On the Convergence of Gradient Descent for Large Learning Rates

Overview

• The paper explores the convergence guarantees of gradient descent and related optimization methods.
• It focuses on a practical scenario where a fixed step size is used, and investigates whether gradient descent can converge from any initialization.
• The paper provides fundamental impossibility results, showing that convergence becomes impossible if the step size is too large, regardless of the initialization.
• It observes a phase transition in the asymptotic value of the gradient norm as the step size crosses a critical value, a phenomenon previously observed by practitioners.
• Using results from dynamical systems theory, the paper provides a proof of this behavior for linear neural networks with a squared loss, and also shows the impossibility of convergence for more general losses without strong assumptions.
• The findings are validated through experiments with non-linear networks.

Plain English Explanation

In machine learning, one of the most commonly used optimization techniques is gradient descent. This method iteratively updates the model parameters in the direction of the negative gradient, which points to the direction of steepest descent.

The convergence of gradient descent is an important topic, as it determines whether the optimization process will eventually reach the desired solution. Previous research has explored various convergence guarantees for gradient descent and related methods.

This paper focuses on a specific practical scenario: when a fixed step size is used, can we expect gradient descent to converge starting from any initial point? The researchers provide some fundamental impossibility results, showing that if the step size is too large, convergence becomes impossible regardless of the starting point.

Interestingly, the paper observes a phase transition in the behavior of the gradient norm (a measure of how much the model needs to be updated) as the step size crosses a critical value. This phenomenon has been noted by practitioners, but the underlying mechanisms were not fully understood.

Using tools from dynamical systems theory, the researchers provide a mathematical proof of this phase transition for the case of linear neural networks with a squared loss function. They also show that the impossibility of convergence holds for more general loss functions, without requiring strong assumptions like Lipschitz continuity.

The findings are validated through experiments with more complex, non-linear neural network models, demonstrating the broader applicability of the insights.

Technical Explanation

The paper investigates the convergence properties of gradient descent and related optimization methods when a fixed step size is used. The key contributions are:

1. Impossibility results: The authors prove that if the step size is too large, gradient descent cannot converge, regardless of the initialization. This holds true even for simple linear models with squared loss.

2. Phase transition in gradient norm: The paper observes a phase transition in the asymptotic value of the gradient norm as the step size crosses a critical value. This phenomenon has been empirically observed by practitioners but the underlying mechanisms were not well understood.

3. Dynamical systems analysis: Using tools from dynamical systems theory, the authors provide a rigorous mathematical proof of the phase transition for linear neural networks with squared loss. They also show the impossibility of convergence for more general loss functions without strong assumptions.

4. Experimental validation: The findings are validated through experiments on non-linear neural network models, demonstrating the broader applicability of the insights.

The key technical elements of the paper include:

• Theoretical analysis of gradient descent dynamics using tools from dynamical systems theory
• Characterization of the phase transition in the asymptotic gradient norm as the step size varies
• Proof of the impossibility of convergence for large step sizes, even for simple linear models
• Extension of the results to more general loss functions beyond the squared loss

Critical Analysis

The paper provides valuable theoretical insights into the convergence properties of gradient descent, a fundamental optimization method in machine learning. The impossibility results and the characterization of the phase transition in the gradient norm shed light on the practical limitations of using a fixed step size in gradient-based optimization.

One potential limitation of the work is that the rigorous mathematical analysis is primarily focused on linear models and squared loss. While the authors show that the impossibility of convergence holds for more general loss functions, the underlying mechanisms may be more complex for non-linear models.

Additionally, the paper does not provide guidance on how to select an appropriate step size in practice. Exploring adaptive step size strategies or alternative optimization methods that can overcome the limitations of fixed-step gradient descent could be an interesting direction for future research.

Another aspect that could be further investigated is the relationship between the phase transition in the gradient norm and the actual convergence behavior of the optimization process. The paper establishes the theoretical connection, but empirical studies on how this manifests in different practical scenarios would be valuable.

Overall, the paper makes important contributions to our fundamental understanding of gradient-based optimization methods and opens up new avenues for exploring more robust and reliable optimization techniques in machine learning.

Conclusion

This research paper provides a detailed analysis of the convergence guarantees of gradient descent and related optimization methods when using a fixed step size. The key findings include:

• Fundamental impossibility results showing that convergence becomes impossible if the step size is too large, regardless of the initialization.
• Characterization of a phase transition in the asymptotic value of the gradient norm as the step size crosses a critical value, a phenomenon previously observed by practitioners.
• Rigorous mathematical proofs of these behaviors using tools from dynamical systems theory, both for linear neural networks with squared loss and more general loss functions.
• Experimental validation of the findings on non-linear neural network models.

These insights contribute to our understanding of the practical limitations of gradient-based optimization and pave the way for the development of more robust and reliable optimization techniques in machine learning. The work also highlights the importance of theoretical analysis in guiding the practical application of optimization algorithms.