Convergent Differential Privacy Analysis for General Federated Learning: the f-DP Perspective
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a convergent differential privacy analysis for general federated learning using the f-DP perspective.
- Federated learning enables multiple clients to collaboratively train a shared model without sharing their raw data.
- Differential privacy provides a formal guarantee of privacy by limiting the amount of information an adversary can learn about individual data points.
- The f-DP framework provides a more general approach to differential privacy that can capture a wider range of privacy mechanisms.
Plain English Explanation
Federated learning is a way for multiple devices or organizations to work together to train a shared machine learning model without having to share their private data. However, there are still risks of revealing sensitive information about the individual users' data.
Differential privacy is a mathematical framework that provides a strong guarantee of privacy by limiting how much any individual's data can influence the final model. The f-DP framework extends differential privacy to be more flexible and able to handle a wider range of privacy-preserving mechanisms.
This paper analyzes how differential privacy can be applied in the context of federated learning, showing that it is possible to achieve strong privacy guarantees while still allowing the clients to collaboratively train an accurate shared model. The key insight is to use the f-DP framework to reason about the privacy properties of the overall federated learning process.
Technical Explanation
The paper first introduces the federated learning setting and the f-DP framework for differential privacy. It then presents a convergent analysis of the privacy loss in federated learning under the f-DP model.
Specifically, the paper makes the following technical contributions:
-
It defines an f-DP-based privacy accounting method for the general federated learning setting, which can handle a wide range of privacy mechanisms.
-
It proves that the overall privacy loss in federated learning converges as the number of communication rounds increases, providing formal privacy guarantees.
-
It demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed approach through numerical experiments on real-world datasets, showing that it can achieve strong privacy while maintaining model accuracy.
The analysis in the paper relies on representing the federated learning process as a Markov chain and then using f-DP properties to bound the privacy loss. This provides a principled way to understand the privacy-accuracy tradeoffs in federated learning.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a solid theoretical foundation for applying differential privacy to federated learning, but there are a few limitations and open questions:
-
The analysis assumes the privacy mechanisms used by each client satisfy f-DP, which may not always be the case in practice. Extending the results to more general privacy mechanisms would be valuable.
-
The convergence results depend on certain assumptions about the federated learning algorithm and the data distribution. Relaxing these assumptions to handle a wider range of practical scenarios would improve the applicability of the approach.
-
The paper does not address potential fairness and equity issues that can arise in federated learning, such as unequal participation or data quality across clients. Incorporating these considerations into the privacy analysis would be an important direction for future work.
Overall, this paper makes an important contribution to the understanding of privacy in federated learning, but there is still more research needed to fully address the practical challenges of deploying differentially private federated learning systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a convergent differential privacy analysis for general federated learning using the f-DP framework. By modeling the federated learning process as a Markov chain and leveraging f-DP properties, the authors show that it is possible to achieve strong privacy guarantees while maintaining model accuracy.
The technical insights from this work can help practitioners and researchers design more robust and privacy-preserving federated learning systems. However, further research is needed to address practical limitations and expand the applicability of the approach to a wider range of real-world scenarios.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Convergent Differential Privacy Analysis for General Federated Learning: the f-DP Perspective
Yan Sun, Li Shen, Dacheng Tao
Federated learning (FL) is an efficient collaborative training paradigm extensively developed with a focus on local privacy protection, and differential privacy (DP) is a classical approach to capture and ensure the reliability of local privacy. The powerful cooperation of FL and DP provides a promising learning framework for large-scale private clients, juggling both privacy securing and trustworthy learning. As the predominant algorithm of DP, the noisy perturbation has been widely studied and incorporated into various federated algorithms, theoretically proven to offer significant privacy protections. However, existing analyses in noisy FL-DP mostly rely on the composition theorem and cannot tightly quantify the privacy leakage challenges, which is nearly tight for small numbers of communication rounds but yields an arbitrarily loose and divergent bound under the large communication rounds. This implies a counterintuitive judgment, suggesting that FL may not provide adequate privacy protection during long-term training. To further investigate the convergent privacy and reliability of the FL-DP framework, in this paper, we comprehensively evaluate the worst privacy of two classical methods under the non-convex and smooth objectives based on the f-DP analysis, i.e. Noisy-FedAvg and Noisy-FedProx methods. With the aid of the shifted-interpolation technique, we successfully prove that the worst privacy of the Noisy-FedAvg method achieves a tight convergent lower bound. Moreover, in the Noisy-FedProx method, with the regularization of the proxy term, the worst privacy has a stable constant lower bound. Our analysis further provides a solid theoretical foundation for the reliability of privacy protection in FL-DP. Meanwhile, our conclusions can also be losslessly converted to other classical DP analytical frameworks, e.g. $(epsilon,delta)$-DP and R$acute{text{e}}$nyi-DP (RDP).
