Constrained C-Test Generation via Mixed-Integer Programming
2404.08821
0
0
🛸
Abstract
This work proposes a novel method to generate C-Tests; a deviated form of cloze tests (a gap filling exercise) where only the last part of a word is turned into a gap. In contrast to previous works that only consider varying the gap size or gap placement to achieve locally optimal solutions, we propose a mixed-integer programming (MIP) approach. This allows us to consider gap size and placement simultaneously, achieving globally optimal solutions, and to directly integrate state-of-the-art models for gap difficulty prediction into the optimization problem. A user study with 40 participants across four C-Test generation strategies (including GPT-4) shows that our approach (MIP) significantly outperforms two of the baseline strategies (based on gap placement and GPT-4); and performs on-par with the third (based on gap size). Our analysis shows that GPT-4 still struggles to fulfill explicit constraints during generation and that MIP produces C-Tests that correlate best with the perceived difficulty. We publish our code, model, and collected data consisting of 32 English C-Tests with 20 gaps each (totaling 3,200 individual gap responses) under an open source license.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a novel method to generate C-Tests, a type of gap-filling exercise where only the last part of a word is turned into a gap.
- Previous approaches only considered varying the gap size or placement to achieve locally optimal solutions.
- The authors propose a mixed-integer programming (MIP) approach that can consider gap size and placement simultaneously, achieving globally optimal solutions, and directly integrate state-of-the-art models for gap difficulty prediction.
- A user study with 40 participants across four C-Test generation strategies (including GPT-4) shows that the MIP approach significantly outperforms two baseline strategies and performs on-par with the third.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new way to create a type of language exercise called a C-Test. In a C-Test, you're given a passage of text with some of the words partially blanked out, and you have to fill in the missing parts.
Previous methods for creating C-Tests only looked at things like how big the blanks should be or where to put them, trying to find the best local solution. But the researchers in this paper took a different approach. They used a mathematical technique called mixed-integer programming (MIP) to consider both the size and placement of the blanks at the same time, aiming for the overall best solution.
This MIP approach also allowed them to directly integrate advanced language models that can predict how difficult the blanks will be for people to fill in. The researchers tested their new MIP-based C-Test generation method against some other approaches, including using the powerful GPT-4 language model. The results showed that the MIP method performed better than two of the other strategies and matched the third.
The key insight here is that by taking a more holistic, optimization-based approach, the researchers were able to create better C-Tests than previous, more limited methods. This could be useful for language learning, assessment, and other applications that rely on these types of gap-filling exercises.
Technical Explanation
The paper proposes a mixed-integer programming (MIP) approach for generating C-Tests, a form of cloze test where only the last part of a word is turned into a gap.
Unlike previous work that only considered varying the gap size or gap placement to achieve locally optimal solutions, the authors' MIP approach allows them to consider gap size and placement simultaneously, achieving globally optimal solutions. This approach also enables them to directly integrate state-of-the-art models for gap difficulty prediction into the optimization problem.
The authors conducted a user study with 40 participants to evaluate four C-Test generation strategies, including their MIP approach and GPT-4. The results show that the MIP approach significantly outperforms two of the baseline strategies (based on gap placement and GPT-4) and performs on-par with the third (based on gap size).
The analysis reveals that GPT-4 still struggles to fulfill explicit constraints during generation, and that the C-Tests generated by the MIP approach correlate best with the perceived difficulty. The authors publish their code, model, and collected data consisting of 32 English C-Tests with 20 gaps each (totaling 3,200 individual gap responses) under an open-source license.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and promising approach to generating C-Tests, but it also raises some interesting questions and potential limitations.
One key aspect that could be further explored is the role of the difficulty prediction model in the MIP optimization process. The authors show that the MIP approach outperforms GPT-4, but it would be interesting to see how the MIP approach would fare against other, potentially more advanced, difficulty prediction models.
Additionally, the user study was relatively small, with only 40 participants. It would be valuable to see the results replicated with a larger and more diverse sample to better understand the generalizability of the findings.
Another potential area for further research is the scalability of the MIP approach. As the size and complexity of the C-Tests increase, the computational demands of the optimization process may become a limiting factor. Exploring ways to make the MIP approach more efficient or investigating alternative optimization techniques could be a fruitful line of inquiry.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of language learning and assessment by proposing a novel, optimization-based approach to C-Test generation. The results are promising, and the authors' willingness to share their code and data is commendable. Further research and refinement of this approach could lead to even more impactful applications in the future.
Conclusion
The paper presents a novel mixed-integer programming (MIP) approach for generating C-Tests, a type of gap-filling exercise where only the last part of a word is turned into a blank.
Unlike previous methods that only considered gap size or placement, the MIP approach can optimize both simultaneously, leading to globally optimal solutions. The authors also integrated state-of-the-art models for gap difficulty prediction into the optimization process.
A user study with 40 participants showed that the MIP approach outperformed two baseline strategies and performed on-par with a third. The analysis suggests that the MIP-generated C-Tests correlate best with perceived difficulty, and that current language models like GPT-4 still struggle with fulfilling explicit constraints during generation.
