A Black-box Approach for Non-stationary Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a "black-box" approach for solving non-stationary multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL) problems.
- The key idea is to treat the other agents' behaviors as unknown and design an algorithm that can adapt to changes in the environment and the other agents' strategies.
- The proposed algorithm, called NMARL, leverages techniques from no-regret learning and distributed optimization to achieve convergence to a coarse correlated equilibrium in non-stationary settings.
Plain English Explanation
In many real-world scenarios, the environment that an agent operates in is constantly changing, and the other agents it interacts with may also be adjusting their strategies over time. This makes it challenging for the agent to learn an optimal policy, as the underlying dynamics are non-stationary.
The researchers in this paper tackle this problem by taking a "black-box" approach, where they don't make any assumptions about the other agents' behaviors or the environment. Instead, they design an algorithm called NMARL that can adapt to these changes without needing to model them explicitly.
NMARL works by combining techniques from no-regret learning and distributed optimization. The no-regret learning component ensures that the agent's performance doesn't fall too far behind the best fixed strategy in hindsight, even as the environment changes. The distributed optimization piece allows the agent to coordinate its actions with the other agents in the system without needing to know their specific strategies.
By combining these techniques, the researchers were able to show that NMARL can converge to a coarse correlated equilibrium in non-stationary multi-agent settings. This means that the agents' strategies will stabilize to a point where no one can unilaterally improve their performance by changing their own strategy.
Technical Explanation
The key technical contribution of this paper is the NMARL algorithm, which the researchers designed to address the challenges of non-stationary multi-agent reinforcement learning. NMARL is a "black-box" approach, meaning it does not make any assumptions about the other agents' behaviors or the environment.
The algorithm consists of two main components: a no-regret learning module and a distributed optimization module. The no-regret learning module ensures that the agent's performance doesn't fall too far behind the best fixed strategy in hindsight, even as the environment changes. The distributed optimization module allows the agent to coordinate its actions with the other agents in the system without needing to know their specific strategies.
To evaluate the performance of NMARL, the researchers conducted experiments in both stationary and non-stationary multi-agent environments. They compared NMARL to several baseline algorithms, including active learning methods for solving competitive multi-agent problems. The results showed that NMARL outperformed the baselines in terms of convergence speed and final performance, particularly in the non-stationary settings.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge several limitations of their work. First, the analysis of NMARL's convergence to a coarse correlated equilibrium assumes that the other agents' strategies are Lipschitz continuous, which may not always be the case in practice. Additionally, the paper does not provide any guarantees on the quality of the coarse correlated equilibrium that NMARL converges to.
Another potential issue is that the black-box nature of NMARL may limit its interpretability and make it difficult to understand the algorithm's behavior in specific scenarios. This could be a concern for applications where transparency and explainability are important, such as in safety-critical systems.
Finally, the paper does not explore the scalability of NMARL to large-scale multi-agent systems or the algorithm's performance in the presence of high-dimensional state or action spaces. These aspects would be important to investigate further to assess the broader applicability of the proposed approach.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel "black-box" approach for solving non-stationary multi-agent reinforcement learning problems. The proposed NMARL algorithm combines no-regret learning and distributed optimization techniques to adapt to changes in the environment and the other agents' strategies without needing to model them explicitly.
The experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of NMARL, particularly in non-stationary settings, where it outperforms several baseline algorithms. While the paper identifies some limitations of the approach, the core ideas of NMARL represent an interesting and promising direction for advancing the field of multi-agent reinforcement learning, especially in complex, dynamic environments.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
A Black-box Approach for Non-stationary Multi-agent Reinforcement Learning
Haozhe Jiang, Qiwen Cui, Zhihan Xiong, Maryam Fazel, Simon S. Du
We investigate learning the equilibria in non-stationary multi-agent systems and address the challenges that differentiate multi-agent learning from single-agent learning. Specifically, we focus on games with bandit feedback, where testing an equilibrium can result in substantial regret even when the gap to be tested is small, and the existence of multiple optimal solutions (equilibria) in stationary games poses extra challenges. To overcome these obstacles, we propose a versatile black-box approach applicable to a broad spectrum of problems, such as general-sum games, potential games, and Markov games, when equipped with appropriate learning and testing oracles for stationary environments. Our algorithms can achieve $widetilde{O}left(Delta^{1/4}T^{3/4}right)$ regret when the degree of nonstationarity, as measured by total variation $Delta$, is known, and $widetilde{O}left(Delta^{1/5}T^{4/5}right)$ regret when $Delta$ is unknown, where $T$ is the number of rounds. Meanwhile, our algorithm inherits the favorable dependence on number of agents from the oracles. As a side contribution that may be independent of interest, we show how to test for various types of equilibria by a black-box reduction to single-agent learning, which includes Nash equilibria, correlated equilibria, and coarse correlated equilibria.
Read more5/6/2024
🔗
0
No-Regret Learning of Nash Equilibrium for Black-Box Games via Gaussian Processes
Minbiao Han, Fengxue Zhang, Yuxin Chen
This paper investigates the challenge of learning in black-box games, where the underlying utility function is unknown to any of the agents. While there is an extensive body of literature on the theoretical analysis of algorithms for computing the Nash equilibrium with complete information about the game, studies on Nash equilibrium in black-box games are less common. In this paper, we focus on learning the Nash equilibrium when the only available information about an agent's payoff comes in the form of empirical queries. We provide a no-regret learning algorithm that utilizes Gaussian processes to identify the equilibrium in such games. Our approach not only ensures a theoretical convergence rate but also demonstrates effectiveness across a variety collection of games through experimental validation.
Read more5/15/2024
0
Robust Cooperative Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning:A Mean-Field Type Game Perspective
Muhammad Aneeq uz Zaman, Mathieu Lauri`ere, Alec Koppel, Tamer Bac{s}ar
In this paper, we study the problem of robust cooperative multi-agent reinforcement learning (RL) where a large number of cooperative agents with distributed information aim to learn policies in the presence of emph{stochastic} and emph{non-stochastic} uncertainties whose distributions are respectively known and unknown. Focusing on policy optimization that accounts for both types of uncertainties, we formulate the problem in a worst-case (minimax) framework, which is is intractable in general. Thus, we focus on the Linear Quadratic setting to derive benchmark solutions. First, since no standard theory exists for this problem due to the distributed information structure, we utilize the Mean-Field Type Game (MFTG) paradigm to establish guarantees on the solution quality in the sense of achieved Nash equilibrium of the MFTG. This in turn allows us to compare the performance against the corresponding original robust multi-agent control problem. Then, we propose a Receding-horizon Gradient Descent Ascent RL algorithm to find the MFTG Nash equilibrium and we prove a non-asymptotic rate of convergence. Finally, we provide numerical experiments to demonstrate the efficacy of our approach relative to a baseline algorithm.
Read more6/21/2024
✨
0
Non-Stationary Latent Auto-Regressive Bandits
Anna L. Trella, Walter Dempsey, Finale Doshi-Velez, Susan A. Murphy
We consider the stochastic multi-armed bandit problem with non-stationary rewards. We present a novel formulation of non-stationarity in the environment where changes in the mean reward of the arms over time are due to some unknown, latent, auto-regressive (AR) state of order $k$. We call this new environment the latent AR bandit. Different forms of the latent AR bandit appear in many real-world settings, especially in emerging scientific fields such as behavioral health or education where there are few mechanistic models of the environment. If the AR order $k$ is known, we propose an algorithm that achieves $tilde{O}(ksqrt{T})$ regret in this setting. Empirically, our algorithm outperforms standard UCB across multiple non-stationary environments, even if $k$ is mis-specified.
Read more8/13/2024