COT: A Generative Approach for Hate Speech Counter-Narratives via Contrastive Optimal Transport
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel approach called Contrastive Optimal Transport (COT) for generating hate speech counter-narratives.
- COT uses self-contrastive learning and target-oriented search to produce counter-narratives that effectively challenge and refute hate speech.
- The proposed method outperforms existing approaches in generating high-quality, diverse, and targeted counter-narratives.
Plain English Explanation
The goal of this research is to develop a way to automatically generate responses that counter hate speech online. Hate speech can be harmful and spread misinformation, so finding ways to challenge it is important.
The researchers developed a technique called Contrastive Optimal Transport (COT) to generate these counter-narratives. COT uses a type of machine learning called self-contrastive learning to produce counter-narratives that are very different from the original hate speech. It also focuses the counter-narratives on specific targets or goals, like refuting a particular claim.
By using this targeted approach, the COT method is able to generate counter-narratives that are more effective at challenging hate speech compared to previous techniques. The counter-narratives are high-quality, diverse, and tailored to the specific hate speech they are responding to.
This research could be helpful for moderating online platforms and providing automated tools to combat the spread of hate speech and misinformation. The researchers also developed an enhanced dataset for training these types of systems.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this work is the use of Contrastive Optimal Transport (COT) to generate counter-narratives. COT combines self-contrastive learning with a target-oriented search process to produce counter-narratives that are highly distinct from the original hate speech while also being tailored to specific goals.
The self-contrastive learning component encourages the generated counter-narratives to be very different from the original hate speech, ensuring they provide a strong contrast. The target-oriented search then focuses the counter-narratives on challenging particular claims or messages in the hate speech.
The researchers also developed an enhanced dataset of hate speech and counter-narratives to train and evaluate the COT model. This dataset includes annotations to guide the target-oriented generation process.
Experiments show that the COT method outperforms existing counter-narrative generation approaches in terms of quality, diversity, and target-orientation. The generated counter-narratives are both effective at challenging hate speech and diverse enough to avoid repetition.
Critical Analysis
The COT approach represents an important step forward in the field of counter-narrative generation. By incorporating both self-contrastive learning and target-oriented search, the method is able to generate high-quality counter-narratives that are well-suited for the task of challenging hate speech.
However, the paper does acknowledge some limitations. The dataset used for training and evaluation, while enhanced, may still not capture the full complexity and diversity of real-world hate speech and counter-narratives. There is also an inherent difficulty in evaluating the real-world impact of such systems.
Furthermore, while the counter-narratives generated by COT are effective, there are still open questions about the best ways to deploy such systems in practice to combat hate speech online. Integrating these systems into content moderation workflows and ensuring they are used responsibly will require careful consideration.
Despite these limitations, the COT approach represents a promising direction for using optimal transport techniques in natural language processing applications. The ability to generate tailored, high-quality counter-narratives could be a valuable tool in the fight against online hate speech and misinformation.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach called Contrastive Optimal Transport (COT) for generating hate speech counter-narratives. COT combines self-contrastive learning and target-oriented search to produce counter-narratives that are highly distinct from the original hate speech while also being tailored to specific goals and claims.
Experiments show that the COT method outperforms existing counter-narrative generation approaches, producing high-quality, diverse, and effectively targeted responses. While the approach has some limitations, it represents an important step forward in the use of advanced natural language processing techniques to combat the spread of hate speech and misinformation online.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
COT: A Generative Approach for Hate Speech Counter-Narratives via Contrastive Optimal Transport
Linhao Zhang, Li Jin, Guangluan Xu, Xiaoyu Li, Xian Sun
Counter-narratives, which are direct responses consisting of non-aggressive fact-based arguments, have emerged as a highly effective approach to combat the proliferation of hate speech. Previous methodologies have primarily focused on fine-tuning and post-editing techniques to ensure the fluency of generated contents, while overlooking the critical aspects of individualization and relevance concerning the specific hatred targets, such as LGBT groups, immigrants, etc. This research paper introduces a novel framework based on contrastive optimal transport, which effectively addresses the challenges of maintaining target interaction and promoting diversification in generating counter-narratives. Firstly, an Optimal Transport Kernel (OTK) module is leveraged to incorporate hatred target information in the token representations, in which the comparison pairs are extracted between original and transported features. Secondly, a self-contrastive learning module is employed to address the issue of model degeneration. This module achieves this by generating an anisotropic distribution of token representations. Finally, a target-oriented search method is integrated as an improved decoding strategy to explicitly promote domain relevance and diversification in the inference process. This strategy modifies the model's confidence score by considering both token similarity and target relevance. Quantitative and qualitative experiments have been evaluated on two benchmark datasets, which demonstrate that our proposed model significantly outperforms current methods evaluated by metrics from multiple aspects.
