysical prospecting, and medical imaging.
- EIT image reconstruction faces challenges due to its inherent nonlinearity and ill-posedness, which can be problematic for classical regularization techniques.
- Deep generative models (DGMs) have shown promise in learning implicit regularizers and prior knowledge to address these challenges.
- This study investigates the potential of three DGMs - variational autoencoder networks, normalizing flow, and score-based diffusion models - for learning implicit regularizers in EIT imaging.
Plain English Explanation
Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) is a type of imaging technique that is used in many different industries and medical applications. However, the way EIT works can be complex and tricky to get right, which can make it difficult to produce clear, accurate images.
This study looks at how three different types of deep learning models, called deep generative models, could help address some of these challenges. Deep generative models are a kind of artificial intelligence that can learn patterns and relationships in data, and then use that knowledge to generate new, realistic-looking data.
The researchers tested three different deep generative models to see how well they could learn the implicit "rules" or "knowledge" needed to produce high-quality EIT images, even when the underlying data is messy or incomplete. They found that each model had its own strengths and weaknesses, and that the best approach might depend on the specific situation and the level of noise or uncertainty in the data.
Overall, the study suggests that deep generative models could be a powerful tool for improving EIT imaging, by helping to overcome some of the inherent challenges in this technique. By learning the underlying patterns and regularities in the data, these models could potentially generate more accurate and reliable images, which could have important applications in fields like medical diagnosis, industrial quality control, and environmental monitoring.
Technical Explanation
The study introduces the inverse problem formulation of EIT imaging, which is inherently nonlinear and ill-posed, posing challenges for classical regularization techniques. To address these challenges, the researchers investigate the potential of three deep generative models (DGMs) - variational autoencoder networks, normalizing flow, and score-based diffusion models - to learn implicit regularizers for EIT image reconstruction.
The study first introduces the background and formulation of the EIT inverse problem. It then proposes three algorithms for performing the EIT inverse problem using the corresponding DGMs. Finally, the researchers present numerical and visual experiments that reveal:
- No single method consistently outperforms the others across all settings.
- When reconstructing an object with 2 anomalies using a well-trained model based on a training dataset containing 4 anomalies, the conditional normalizing flow model (CNF) exhibits the best generalization in low-level noise, while the conditional score-based diffusion model (CSD*) demonstrates the best generalization in high-level noise settings.
The study's findings encourage other researchers to assess the potential of DGMs in EIT and other nonlinear inverse problems.
Critical Analysis
The study presents a thorough investigation of the use of deep generative models for addressing the challenges in EIT image reconstruction. The researchers acknowledge that no single method consistently outperforms the others, which highlights the importance of considering the specific problem context and data characteristics when selecting the appropriate DGM approach.
One potential limitation of the study is that it only considers three DGM architectures, and it would be valuable to explore the performance of other DGM variants or hybrid models that could potentially combine the strengths of multiple approaches. Additionally, the study focuses on numerical and visual experiments, and it would be interesting to see how the different DGM-based methods perform in real-world EIT applications, where the data may be even more complex and noisy.
Furthermore, the study does not delve into the interpretability or explainability of the learned regularizers, which could be an important consideration for certain applications where the underlying principles need to be understood and validated. Exploring ways to make the DGM-based approaches more transparent and accessible to domain experts could be a fruitful area for future research.
Overall, this study provides a solid foundation for understanding the potential of deep generative models in addressing the challenges of EIT image reconstruction, and it encourages further exploration and refinement of these techniques in the context of nonlinear inverse problems.
Conclusion
This study investigates the use of three deep generative models - variational autoencoders, normalizing flow, and score-based diffusion models - for learning implicit regularizers in Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) image reconstruction. The findings suggest that deep generative models can play a crucial role in addressing the inherent nonlinearity and ill-posedness of the EIT inverse problem, which poses challenges for classical regularization techniques.
