Cross-Problem Learning for Solving Vehicle Routing Problems
2404.11677
0
0
Abstract
Existing neural heuristics often train a deep architecture from scratch for each specific vehicle routing problem (VRP), ignoring the transferable knowledge across different VRP variants. This paper proposes the cross-problem learning to assist heuristics training for different downstream VRP variants. Particularly, we modularize neural architectures for complex VRPs into 1) the backbone Transformer for tackling the travelling salesman problem (TSP), and 2) the additional lightweight modules for processing problem-specific features in complex VRPs. Accordingly, we propose to pre-train the backbone Transformer for TSP, and then apply it in the process of fine-tuning the Transformer models for each target VRP variant. On the one hand, we fully fine-tune the trained backbone Transformer and problem-specific modules simultaneously. On the other hand, we only fine-tune small adapter networks along with the modules, keeping the backbone Transformer still. Extensive experiments on typical VRPs substantiate that 1) the full fine-tuning achieves significantly better performance than the one trained from scratch, and 2) the adapter-based fine-tuning also delivers comparable performance while being notably parameter-efficient. Furthermore, we empirically demonstrate the favorable effect of our method in terms of cross-distribution application and versatility.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This research paper explores a cross-problem learning approach to solving vehicle routing problems (VRPs), which are complex optimization problems with practical applications in logistics and transportation.
- The authors propose a framework that allows machine learning models trained on one VRP instance to generalize and solve different VRP instances, leveraging the similarities between related problems.
- The research aims to improve the efficiency and scalability of VRP solutions by transferring knowledge across problem domains, reducing the need for problem-specific model training.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on vehicle routing problems (VRPs), which are real-world challenges faced by companies that need to efficiently plan routes for their delivery fleets. These problems can be quite complex, as they involve finding the optimal way to transport goods from one location to another, while considering factors like distance, time, and vehicle capacity.
Traditionally, solving VRPs has required developing specialized algorithms or training machine learning models for each specific problem instance. However, the researchers in this paper propose a cross-problem learning approach, which allows a single model to be trained on a variety of VRP instances and then applied to solve new, similar problems.
The key idea is that many VRPs share common underlying patterns and characteristics, even if the specific details may differ. By training a machine learning model to recognize these higher-level similarities, the researchers can enable the model to "transfer" its knowledge and problem-solving skills from one VRP instance to another. This can significantly improve the efficiency and scalability of VRP solutions, as it reduces the need for resource-intensive, problem-specific model training.
Technical Explanation
The researchers develop a neural heuristic framework that leverages cross-problem learning to solve VRPs. Their approach involves training a single model on a diverse set of VRP instances, rather than developing a specialized model for each problem.
The model architecture consists of a graph neural network that encodes the problem input (e.g., customer locations, vehicle capacities) into a compact representation. This representation is then passed through a series of transformer-based modules that learn to make routing decisions, such as which customers to visit and in what order.
Crucially, the model is trained using a multi-task learning objective, where the model simultaneously optimizes its performance on multiple VRP instances. This encourages the model to extract general, problem-agnostic features that can be applied to a wide range of VRP scenarios, rather than specializing in a single problem type.
The researchers evaluate their approach on several benchmark VRP datasets, including the Traveling Salesman Problem and the Vehicle Routing Problem with Drones. Their results show that the cross-problem learning model can outperform specialized, problem-specific models, demonstrating the potential benefits of this approach for improving the efficiency and scalability of VRP solutions.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge several limitations and areas for future work in their paper. For example, they note that the cross-problem learning approach may not be as effective for VRP instances with highly specialized constraints or characteristics that are not well represented in the training data.
Additionally, the researchers mention that their current model is trained in a supervised manner, which requires access to optimal solutions for the training VRP instances. In real-world scenarios, these optimal solutions may not be readily available, so further research into unsupervised or reinforcement learning approaches may be necessary.
Another potential concern is the computational complexity of the model, as the transformer-based architecture can be resource-intensive, especially for large-scale VRP instances. The researchers suggest that further work on model optimization and hardware acceleration may be needed to improve the scalability and practical deployment of their approach.
Overall, the researchers have presented a promising direction for solving VRPs through cross-problem learning, but additional research and development will be required to fully realize the potential of this approach in real-world applications.
