On the Convergence of Policy in Unregularized Policy Mirror Descent

Read original: arXiv:2205.08176 - Published 6/4/2024 by Dachao Lin, Zhihua Zhang

🛸

Overview

This paper provides a convergence analysis of the policy in the recent "Policy Mirror Descent (PMD)" algorithm.
It considers the unregularized setting, following a previous work [11], and uses a generalized Bregman divergence.
The main contribution is directly providing the convergence rates of the policy under this generalized Bregman divergence.
The results are inspired by the convergence of value function in previous works and extend the study of policy mirror descent.
The paper shows that a large body of Bregman divergences, including the classical Euclidean distance, can lead to finite-step convergence to an optimal policy.

Plain English Explanation

This paper looks at the mathematical properties of an algorithm called "Policy Mirror Descent (PMD)," which is a method for optimizing policies in reinforcement learning. The authors focus on a particular setting where there is no additional regularization, building on a previous study [11].

The key contribution is that the paper directly computes the rate of convergence for the policy itself, using a generalized version of a mathematical concept called Bregman divergence. This extends the previous understanding of how the value function (a measure of expected future reward) converges.

The main insight is that a wide range of Bregman divergences, including the simple Euclidean distance, can lead to fast, finite-step convergence to an optimal policy. This is an important theoretical result that helps us better understand the capabilities and limitations of PMD and related policy optimization algorithms.

Technical Explanation

The paper analyzes the convergence properties of the Policy Mirror Descent (PMD) algorithm, building on previous work [11] that studied the value function convergence.

Unlike that prior work, this paper directly characterizes the convergence rate of the policy itself, using a generalized Bregman divergence as the distance metric. The authors show that a large class of Bregman divergences, including the classic Euclidean distance, can lead to finite-step convergence to an optimal policy.

This result extends the understanding of policy-based primal-dual methods for constrained MDPs and second-order convergence of biased policy gradient algorithms. It is inspired by the convergence analysis of stochastic softmax policies.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough theoretical analysis of the PMD algorithm, building on and extending previous work in this area. The key limitation is that the analysis is restricted to the unregularized setting, whereas many practical applications may require some form of regularization.

Additionally, the paper does not consider the impact of function approximation or other practical challenges that arise when applying these algorithms to real-world problems. Further research would be needed to understand how these theoretical guarantees translate to performance in more realistic scenarios.

That said, the results are an important contribution to the fundamental understanding of policy optimization algorithms. The identification of a broad class of Bregman divergences that can lead to fast convergence is a valuable insight that could inform the design of new algorithms or the selection of appropriate divergence measures for specific applications.

Conclusion

This paper provides a convergence analysis of the Policy Mirror Descent (PMD) algorithm, a method for optimizing policies in reinforcement learning. The key contribution is a direct characterization of the convergence rate of the policy itself, using a generalized Bregman divergence as the distance metric.

The main insight is that a wide range of Bregman divergences, including the simple Euclidean distance, can lead to fast, finite-step convergence to an optimal policy. This theoretical result extends our understanding of policy optimization algorithms and could inform the development of new methods or the application of existing ones in practical settings.

While the analysis is limited to the unregularized setting, the paper represents an important step forward in the fundamental understanding of policy-based reinforcement learning algorithms and their convergence properties.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🛸

On the Convergence of Policy in Unregularized Policy Mirror Descent

Dachao Lin, Zhihua Zhang

In this short note, we give the convergence analysis of the policy in the recent famous policy mirror descent (PMD). We mainly consider the unregularized setting following [11] with generalized Bregman divergence. The difference is that we directly give the convergence rates of policy under generalized Bregman divergence. Our results are inspired by the convergence of value function in previous works and are an extension study of policy mirror descent. Though some results have already appeared in previous work, we further discover a large body of Bregman divergences could give finite-step convergence to an optimal policy, such as the classical Euclidean distance.

6/4/2024

Learning mirror maps in policy mirror descent

Carlo Alfano, Sebastian Towers, Silvia Sapora, Chris Lu, Patrick Rebeschini

Policy Mirror Descent (PMD) is a popular framework in reinforcement learning, serving as a unifying perspective that encompasses numerous algorithms. These algorithms are derived through the selection of a mirror map and enjoy finite-time convergence guarantees. Despite its popularity, the exploration of PMD's full potential is limited, with the majority of research focusing on a particular mirror map -- namely, the negative entropy -- which gives rise to the renowned Natural Policy Gradient (NPG) method. It remains uncertain from existing theoretical studies whether the choice of mirror map significantly influences PMD's efficacy. In our work, we conduct empirical investigations to show that the conventional mirror map choice (NPG) often yields less-than-optimal outcomes across several standard benchmark environments. Using evolutionary strategies, we identify more efficient mirror maps that enhance the performance of PMD. We first focus on a tabular environment, i.e. Grid-World, where we relate existing theoretical bounds with the performance of PMD for a few standard mirror maps and the learned one. We then show that it is possible to learn a mirror map that outperforms the negative entropy in more complex environments, such as the MinAtar suite. Our results suggest that mirror maps generalize well across various environments, raising questions about how to best match a mirror map to an environment's structure and characteristics.

6/10/2024

Functional Acceleration for Policy Mirror Descent

Veronica Chelu, Doina Precup

We apply functional acceleration to the Policy Mirror Descent (PMD) general family of algorithms, which cover a wide range of novel and fundamental methods in Reinforcement Learning (RL). Leveraging duality, we propose a momentum-based PMD update. By taking the functional route, our approach is independent of the policy parametrization and applicable to large-scale optimization, covering previous applications of momentum at the level of policy parameters as a special case. We theoretically analyze several properties of this approach and complement with a numerical ablation study, which serves to illustrate the policy optimization dynamics on the value polytope, relative to different algorithmic design choices in this space. We further characterize numerically several features of the problem setting relevant for functional acceleration, and lastly, we investigate the impact of approximation on their learning mechanics.

7/24/2024

🌿

Convergence and sample complexity of natural policy gradient primal-dual methods for constrained MDPs

Dongsheng Ding, Kaiqing Zhang, Jiali Duan, Tamer Bac{s}ar, Mihailo R. Jovanovi'c

We study sequential decision making problems aimed at maximizing the expected total reward while satisfying a constraint on the expected total utility. We employ the natural policy gradient method to solve the discounted infinite-horizon optimal control problem for Constrained Markov Decision Processes (constrained MDPs). Specifically, we propose a new Natural Policy Gradient Primal-Dual (NPG-PD) method that updates the primal variable via natural policy gradient ascent and the dual variable via projected sub-gradient descent. Although the underlying maximization involves a nonconcave objective function and a nonconvex constraint set, under the softmax policy parametrization we prove that our method achieves global convergence with sublinear rates regarding both the optimality gap and the constraint violation. Such convergence is independent of the size of the state-action space, i.e., it is~dimension-free. Furthermore, for log-linear and general smooth policy parametrizations, we establish sublinear convergence rates up to a function approximation error caused by restricted policy parametrization. We also provide convergence and finite-sample complexity guarantees for two sample-based NPG-PD algorithms. Finally, we use computational experiments to showcase the merits and the effectiveness of our approach.

8/30/2024