Read more8/29/2024
0
Enhancing Federated Learning with Adaptive Differential Privacy and Priority-Based Aggregation
Mahtab Talaei, Iman Izadi
Federated learning (FL), a novel branch of distributed machine learning (ML), develops global models through a private procedure without direct access to local datasets. However, it is still possible to access the model updates (gradient updates of deep neural networks) transferred between clients and servers, potentially revealing sensitive local information to adversaries using model inversion attacks. Differential privacy (DP) offers a promising approach to addressing this issue by adding noise to the parameters. On the other hand, heterogeneities in data structure, storage, communication, and computational capabilities of devices can cause convergence problems and delays in developing the global model. A personalized weighted averaging of local parameters based on the resources of each device can yield a better aggregated model in each round. In this paper, to efficiently preserve privacy, we propose a personalized DP framework that injects noise based on clients' relative impact factors and aggregates parameters while considering heterogeneities and adjusting properties. To fulfill the DP requirements, we first analyze the convergence boundary of the FL algorithm when impact factors are personalized and fixed throughout the learning process. We then further study the convergence property considering time-varying (adaptive) impact factors.
Read more6/27/2024
0
Universally Harmonizing Differential Privacy Mechanisms for Federated Learning: Boosting Accuracy and Convergence
Shuya Feng, Meisam Mohammady, Hanbin Hong, Shenao Yan, Ashish Kundu, Binghui Wang, Yuan Hong
Differentially private federated learning (DP-FL) is a promising technique for collaborative model training while ensuring provable privacy for clients. However, optimizing the tradeoff between privacy and accuracy remains a critical challenge. To our best knowledge, we propose the first DP-FL framework (namely UDP-FL), which universally harmonizes any randomization mechanism (e.g., an optimal one) with the Gaussian Moments Accountant (viz. DP-SGD) to significantly boost accuracy and convergence. Specifically, UDP-FL demonstrates enhanced model performance by mitigating the reliance on Gaussian noise. The key mediator variable in this transformation is the R'enyi Differential Privacy notion, which is carefully used to harmonize privacy budgets. We also propose an innovative method to theoretically analyze the convergence for DP-FL (including our UDP-FL ) based on mode connectivity analysis. Moreover, we evaluate our UDP-FL through extensive experiments benchmarked against state-of-the-art (SOTA) methods, demonstrating superior performance on both privacy guarantees and model performance. Notably, UDP-FL exhibits substantial resilience against different inference attacks, indicating a significant advance in safeguarding sensitive data in federated learning environments.
Read more7/25/2024
⚙️
0
FedLAP-DP: Federated Learning by Sharing Differentially Private Loss Approximations
Hui-Po Wang, Dingfan Chen, Raouf Kerkouche, Mario Fritz
Conventional gradient-sharing approaches for federated learning (FL), such as FedAvg, rely on aggregation of local models and often face performance degradation under differential privacy (DP) mechanisms or data heterogeneity, which can be attributed to the inconsistency between the local and global objectives. To address this issue, we propose FedLAP-DP, a novel privacy-preserving approach for FL. Our formulation involves clients synthesizing a small set of samples that approximate local loss landscapes by simulating the gradients of real images within a local region. Acting as loss surrogates, these synthetic samples are aggregated on the server side to uncover the global loss landscape and enable global optimization. Building upon these insights, we offer a new perspective to enforce record-level differential privacy in FL. A formal privacy analysis demonstrates that FedLAP-DP incurs the same privacy costs as typical gradient-sharing schemes while achieving an improved trade-off between privacy and utility. Extensive experiments validate the superiority of our approach across various datasets with highly skewed distributions in both DP and non-DP settings. Beyond the promising performance, our approach presents a faster convergence speed compared to typical gradient-sharing methods and opens up the possibility of trading communication costs for better performance by sending a larger set of synthetic images. The source is available at https://github.com/a514514772/FedLAP-DP.
Read more5/6/2024