This work offers a promising new direction for creating more effective C-Tests, which could have significant applications in language learning, assessment, and other domains that rely on these types of exercises. The authors' commitment to open-sourcing their code, model, and data further enhances the potential impact of this research.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Benchmarking Generative Models on Computational Thinking Tests in Elementary Visual Programming
Victor-Alexandru Pu{a}durean, Adish Singla
0
0
Generative models have demonstrated human-level proficiency in various benchmarks across domains like programming, natural sciences, and general knowledge. Despite these promising results on competitive benchmarks, they still struggle with seemingly simple problem-solving tasks typically carried out by elementary-level students. How do state-of-the-art models perform on standardized tests designed to assess computational thinking and problem-solving skills at schools? In this paper, we curate a novel benchmark involving computational thinking tests grounded in elementary visual programming domains. Our initial results show that state-of-the-art models like GPT-4o and Llama3 barely match the performance of an average school student. To further boost the performance of these models, we fine-tune them using a novel synthetic data generation methodology. The key idea is to develop a comprehensive dataset using symbolic methods that capture different skill levels, ranging from recognition of visual elements to multi-choice quizzes to synthesis-style tasks. We showcase how various aspects of symbolic information in synthetic data help improve fine-tuned models' performance. We will release the full implementation and datasets to facilitate further research on enhancing computational thinking in generative models.
6/17/2024
Intertwining CP and NLP: The Generation of Unreasonably Constrained Sentences
Alexandre Bonlarron, Jean-Charles R'egin
0
0
Constrained text generation remains a challenging task, particularly when dealing with hard constraints. Traditional Natural Language Processing (NLP) approaches prioritize generating meaningful and coherent output. Also, the current state-of-the-art methods often lack the expressiveness and constraint satisfaction capabilities to handle such tasks effectively. This paper presents the Constraints First Framework to remedy this issue. This framework considers a constrained text generation problem as a discrete combinatorial optimization problem. It is solved by a constraint programming method that combines linguistic properties (e.g., n-grams or language level) with other more classical constraints (e.g., the number of characters, syllables, or words). Eventually, a curation phase allows for selecting the best-generated sentences according to perplexity using a large language model. The effectiveness of this approach is demonstrated by tackling a new more tediously constrained text generation problem: the iconic RADNER sentences problem. This problem aims to generate sentences respecting a set of quite strict rules defined by their use in vision and clinical research. Thanks to our CP-based approach, many new strongly constrained sentences have been successfully generated in an automatic manner. This highlights the potential of our approach to handle unreasonably constrained text generation scenarios.
6/26/2024
Code-Aware Prompting: A study of Coverage Guided Test Generation in Regression Setting using LLM
Gabriel Ryan, Siddhartha Jain, Mingyue Shang, Shiqi Wang, Xiaofei Ma, Murali Krishna Ramanathan, Baishakhi Ray
0
0
Testing plays a pivotal role in ensuring software quality, yet conventional Search Based Software Testing (SBST) methods often struggle with complex software units, achieving suboptimal test coverage. Recent works using large language models (LLMs) for test generation have focused on improving generation quality through optimizing the test generation context and correcting errors in model outputs, but use fixed prompting strategies that prompt the model to generate tests without additional guidance. As a result LLM-generated testsuites still suffer from low coverage. In this paper, we present SymPrompt, a code-aware prompting strategy for LLMs in test generation. SymPrompt's approach is based on recent work that demonstrates LLMs can solve more complex logical problems when prompted to reason about the problem in a multi-step fashion. We apply this methodology to test generation by deconstructing the testsuite generation process into a multi-stage sequence, each of which is driven by a specific prompt aligned with the execution paths of the method under test, and exposing relevant type and dependency focal context to the model. Our approach enables pretrained LLMs to generate more complete test cases without any additional training. We implement SymPrompt using the TreeSitter parsing framework and evaluate on a benchmark challenging methods from open source Python projects. SymPrompt enhances correct test generations by a factor of 5 and bolsters relative coverage by 26% for CodeGen2. Notably, when applied to GPT-4, SymPrompt improves coverage by over 2x compared to baseline prompting strategies.
4/4/2024
🤿
Deep learning enhanced mixed integer optimization: Learning to reduce model dimensionality
Niki Triantafyllou, Maria M. Papathanasiou
0
0
This work introduces a framework to address the computational complexity inherent in Mixed-Integer Programming (MIP) models by harnessing the potential of deep learning. By employing deep learning, we construct problem-specific heuristics that identify and exploit common structures across MIP instances. We train deep learning models to estimate complicating binary variables for target MIP problem instances. The resulting reduced MIP models are solved using standard off-the-shelf solvers. We present an algorithm for generating synthetic data enhancing the robustness and generalizability of our models across diverse MIP instances. We compare the effectiveness of (a) feed-forward neural networks (ANN) and (b) convolutional neural networks (CNN). To enhance the framework's performance, we employ Bayesian optimization for hyperparameter tuning, aiming to maximize the occurrence of global optimum solutions. We apply this framework to a flow-based facility location allocation MIP formulation that describes long-term investment planning and medium-term tactical scheduling in a personalized medicine supply chain.
5/13/2024