Read more6/19/2024
🖼️
0
COT Flow: Learning Optimal-Transport Image Sampling and Editing by Contrastive Pairs
Xinrui Zu, Qian Tao
Diffusion models have demonstrated strong performance in sampling and editing multi-modal data with high generation quality, yet they suffer from the iterative generation process which is computationally expensive and slow. In addition, most methods are constrained to generate data from Gaussian noise, which limits their sampling and editing flexibility. To overcome both disadvantages, we present Contrastive Optimal Transport Flow (COT Flow), a new method that achieves fast and high-quality generation with improved zero-shot editing flexibility compared to previous diffusion models. Benefiting from optimal transport (OT), our method has no limitation on the prior distribution, enabling unpaired image-to-image (I2I) translation and doubling the editable space (at both the start and end of the trajectory) compared to other zero-shot editing methods. In terms of quality, COT Flow can generate competitive results in merely one step compared to previous state-of-the-art unpaired image-to-image (I2I) translation methods. To highlight the advantages of COT Flow through the introduction of OT, we introduce the COT Editor to perform user-guided editing with excellent flexibility and quality. The code will be released at https://github.com/zuxinrui/cot_flow.
Read more6/19/2024
0
HateCOT: An Explanation-Enhanced Dataset for Generalizable Offensive Speech Detection via Large Language Models
Huy Nghiem, Hal Daum'e III
The widespread use of social media necessitates reliable and efficient detection of offensive content to mitigate harmful effects. Although sophisticated models perform well on individual datasets, they often fail to generalize due to varying definitions and labeling of offensive content. In this paper, we introduce HateCOT, an English dataset with over 52,000 samples from diverse sources, featuring explanations generated by GPT-3.5Turbo and curated by humans. We demonstrate that pretraining on HateCOT significantly enhances the performance of open-source Large Language Models on three benchmark datasets for offensive content detection in both zero-shot and few-shot settings, despite differences in domain and task. Additionally, HateCOT facilitates effective K-shot fine-tuning of LLMs with limited data and improves the quality of their explanations, as confirmed by our human evaluation.
Read more6/18/2024
📉
0
Distributional Counterfactual Explanation With Optimal Transport
Lei You, Lele Cao, Mattias Nilsson, Bo Zhao, Lei Lei
Counterfactual explanations (CE) are the de facto method of providing insight and interpretability in black-box decision-making models by identifying alternative input instances that lead to different outcomes. This paper extends the concept of CE to a distributional context, broadening the scope from individual data points to entire input and output distributions, named distributional counterfactual explanation (DCE). In DCE, we take the stakeholder's perspective and shift focus to analyzing the distributional properties of the factual and counterfactual, drawing parallels to the classical approach of assessing individual instances and their resulting decisions. We leverage optimal transport (OT) to frame a chance-constrained optimization problem, aiming to derive a counterfactual distribution that closely aligns with its factual counterpart, substantiated by statistical confidence. Our proposed optimization method, Discount, strategically balances this confidence in both the input and output distributions. This algorithm is accompanied by an analysis of its convergence rate. The efficacy of our proposed method is substantiated through a series of quantitative and qualitative experiments, highlighting its potential to provide deep insights into decision-making models.
Read more5/28/2024