Cooperative Coevolution for Non-Separable Large-Scale Black-Box Optimization: Convergence Analyses and Distributed Accelerations

Overview

• This paper analyzes and extends the large-scale version of the well-known cooperative coevolution (CC) framework, a divide-and-conquer black-box optimization approach, on non-separable functions.
• It reveals empirical insights into when decomposition-based methods are preferred or not in practice on certain non-separable large-scale problems.
• The paper formalizes CC as a continuous-game model to simplify the analysis of its convergence, focusing on the pure Nash equilibrium concept.
• Based on the convergence analyses, the authors propose a hierarchical decomposition strategy to address the risk of getting trapped in suboptimal Nash equilibria.
• The approach is accelerated using distributed computing under a multi-level learning framework that combines the fine-tuning ability of decomposition with the invariance property of CMA-ES.

Plain English Explanation

Many real-world optimization problems involve complex, non-separable functions that are difficult to solve. This paper explores a divide-and-conquer approach called cooperative coevolution (CC) to tackle these large-scale, non-separable problems.

The researchers first looked at when decomposition-based methods, like CC, work well and when they don't on certain non-separable problems. They then simplified the CC framework, modeling it as a continuous game, to better analyze how it converges. This allowed them to focus on the concept of a "pure Nash equilibrium," which is a stable point where no player can improve their outcome by changing their strategy unilaterally.

Based on this analysis, the researchers proposed a hierarchical decomposition strategy. This helps address the risk of getting stuck in a suboptimal Nash equilibrium, which can happen with decomposition approaches. To speed up the process, they used powerful distributed computing combined with a multi-level learning framework. This combines the fine-tuning ability of decomposition with the stability of a CMA-ES algorithm.

The researchers tested their approach on a set of high-dimensional problems and found it had strong search performance and was able to scale well as the number of CPU cores increased.

Technical Explanation

The paper begins by highlighting the ubiquity of non-separable optimization problems in the real world and the need for effective optimization frameworks to solve them at scale. The authors then analyze and extend the cooperative coevolution (CC) approach, a divide-and-conquer black-box optimization technique, for such non-separable large-scale problems.

First, the paper reveals empirical insights into when decomposition-based methods like CC are preferred or not in practice on certain non-separable large-scale problems. This is an aspect that has not been clearly addressed in many previous CC studies.

Next, the authors formalize the CC framework as a continuous-game model through simplification, without losing its essential properties. Unlike prior work using evolutionary game theory for CC, this new model provides a simpler yet useful perspective to analyze the convergence of CC, focusing solely on the pure Nash equilibrium concept.

Building on the convergence analyses, the researchers propose a hierarchical decomposition strategy to address the risk of getting trapped in suboptimal Nash equilibria, which can be a limitation of decomposition approaches. As discussed in this paper, local optima can be a challenge in complex optimization problems.

To accelerate the proposed method, the authors leverage powerful distributed computing under the multi-level learning framework. This combines the fine-tuning ability of decomposition with the invariance property of the CMA-ES algorithm, as explored in this related work.

The paper evaluates the search performance and scalability of the approach on a set of high-dimensional test functions using a clustering computing platform with 400 CPU cores. This experiment design is similar to the black-box optimization approach for non-stationary multi-agent systems and the self-improved learning for scalable neural combinatorial optimization.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a comprehensive analysis and extension of the cooperative coevolution (CC) framework for tackling non-separable large-scale optimization problems. The insights into when decomposition-based methods are preferred or not in practice are valuable, as they can help guide the selection of appropriate optimization techniques for different problem domains.

The formalization of CC as a continuous-game model is a clever simplification that enables a more straightforward analysis of its convergence properties. By focusing on the pure Nash equilibrium concept, the authors have developed a more general approach that can be applied to a wider range of fitness landscapes.

The proposed hierarchical decomposition strategy is a promising solution to the risk of getting trapped in suboptimal Nash equilibria, which is an important limitation of decomposition-based methods. However, the efficacy of this approach may depend on the specific problem structure and the ability to identify appropriate decomposition strategies.

The use of distributed computing and the multi-level learning framework is a sensible approach to accelerate the optimization process. However, the performance and scalability of this technique may be influenced by factors such as the problem complexity, the available computational resources, and the efficiency of the implementation.

One potential area for further research could be the exploration of more adaptive or self-organizing decomposition strategies that can dynamically adjust to the problem landscape, potentially reducing the risk of suboptimal convergence. Additionally, the incorporation of more advanced techniques, such as multi-objective optimization or constrained optimization, could further expand the applicability of the proposed framework.

Conclusion

This paper presents a comprehensive analysis and extension of the cooperative coevolution (CC) framework for solving large-scale, non-separable optimization problems. By revealing empirical insights, formalizing CC as a continuous-game model, and proposing a hierarchical decomposition strategy, the authors have developed a more robust and scalable approach to this challenging class of optimization problems.

The integration of distributed computing and multi-level learning techniques has demonstrated the ability to accelerate the optimization process while maintaining strong search performance. This work contributes to the ongoing efforts in the field of black-box optimization, expanding the capabilities of divide-and-conquer approaches to tackle increasingly complex real-world problems.