The results show that while no single method consistently outperforms the others, the conditional normalizing flow model and the conditional score-based diffusion model exhibit promising generalization capabilities in different noise settings. These insights encourage further exploration of deep generative models in EIT and other nonlinear inverse problems, where their ability to learn implicit regularizers and prior knowledge could lead to significant advancements in imaging and reconstruction techniques across various industries and medical applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Bi-level Guided Diffusion Models for Zero-Shot Medical Imaging Inverse Problems
Hossein Askari, Fred Roosta, Hongfu Sun
0
0
In the realm of medical imaging, inverse problems aim to infer high-quality images from incomplete, noisy measurements, with the objective of minimizing expenses and risks to patients in clinical settings. The Diffusion Models have recently emerged as a promising approach to such practical challenges, proving particularly useful for the zero-shot inference of images from partially acquired measurements in Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) and Computed Tomography (CT). A central challenge in this approach, however, is how to guide an unconditional prediction to conform to the measurement information. Existing methods rely on deficient projection or inefficient posterior score approximation guidance, which often leads to suboptimal performance. In this paper, we propose underline{textbf{B}}i-level underline{G}uided underline{D}iffusion underline{M}odels ({BGDM}), a zero-shot imaging framework that efficiently steers the initial unconditional prediction through a emph{bi-level} guidance strategy. Specifically, BGDM first approximates an emph{inner-level} conditional posterior mean as an initial measurement-consistent reference point and then solves an emph{outer-level} proximal optimization objective to reinforce the measurement consistency. Our experimental findings, using publicly available MRI and CT medical datasets, reveal that BGDM is more effective and efficient compared to the baselines, faithfully generating high-fidelity medical images and substantially reducing hallucinatory artifacts in cases of severe degradation.
4/8/2024
Physics-integrated generative modeling using attentive planar normalizing flow based variational autoencoder
Sheikh Waqas Akhtar
0
0
Physics-integrated generative modeling is a class of hybrid or grey-box modeling in which we augment the the data-driven model with the physics knowledge governing the data distribution. The use of physics knowledge allows the generative model to produce output in a controlled way, so that the output, by construction, complies with the physical laws. It imparts improved generalization ability to extrapolate beyond the training distribution as well as improved interpretability because the model is partly grounded in firm domain knowledge. In this work, we aim to improve the fidelity of reconstruction and robustness to noise in the physics integrated generative model. To this end, we use variational-autoencoder as a generative model. To improve the reconstruction results of the decoder, we propose to learn the latent posterior distribution of both the physics as well as the trainable data-driven components using planar normalizng flow. Normalizng flow based posterior distribution harnesses the inherent dynamical structure of the data distribution, hence the learned model gets closer to the true underlying data distribution. To improve the robustness of generative model against noise injected in the model, we propose a modification in the encoder part of the normalizing flow based VAE. We designed the encoder to incorporate scaled dot product attention based contextual information in the noisy latent vector which will mitigate the adverse effect of noise in the latent vector and make the model more robust. We empirically evaluated our models on human locomotion dataset [33] and the results validate the efficacy of our proposed models in terms of improvement in reconstruction quality as well as robustness against noise injected in the model.
4/19/2024
Image Neural Field Diffusion Models
Yinbo Chen, Oliver Wang, Richard Zhang, Eli Shechtman, Xiaolong Wang, Michael Gharbi
0
0
Diffusion models have shown an impressive ability to model complex data distributions, with several key advantages over GANs, such as stable training, better coverage of the training distribution's modes, and the ability to solve inverse problems without extra training. However, most diffusion models learn the distribution of fixed-resolution images. We propose to learn the distribution of continuous images by training diffusion models on image neural fields, which can be rendered at any resolution, and show its advantages over fixed-resolution models. To achieve this, a key challenge is to obtain a latent space that represents photorealistic image neural fields. We propose a simple and effective method, inspired by several recent techniques but with key changes to make the image neural fields photorealistic. Our method can be used to convert existing latent diffusion autoencoders into image neural field autoencoders. We show that image neural field diffusion models can be trained using mixed-resolution image datasets, outperform fixed-resolution diffusion models followed by super-resolution models, and can solve inverse problems with conditions applied at different scales efficiently.
6/12/2024
Diffusion assisted image reconstruction in optoacoustic tomography
M. G. Gonz'alez, M. Vera, A. Dreszman, L. J. Rey Vega
0
0
In this paper we consider the problem of acoustic inversion in the context of the optoacoustic tomography image reconstruction problem. By leveraging the ability of the recently proposed diffusion models for image generative tasks among others, we devise an image reconstruction architecture based on a conditional diffusion process. The scheme makes use of an initial image reconstruction, which is preprocessed by an autoencoder to generate an adequate representation. This representation is used as conditional information in a generative diffusion process. Although the computational requirements for training and implementing the architecture are not low, several design choices discussed in the work were made to keep them manageable. Numerical results show that the conditional information allows to properly bias the parameters of the diffusion model to improve the quality of the initial reconstructed image, eliminating artifacts or even reconstructing finer details of the ground-truth image that are not recoverable by the initial image reconstruction method. We also tested the proposal under experimental conditions and the obtained results were in line with those corresponding to the numerical simulations. Improvements in image quality up to 17 % in terms of peak signal-to-noise ratio were observed.
4/17/2024