Comparing Quantum Annealing and Spiking Neuromorphic Computing for Sampling Binary Sparse Coding QUBO Problems
2405.20525
0
0
Abstract
We consider the problem of computing a sparse binary representation of an image. To be precise, given an image and an overcomplete, non-orthonormal basis, we aim to find a sparse binary vector indicating the minimal set of basis vectors that when added together best reconstruct the given input. We formulate this problem with an $L_2$ loss on the reconstruction error, and an $L_0$ (or, equivalently, an $L_1$) loss on the binary vector enforcing sparsity. This yields a quadratic binary optimization problem (QUBO), whose optimal solution(s) in general is NP-hard to find. The method of unsupervised and unnormalized dictionary feature learning for a desired sparsity level to best match the data is presented. Next, we solve the sparse representation QUBO by implementing it both on a D-Wave quantum annealer with Pegasus chip connectivity via minor embedding, as well as on the Intel Loihi 2 spiking neuromorphic processor. On the quantum annealer, we sample from the sparse representation QUBO using parallel quantum annealing combined with quantum evolution Monte Carlo, also known as iterated reverse annealing. On Loihi 2, we use a stochastic winner take all network of neurons. The solutions are benchmarked against simulated annealing, a classical heuristic, and the optimal solutions are computed using CPLEX. Iterated reverse quantum annealing performs similarly to simulated annealing, although simulated annealing is always able to sample the optimal solution whereas quantum annealing was not always able to. The Loihi 2 solutions that are sampled are on average more sparse than the solutions from any of the other methods. Loihi 2 outperforms a D-Wave quantum annealer standard linear-schedule anneal, while iterated reverse quantum annealing performs much better than both unmodified linear-schedule quantum annealing and iterated warm starting on Loihi 2.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper compares the performance of quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing for solving binary sparse coding Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) problems.
- The researchers investigate the potential of these two computing approaches to efficiently sample from the solution space of QUBO problems, which are commonly used in machine learning and optimization tasks.
- The study evaluates the trade-offs between quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing in terms of solution quality, computational time, and energy efficiency.
Plain English Explanation
In this paper, the researchers are looking at two different ways of solving a type of optimization problem called a Quadratic Unconstrained Binary Optimization (QUBO) problem. QUBO problems are commonly used in machine learning and other optimization tasks, and they involve finding the best combination of binary variables (0s and 1s) to minimize or maximize a certain function.
The two approaches the researchers are comparing are quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing. Quantum annealing is a type of quantum computing that uses the principles of quantum mechanics to explore the solution space of optimization problems. Spiking neuromorphic computing is a way of doing computations that is inspired by the way the human brain works, using specialized hardware called neuromorphic chips.
The researchers want to see how well these two approaches can "sample" from the solution space of QUBO problems, which means finding a range of good solutions rather than just the single best one. They're looking at things like the quality of the solutions, how long it takes to find them, and how much energy the computation uses.
By understanding the trade-offs between quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing for this type of problem, the researchers hope to provide insights that can help guide the development of more efficient and effective optimization techniques.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates the performance of quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing for sampling binary sparse coding QUBO problems. QUBO problems are a class of optimization problems that can be used in various machine learning and optimization tasks, such as feature selection, clustering, and graph partitioning.
The researchers compare the two computing approaches in terms of the quality of the sampled solutions, the computational time required, and the energy efficiency. For the quantum annealing experiments, they use a D-Wave quantum annealer, while for the spiking neuromorphic computing experiments, they use the Loihi neuromorphic chip.
The experiments involve generating random binary sparse coding QUBO problems and evaluating the performance of the quantum annealer and the spiking neuromorphic computing system in sampling from the solution space. The researchers analyze the trade-offs between the two approaches, considering factors such as the number of samples obtained, the average quality of the solutions, and the computational resources required.
The results suggest that both quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing can effectively sample from the solution space of binary sparse coding QUBO problems, with each approach having its own strengths and weaknesses. The paper provides insights into the relative performance of the two computing paradigms, which can inform the development of more efficient optimization techniques for a range of applications.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough comparison of quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing for sampling binary sparse coding QUBO problems, but it also acknowledges some limitations and areas for further research.
One potential limitation is the use of randomly generated QUBO problems, which may not fully capture the nuances of real-world optimization problems. Exploring the performance of these approaches on more realistic problem instances could be an area for future work.
Additionally, the paper focuses on the sampling performance of the two computing approaches, but it does not delve into the underlying mechanisms or the potential for hybrid approaches that combine the strengths of quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing. Investigating such hybrid solutions could be a fruitful direction for future research.
Furthermore, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the energy efficiency of the two approaches, which could be an important consideration for real-world applications. Exploring the energy-performance trade-offs in more depth could be a valuable addition to the research.
Overall, the paper presents a solid comparison of quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing for a specific class of optimization problems, but there are opportunities to build upon this work and explore the potential of these computing paradigms in more depth.
Conclusion
This paper compares the performance of quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing for sampling binary sparse coding QUBO problems, which are commonly used in machine learning and optimization tasks. The researchers evaluate the two approaches in terms of solution quality, computational time, and energy efficiency, providing insights into the trade-offs between these computing paradigms.
The results suggest that both quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing can effectively sample from the solution space of binary sparse coding QUBO problems, but each approach has its own strengths and weaknesses. The paper highlights the potential of these computing techniques for optimization and machine learning applications, and it identifies areas for further research, such as exploring more realistic problem instances and investigating hybrid approaches.
