Beyond Stationarity: Convergence Analysis of Stochastic Softmax Policy Gradient Methods
2310.02671
0
0
โ
Abstract
Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) are a formal framework for modeling and solving sequential decision-making problems. In finite-time horizons such problems are relevant for instance for optimal stopping or specific supply chain problems, but also in the training of large language models. In contrast to infinite horizon MDPs optimal policies are not stationary, policies must be learned for every single epoch. In practice all parameters are often trained simultaneously, ignoring the inherent structure suggested by dynamic programming. This paper introduces a combination of dynamic programming and policy gradient called dynamic policy gradient, where the parameters are trained backwards in time. For the tabular softmax parametrisation we carry out the convergence analysis for simultaneous and dynamic policy gradient towards global optima, both in the exact and sampled gradient settings without regularisation. It turns out that the use of dynamic policy gradient training much better exploits the structure of finite- time problems which is reflected in improved convergence bounds.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) are a framework for modeling sequential decision-making problems
- In finite-time horizons, optimal policies are not stationary and must be learned for each epoch
- Existing approaches often train all parameters simultaneously, ignoring the inherent structure suggested by dynamic programming
- This paper introduces a new approach called "dynamic policy gradient" that trains parameters backwards in time to better exploit the structure of finite-time problems
Plain English Explanation
Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) are a way to model and solve problems where decisions need to be made over time. For example, an optimal stopping problem or a supply chain management problem. In these finite-time problems, the optimal policy - the best set of decisions to make - changes for each time step. This is different from infinite-horizon MDPs where the optimal policy is the same over time.
Existing approaches often train all the parameters of the model at the same time, without taking advantage of the way these finite-time problems are structured. This paper introduces a new method called "dynamic policy gradient" that trains the parameters backwards in time, better exploiting the structure of the problem.
The key idea is that by training the parameters in reverse order, the method can more efficiently find the optimal policy for each time step. This leads to improved convergence compared to training all parameters simultaneously, which ignores the inherent dynamics of finite-time problems.
Technical Explanation
The paper analyzes the convergence of simultaneous and dynamic policy gradient methods for the tabular softmax parameterization of finite-horizon MDPs. It considers both the exact gradient setting and the sampled gradient setting without regularization.
The analysis shows that the dynamic policy gradient approach much better exploits the structure of finite-time problems, leading to improved convergence bounds compared to the simultaneous approach. This is in line with prior work on learning optimal stochastic policies using gradient methods and analyzing off-policy multi-step temporal difference learning.
The paper also discusses connections to approximate linear programming and decentralized policy iteration in cooperative multi-agent settings, suggesting potential avenues for further research.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a strong theoretical analysis of the dynamic policy gradient approach, demonstrating its advantages over simultaneous training for finite-horizon MDPs. However, the analysis is limited to the tabular softmax parameterization, and it would be valuable to see how the method performs with more expressive function approximators.
Additionally, the paper does not explore the practical implementation details or empirical performance of the dynamic policy gradient method. Further research is needed to understand how it compares to state-of-the-art approaches on real-world problems.
The connections to approximate linear programming and decentralized multi-agent settings are intriguing, but the paper does not delve deeply into these directions. Exploring these connections more thoroughly could lead to interesting extensions and applications of the dynamic policy gradient technique.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach called "dynamic policy gradient" for training policies in finite-horizon Markov Decision Processes. By exploiting the inherent structure of these problems and training parameters backwards in time, the method can achieve improved convergence compared to standard simultaneous training approaches.
The theoretical analysis provided in the paper is rigorous and insightful, but further research is needed to understand the practical performance and potential extensions of the dynamic policy gradient technique. Nonetheless, this work represents an important contribution to the field of reinforcement learning and optimal control, with implications for a wide range of sequential decision-making problems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
๐ผ๏ธ
Elementary Analysis of Policy Gradient Methods
Jiacai Liu, Wenye Li, Ke Wei
0
0
Projected policy gradient under the simplex parameterization, policy gradient and natural policy gradient under the softmax parameterization, are fundamental algorithms in reinforcement learning. There have been a flurry of recent activities in studying these algorithms from the theoretical aspect. Despite this, their convergence behavior is still not fully understood, even given the access to exact policy evaluations. In this paper, we focus on the discounted MDP setting and conduct a systematic study of the aforementioned policy optimization methods. Several novel results are presented, including 1) global linear convergence of projected policy gradient for any constant step size, 2) sublinear convergence of softmax policy gradient for any constant step size, 3) global linear convergence of softmax natural policy gradient for any constant step size, 4) global linear convergence of entropy regularized softmax policy gradient for a wider range of constant step sizes than existing result, 5) tight local linear convergence rate of entropy regularized natural policy gradient, and 6) a new and concise local quadratic convergence rate of soft policy iteration without the assumption on the stationary distribution under the optimal policy. New and elementary analysis techniques have been developed to establish these results.
