A Computational Analysis of the Dehumanisation of Migrants from Syria and Ukraine in Slovene News Media
2404.07036
0
0
Abstract
Dehumanisation involves the perception and or treatment of a social group's members as less than human. This phenomenon is rarely addressed with computational linguistic techniques. We adapt a recently proposed approach for English, making it easier to transfer to other languages and to evaluate, introducing a new sentiment resource, the use of zero-shot cross-lingual valence and arousal detection, and a new method for statistical significance testing. We then apply it to study attitudes to migration expressed in Slovene newspapers, to examine changes in the Slovene discourse on migration between the 2015-16 migration crisis following the war in Syria and the 2022-23 period following the war in Ukraine. We find that while this discourse became more negative and more intense over time, it is less dehumanising when specifically addressing Ukrainian migrants compared to others.
Create account to get full access
Overview
โข This study presents a computational analysis of the dehumanization of migrants from Syria and Ukraine in Slovene news media. โข The researchers used natural language processing techniques to examine the language used in news articles to describe these migrant groups. โข The goal was to identify patterns of dehumanization, such as the use of dehumanizing metaphors or the portrayal of migrants as a threat or burden.
Plain English Explanation
This research paper looks at how the Slovene news media talks about migrants from Syria and Ukraine. The researchers used computer programs to analyze the language used in news articles to describe these two groups of migrants. They were trying to find signs of "dehumanization" - ways that the media portrays migrants as less than human, such as using metaphors that compare them to animals or natural disasters. The researchers wanted to see if there were differences in how the media talked about Syrian migrants versus Ukrainian migrants, and what that might reveal about biases or prejudices in how these groups are perceived.
Technical Explanation
The study used computational techniques to analyze the language used in Slovene news articles about migrants from Syria and Ukraine. The researchers collected a large corpus of news articles and applied natural language processing (NLP) algorithms to identify the use of dehumanizing language, such as metaphors that compare migrants to animals or natural disasters. They also looked at whether the tone and framing of the articles differed between the two migrant groups.
The data and resources used in the study included a corpus of Slovene news articles mentioning migrants from Syria and Ukraine, as well as dictionaries and taxonomies to help detect dehumanizing language. The researchers developed custom NLP models to analyze the text and identify relevant linguistic features.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough and rigorous computational analysis of dehumanization in Slovene news coverage of migrants. However, it acknowledges some limitations, such as the potential for bias in the news sources sampled and the challenges of defining and detecting dehumanizing language using automated techniques. The researchers also note that their analysis does not reveal the underlying causes or motivations for the observed patterns of dehumanization.
Further research could explore the broader context of media discourse around migration, such as by comparing coverage of different migrant groups or examining the role of political ideology and social attitudes. Studies on cross-lingual and multilingual aspects of this issue could also provide additional insights.
Conclusion
This study offers a valuable computational perspective on the dehumanization of migrants in Slovene news media. By using NLP techniques to systematically analyze large volumes of text, the researchers were able to identify patterns and differences in how Syrian and Ukrainian migrants are portrayed. While the findings highlight concerning trends, they also point to the need for further research to better understand the complex interplay of media, language, and societal attitudes toward migration.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
๐ท๏ธ
Mentions of Prejudice in News Media -- An International Comparison
David Rozado
0
0
Previous research has identified a post-2010 sharp increase of terms used to denounce prejudice (i.e. racism, sexism, homophobia, Islamophobia, anti-Semitism, etc.) in U.S. and U.K. news media content. Here, we extend previous analysis to an international sample of news media organizations. Thus, we quantify the prevalence of prejudice-denouncing terms and social justice associated terminology (diversity, inclusion, equality, etc.) in over 98 million news and opinion articles across 124 popular news media outlets from 36 countries representing 6 different world regions: English-speaking West, continental Europe, Latin America, sub-Saharan Africa, Persian Gulf region and Asia. We find that the post-2010 increasing prominence in news media of the studied terminology is not circumscribed to the U.S. and the U.K. but rather appears to be a mostly global phenomenon starting in the first half of the 2010s decade in pioneering countries yet largely prevalent around the globe post-2015. However, different world regions' news media emphasize distinct types of prejudice with varying degrees of intensity. We find no evidence of U.S. news media having been first in the world in increasing the frequency of prejudice coverage in their content. The large degree of temporal synchronicity with which the studied set of terms increased in news media across a vast majority of countries raises important questions about the root causes driving this phenomenon.