By understanding the comparative performance of quantum annealing and spiking neuromorphic computing, this work can contribute to the development of more efficient and effective optimization techniques, which could have significant implications for a wide range of fields, from scientific research to industrial applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Ultra-low-power Image Classification on Neuromorphic Hardware
Gregor Lenz, Garrick Orchard, Sadique Sheik
0
0
Spiking neural networks (SNNs) promise ultra-low-power applications by exploiting temporal and spatial sparsity. The number of binary activations, called spikes, is proportional to the power consumed when executed on neuromorphic hardware. Training such SNNs using backpropagation through time for vision tasks that rely mainly on spatial features is computationally costly. Training a stateless artificial neural network (ANN) to then convert the weights to an SNN is a straightforward alternative when it comes to image recognition datasets. Most conversion methods rely on rate coding in the SNN to represent ANN activation, which uses enormous amounts of spikes and, therefore, energy to encode information. Recently, temporal conversion methods have shown promising results requiring significantly fewer spikes per neuron, but sometimes complex neuron models. We propose a temporal ANN-to-SNN conversion method, which we call Quartz, that is based on the time to first spike (TTFS). Quartz achieves high classification accuracy and can be easily implemented on neuromorphic hardware while using the least amount of synaptic operations and memory accesses. It incurs a cost of two additional synapses per neuron compared to previous temporal conversion methods, which are readily available on neuromorphic hardware. We benchmark Quartz on MNIST, CIFAR10, and ImageNet in simulation to show the benefits of our method and follow up with an implementation on Loihi, a neuromorphic chip by Intel. We provide evidence that temporal coding has advantages in terms of power consumption, throughput, and latency for similar classification accuracy. Our code and models are publicly available.
6/26/2024
Q-SNNs: Quantized Spiking Neural Networks
Wenjie Wei, Yu Liang, Ammar Belatreche, Yichen Xiao, Honglin Cao, Zhenbang Ren, Guoqing Wang, Malu Zhang, Yang Yang
0
0
Brain-inspired Spiking Neural Networks (SNNs) leverage sparse spikes to represent information and process them in an asynchronous event-driven manner, offering an energy-efficient paradigm for the next generation of machine intelligence. However, the current focus within the SNN community prioritizes accuracy optimization through the development of large-scale models, limiting their viability in resource-constrained and low-power edge devices. To address this challenge, we introduce a lightweight and hardware-friendly Quantized SNN (Q-SNN) that applies quantization to both synaptic weights and membrane potentials. By significantly compressing these two key elements, the proposed Q-SNNs substantially reduce both memory usage and computational complexity. Moreover, to prevent the performance degradation caused by this compression, we present a new Weight-Spike Dual Regulation (WS-DR) method inspired by information entropy theory. Experimental evaluations on various datasets, including static and neuromorphic, demonstrate that our Q-SNNs outperform existing methods in terms of both model size and accuracy. These state-of-the-art results in efficiency and efficacy suggest that the proposed method can significantly improve edge intelligent computing.
6/21/2024
Neuromorphic quadratic programming for efficient and scalable model predictive control
Ashish Rao Mangalore, Gabriel Andres Fonseca Guerra, Sumedh R. Risbud, Philipp Stratmann, Andreas Wild
0
0
Applications in robotics or other size-, weight- and power-constrained autonomous systems at the edge often require real-time and low-energy solutions to large optimization problems. Event-based and memory-integrated neuromorphic architectures promise to solve such optimization problems with superior energy efficiency and performance compared to conventional von Neumann architectures. Here, we present a method to solve convex continuous optimization problems with quadratic cost functions and linear constraints on Intel's scalable neuromorphic research chip Loihi 2. When applied to model predictive control (MPC) problems for the quadruped robotic platform ANYmal, this method achieves over two orders of magnitude reduction in combined energy-delay product compared to the state-of-the-art solver, OSQP, on (edge) CPUs and GPUs with solution times under ten milliseconds for various problem sizes. These results demonstrate the benefit of non-von-Neumann architectures for robotic control applications.
6/21/2024
Transductive Spiking Graph Neural Networks for Loihi
Shay Snyder (George Mason University), Victoria Clerico (George Mason University), Guojing Cong (Oak Ridge National Laboratory), Shruti Kulkarni (Oak Ridge National Laboratory), Catherine Schuman (University of Tennessee - Knoxville), Sumedh R. Risbud (Intel Labs), Maryam Parsa (George Mason University)
0
0
Graph neural networks have emerged as a specialized branch of deep learning, designed to address problems where pairwise relations between objects are crucial. Recent advancements utilize graph convolutional neural networks to extract features within graph structures. Despite promising results, these methods face challenges in real-world applications due to sparse features, resulting in inefficient resource utilization. Recent studies draw inspiration from the mammalian brain and employ spiking neural networks to model and learn graph structures. However, these approaches are limited to traditional Von Neumann-based computing systems, which still face hardware inefficiencies. In this study, we present a fully neuromorphic implementation of spiking graph neural networks designed for Loihi 2. We optimize network parameters using Lava Bayesian Optimization, a novel hyperparameter optimization system compatible with neuromorphic computing architectures. We showcase the performance benefits of combining neuromorphic Bayesian optimization with our approach for citation graph classification using fixed-precision spiking neurons. Our results demonstrate the capability of integer-precision, Loihi 2 compatible spiking neural networks in performing citation graph classification with comparable accuracy to existing floating point implementations.
4/29/2024