4/12/2024
๐
Towards Principled, Practical Policy Gradient for Bandits and Tabular MDPs
Michael Lu, Matin Aghaei, Anant Raj, Sharan Vaswani
0
0
We consider (stochastic) softmax policy gradient (PG) methods for bandits and tabular Markov decision processes (MDPs). While the PG objective is non-concave, recent research has used the objective's smoothness and gradient domination properties to achieve convergence to an optimal policy. However, these theoretical results require setting the algorithm parameters according to unknown problem-dependent quantities (e.g. the optimal action or the true reward vector in a bandit problem). To address this issue, we borrow ideas from the optimization literature to design practical, principled PG methods in both the exact and stochastic settings. In the exact setting, we employ an Armijo line-search to set the step-size for softmax PG and empirically demonstrate a linear convergence rate. In the stochastic setting, we utilize exponentially decreasing step-sizes, and characterize the convergence rate of the resulting algorithm. We show that the proposed algorithm offers similar theoretical guarantees as the state-of-the art results, but does not require the knowledge of oracle-like quantities. For the multi-armed bandit setting, our techniques result in a theoretically-principled PG algorithm that does not require explicit exploration, the knowledge of the reward gap, the reward distributions, or the noise. Finally, we empirically compare the proposed methods to PG approaches that require oracle knowledge, and demonstrate competitive performance.
5/24/2024
๐งช
Learning Optimal Deterministic Policies with Stochastic Policy Gradients
Alessandro Montenegro, Marco Mussi, Alberto Maria Metelli, Matteo Papini
0
0
Policy gradient (PG) methods are successful approaches to deal with continuous reinforcement learning (RL) problems. They learn stochastic parametric (hyper)policies by either exploring in the space of actions or in the space of parameters. Stochastic controllers, however, are often undesirable from a practical perspective because of their lack of robustness, safety, and traceability. In common practice, stochastic (hyper)policies are learned only to deploy their deterministic version. In this paper, we make a step towards the theoretical understanding of this practice. After introducing a novel framework for modeling this scenario, we study the global convergence to the best deterministic policy, under (weak) gradient domination assumptions. Then, we illustrate how to tune the exploration level used for learning to optimize the trade-off between the sample complexity and the performance of the deployed deterministic policy. Finally, we quantitatively compare action-based and parameter-based exploration, giving a formal guise to intuitive results.
5/31/2024
๐ฌ
A policy gradient approach for Finite Horizon Constrained Markov Decision Processes
Soumyajit Guin, Shalabh Bhatnagar
0
0
The infinite horizon setting is widely adopted for problems of reinforcement learning (RL). These invariably result in stationary policies that are optimal. In many situations, finite horizon control problems are of interest and for such problems, the optimal policies are time-varying in general. Another setting that has become popular in recent times is of Constrained Reinforcement Learning, where the agent maximizes its rewards while it also aims to satisfy some given constraint criteria. However, this setting has only been studied in the context of infinite horizon MDPs where stationary policies are optimal. We present an algorithm for constrained RL in the Finite Horizon Setting where the horizon terminates after a fixed (finite) time. We use function approximation in our algorithm which is essential when the state and action spaces are large or continuous and use the policy gradient method to find the optimal policy. The optimal policy that we obtain depends on the stage and so is non-stationary in general. To the best of our knowledge, our paper presents the first policy gradient algorithm for the finite horizon setting with constraints. We show the convergence of our algorithm to a constrained optimal policy. We also compare and analyze the performance of our algorithm through experiments and show that our algorithm performs better than some other well known algorithms.
6/24/2024