5/6/2024
A Study on Scaling Up Multilingual News Framing Analysis
Syeda Sabrina Akter, Antonios Anastasopoulos
0
0
Media framing is the study of strategically selecting and presenting specific aspects of political issues to shape public opinion. Despite its relevance to almost all societies around the world, research has been limited due to the lack of available datasets and other resources. This study explores the possibility of dataset creation through crowdsourcing, utilizing non-expert annotators to develop training corpora. We first extend framing analysis beyond English news to a multilingual context (12 typologically diverse languages) through automatic translation. We also present a novel benchmark in Bengali and Portuguese on the immigration and same-sex marriage domains. Additionally, we show that a system trained on our crowd-sourced dataset, combined with other existing ones, leads to a 5.32 percentage point increase from the baseline, showing that crowdsourcing is a viable option. Last, we study the performance of large language models (LLMs) for this task, finding that task-specific fine-tuning is a better approach than employing bigger non-specialized models.
4/3/2024
๐
A multidisciplinary framework for deconstructing bots' pluripotency in dualistic antagonism
Wentao Xu, Kazutoshi Sasahara, Jianxun Chu, Bin Wang, Wenlu Fan, Zhiwen Hu
0
0
Anthropomorphic social bots are engineered to emulate human verbal communication and generate toxic or inflammatory content across social networking services (SNSs). Bot-disseminated misinformation could subtly yet profoundly reshape societal processes by complexly interweaving factors like repeated disinformation exposure, amplified political polarization, compromised indicators of democratic health, shifted perceptions of national identity, propagation of false social norms, and manipulation of collective memory over time. However, extrapolating bots' pluripotency across hybridized, multilingual, and heterogeneous media ecologies from isolated SNS analyses remains largely unknown, underscoring the need for a comprehensive framework to characterise bots' emergent risks to civic discourse. Here we propose an interdisciplinary framework to characterise bots' pluripotency, incorporating quantification of influence, network dynamics monitoring, and interlingual feature analysis. When applied to the geopolitical discourse around the Russo-Ukrainian conflict, results from interlanguage toxicity profiling and network analysis elucidated spatiotemporal trajectories of pro-Russian and pro-Ukrainian human and bots across hybrid SNSs. Weaponized bots predominantly inhabited X, while human primarily populated Reddit in the social media warfare. This rigorous framework promises to elucidate interlingual homogeneity and heterogeneity in bots' pluripotent behaviours, revealing synergistic human-bot mechanisms underlying regimes of information manipulation, echo chamber formation, and collective memory manifestation in algorithmically structured societies.
5/14/2024
๐งช
Attitudes Towards Migration in a COVID-19 Context: Testing a Behavioral Immune System Hypothesis with Twitter Data
Yerka Freire-Vidal, Gabriela Fajardo, Carlos Rodr'iguez-Sickert, Eduardo Graells-Garrido, Jos'e Antonio Mu~noz-Reyes, Oriana Figueroa
0
0
The COVID-19 outbreak implied many changes in the daily life of most of the world's population for a long time, prompting severe restrictions on sociality. The Behavioral Immune System (BIS) suggests that when facing pathogens, a psychological mechanism would be activated that, among other things, would generate an increase in prejudice and discrimination towards marginalized groups, including immigrants. This study aimed to test if people tend to enhance their rejection of minorities and foreign groups under the threat of contagious diseases, using the users' attitudes towards migrants in Twitter data from Chile, for pre-pandemic and pandemic contexts. Our results only partially support the BIS hypothesis, since threatened users increased their tweet production in the pandemic period, compared to empathetic users, but the latter grew in number and also increased the reach of their tweets between the two periods. We also found differences in the use of language between these types of users. Alternative explanations for these results may be context-dependent.
5/24/2024