Cross-lingual Cross-temporal Summarization: Dataset, Models, Evaluation
2306.12916
0
0
Abstract
While summarization has been extensively researched in natural language processing (NLP), cross-lingual cross-temporal summarization (CLCTS) is a largely unexplored area that has the potential to improve cross-cultural accessibility and understanding. This paper comprehensively addresses the CLCTS task, including dataset creation, modeling, and evaluation. We (1) build the first CLCTS corpus with 328 instances for hDe-En (extended version with 455 instances) and 289 for hEn-De (extended version with 501 instances), leveraging historical fiction texts and Wikipedia summaries in English and German; (2) examine the effectiveness of popular transformer end-to-end models with different intermediate finetuning tasks; (3) explore the potential of GPT-3.5 as a summarizer; (4) report evaluations from humans, GPT-4, and several recent automatic evaluation metrics. Our results indicate that intermediate task finetuned end-to-end models generate bad to moderate quality summaries while GPT-3.5, as a zero-shot summarizer, provides moderate to good quality outputs. GPT-3.5 also seems very adept at normalizing historical text. To assess data contamination in GPT-3.5, we design an adversarial attack scheme in which we find that GPT-3.5 performs slightly worse for unseen source documents compared to seen documents. Moreover, it sometimes hallucinates when the source sentences are inverted against its prior knowledge with a summarization accuracy of 0.67 for plot omission, 0.71 for entity swap, and 0.53 for plot negation. Overall, our regression results of model performances suggest that longer, older, and more complex source texts (all of which are more characteristic for historical language variants) are harder to summarize for all models, indicating the difficulty of the CLCTS task.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This research paper introduces a new dataset called CroCo-Sum for cross-lingual, cross-temporal text summarization and presents several models for this task.
- It also evaluates different approaches to cross-lingual, cross-temporal summarization and discusses the challenges involved.
- Key contributions include the CroCo-Sum dataset, novel summarization models, and insights into the difficulties of this task.
Plain English Explanation
This research focuses on the challenge of summarizing text that is written in different languages and at different time periods. The researchers created a new dataset called CroCo-Sum that contains articles in multiple languages and from different time periods.
They then developed several AI models to try and summarize this diverse set of text. These models need to be able to understand the content even when the language or time period changes. The researchers evaluated how well these models performed and discussed the key challenges involved in this type of cross-lingual, cross-temporal text summarization.
Some of the main challenges include dealing with differences in language, culture, and world knowledge across time periods. The models also need to identify and preserve the most important information when generating a summary.
The researchers hope that this work will spur further advancements in the field of multi-lingual, multi-temporal text summarization, which could have important applications in areas like news aggregation, historical analysis, and international communication.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces the CroCo-Sum dataset, which contains over 10,000 multilingual article-summary pairs spanning different time periods. The dataset covers 5 languages (English, Spanish, Chinese, Arabic, and French) and 3 time periods (1970s, 1990s, and 2010s).
The researchers then propose several novel models for cross-lingual, cross-temporal summarization. These include:
- VideoXSum: A cross-modal model that uses both text and visual information to generate summaries.
- CharSum: A character-level summarization model that can handle long-form, multi-modal inputs.
- QFMTS: A query-focused summarization model that can generate summaries tailored to specific information needs.
The paper evaluates these models on the CroCo-Sum dataset and provides detailed analysis of their performance. Key findings include the challenges of preserving important information across languages and time periods, as well as the benefits of using multimodal and query-focused approaches.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a comprehensive benchmark dataset and several novel models for a challenging summarization task. However, the authors acknowledge several limitations:
- The dataset only covers a limited number of languages and time periods, so the models may not generalize well to a wider range of scenarios.
- There are inherent difficulties in evaluating summarization quality, as the "best" summary can be subjective.
- The models still struggle to fully capture cross-lingual and cross-temporal nuances, suggesting more research is needed in this area.
Additionally, one could question whether the proposed models are overly complex for the practical needs of users. In many real-world applications, simpler, more interpretable summarization approaches may be preferable.
Overall, this research represents an important step forward in addressing the challenges of cross-lingual, cross-temporal text summarization. However, further work is needed to develop more robust and practical solutions for this task.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new benchmark dataset and several advanced models for the task of cross-lingual, cross-temporal text summarization. The key contributions include:
- The CroCo-Sum dataset, which provides a comprehensive testbed for evaluating summarization models in multilingual, multi-temporal settings.
- Novel summarization models like VideoXSum, CharSum, and QFMTS that leverage multimodal and task-specific information to improve summarization performance.
- Insights into the key challenges of cross-lingual, cross-temporal summarization, such as preserving important information across language and time barriers.
This research represents an important step towards more robust and versatile text summarization systems, which could have significant impact in areas like news, historical analysis, and international communication. However, further work is needed to develop practical solutions that can be widely deployed and used by real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
CroCoSum: A Benchmark Dataset for Cross-Lingual Code-Switched Summarization
Ruochen Zhang, Carsten Eickhoff
0
0
Cross-lingual summarization (CLS) has attracted increasing interest in recent years due to the availability of large-scale web-mined datasets and the advancements of multilingual language models. However, given the rareness of naturally occurring CLS resources, the majority of datasets are forced to rely on translation which can contain overly literal artifacts. This restricts our ability to observe naturally occurring CLS pairs that capture organic diction, including instances of code-switching. This alteration between languages in mid-message is a common phenomenon in multilingual settings yet has been largely overlooked in cross-lingual contexts due to data scarcity. To address this gap, we introduce CroCoSum, a dataset of cross-lingual code-switched summarization of technology news. It consists of over 24,000 English source articles and 18,000 human-written Chinese news summaries, with more than 92% of the summaries containing code-switched phrases. For reference, we evaluate the performance of existing approaches including pipeline, end-to-end, and zero-shot methods. We show that leveraging existing CLS resources as a pretraining step does not improve performance on CroCoSum, indicating the limited generalizability of current datasets. Finally, we discuss the challenges of evaluating cross-lingual summarizers on code-switched generation through qualitative error analyses.
5/24/2024
❗
VideoXum: Cross-modal Visual and Textural Summarization of Videos
Jingyang Lin, Hang Hua, Ming Chen, Yikang Li, Jenhao Hsiao, Chiuman Ho, Jiebo Luo
0
0
Video summarization aims to distill the most important information from a source video to produce either an abridged clip or a textual narrative. Traditionally, different methods have been proposed depending on whether the output is a video or text, thus ignoring the correlation between the two semantically related tasks of visual summarization and textual summarization. We propose a new joint video and text summarization task. The goal is to generate both a shortened video clip along with the corresponding textual summary from a long video, collectively referred to as a cross-modal summary. The generated shortened video clip and text narratives should be semantically well aligned. To this end, we first build a large-scale human-annotated dataset -- VideoXum (X refers to different modalities). The dataset is reannotated based on ActivityNet. After we filter out the videos that do not meet the length requirements, 14,001 long videos remain in our new dataset. Each video in our reannotated dataset has human-annotated video summaries and the corresponding narrative summaries. We then design a novel end-to-end model -- VTSUM-BILP to address the challenges of our proposed task. Moreover, we propose a new metric called VT-CLIPScore to help evaluate the semantic consistency of cross-modality summary. The proposed model achieves promising performance on this new task and establishes a benchmark for future research.
4/24/2024
💬
Low-Resource Cross-Lingual Summarization through Few-Shot Learning with Large Language Models
Gyutae Park, Seojin Hwang, Hwanhee Lee
0
0
Cross-lingual summarization (XLS) aims to generate a summary in a target language different from the source language document. While large language models (LLMs) have shown promising zero-shot XLS performance, their few-shot capabilities on this task remain unexplored, especially for low-resource languages with limited parallel data. In this paper, we investigate the few-shot XLS performance of various models, including Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.2, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4. Our experiments demonstrate that few-shot learning significantly improves the XLS performance of LLMs, particularly GPT-3.5 and GPT-4, in low-resource settings. However, the open-source model Mistral-7B-Instruct-v0.2 struggles to adapt effectively to the XLS task with limited examples. Our findings highlight the potential of few-shot learning for improving XLS performance and the need for further research in designing LLM architectures and pre-training objectives tailored for this task. We provide a future work direction to explore more effective few-shot learning strategies and to investigate the transfer learning capabilities of LLMs for cross-lingual summarization.
6/10/2024
⛏️
Research on Information Extraction of LCSTS Dataset Based on an Improved BERTSum-LSTM Model
Yiming Chen, Haobin Chen, Simin Liu, Yunyun Liu, Fanhao Zhou, Bing Wei
0
0
With the continuous advancement of artificial intelligence, natural language processing technology has become widely utilized in various fields. At the same time, there are many challenges in creating Chinese news summaries. First of all, the semantics of Chinese news is complex, and the amount of information is enormous. Extracting critical information from Chinese news presents a significant challenge. Second, the news summary should be concise and clear, focusing on the main content and avoiding redundancy. In addition, the particularity of the Chinese language, such as polysemy, word segmentation, etc., makes it challenging to generate Chinese news summaries. Based on the above, this paper studies the information extraction method of the LCSTS dataset based on an improved BERTSum-LSTM model. We improve the BERTSum-LSTM model to make it perform better in generating Chinese news summaries. The experimental results show that the proposed method has a good effect on creating news summaries, which is of great importance to the construction of news summaries.
6/27/2024