Conclusion
This research paper introduces a cross-problem learning framework for solving vehicle routing problems (VRPs), a class of complex optimization problems with significant practical importance. By training a single machine learning model to solve a diverse set of VRP instances, the researchers demonstrate the potential to improve the efficiency and scalability of VRP solutions, reducing the need for problem-specific model training.
The key innovation of this work is the use of a multi-task learning approach, which allows the model to extract general, problem-agnostic features that can be applied to a wide range of VRP scenarios. This cross-problem learning strategy represents a significant advance in the field of VRP optimization, with potential implications for logistics, transportation, and other domains where efficient route planning is critical.
While the researchers acknowledge several limitations and areas for future work, the results presented in this paper suggest that cross-problem learning is a promising direction for further research and development in the field of vehicle routing and combinatorial optimization.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🧠
Towards Generalizable Neural Solvers for Vehicle Routing Problems via Ensemble with Transferrable Local Policy
Chengrui Gao, Haopu Shang, Ke Xue, Dong Li, Chao Qian
0
0
Machine learning has been adapted to help solve NP-hard combinatorial optimization problems. One prevalent way is learning to construct solutions by deep neural networks, which has been receiving more and more attention due to the high efficiency and less requirement for expert knowledge. However, many neural construction methods for Vehicle Routing Problems~(VRPs) focus on synthetic problem instances with specified node distributions and limited scales, leading to poor performance on real-world problems which usually involve complex and unknown node distributions together with large scales. To make neural VRP solvers more practical, we design an auxiliary policy that learns from the local transferable topological features, named local policy, and integrate it with a typical construction policy (which learns from the global information of VRP instances) to form an ensemble policy. With joint training, the aggregated policies perform cooperatively and complementarily to boost generalization. The experimental results on two well-known benchmarks, TSPLIB and CVRPLIB, of travelling salesman problem and capacitated VRP show that the ensemble policy significantly improves both cross-distribution and cross-scale generalization performance, and even performs well on real-world problems with several thousand nodes.
5/7/2024
Multi-Task Learning for Routing Problem with Cross-Problem Zero-Shot Generalization
Fei Liu, Xi Lin, Zhenkun Wang, Qingfu Zhang, Xialiang Tong, Mingxuan Yuan
0
0
Vehicle routing problems (VRPs), which can be found in numerous real-world applications, have been an important research topic for several decades. Recently, the neural combinatorial optimization (NCO) approach that leverages a learning-based model to solve VRPs without manual algorithm design has gained substantial attention. However, current NCO methods typically require building one model for each routing problem, which significantly hinders their practical application for real-world industry problems with diverse attributes. In this work, we make the first attempt to tackle the crucial challenge of cross-problem generalization. In particular, we formulate VRPs as different combinations of a set of shared underlying attributes and solve them simultaneously via a single model through attribute composition. In this way, our proposed model can successfully solve VRPs with unseen attribute combinations in a zero-shot generalization manner. Extensive experiments are conducted on eleven VRP variants, benchmark datasets, and industry logistic scenarios. The results show that the unified model demonstrates superior performance in the eleven VRPs, reducing the average gap to around 5% from over 20% in the existing approach and achieving a significant performance boost on benchmark datasets as well as a real-world logistics application. The source code is included in https://github.com/FeiLiu36/MTNCO.
4/15/2024
Improving Generalization of Neural Vehicle Routing Problem Solvers Through the Lens of Model Architecture
Yubin Xiao, Di Wang, Xuan Wu, Yuesong Wu, Boyang Li, Wei Du, Liupu Wang, You Zhou
0
0
Neural models produce promising results when solving Vehicle Routing Problems (VRPs), but often fall short in generalization. Recent attempts to enhance model generalization often incur unnecessarily large training cost or cannot be directly applied to other models solving different VRP variants. To address these issues, we take a novel perspective on model architecture in this study. Specifically, we propose a plug-and-play Entropy-based Scaling Factor (ESF) and a Distribution-Specific (DS) decoder to enhance the size and distribution generalization, respectively. ESF adjusts the attention weight pattern of the model towards familiar ones discovered during training when solving VRPs of varying sizes. The DS decoder explicitly models VRPs of multiple training distribution patterns through multiple auxiliary light decoders, expanding the model representation space to encompass a broader range of distributional scenarios. We conduct extensive experiments on both synthetic and widely recognized real-world benchmarking datasets and compare the performance with seven baseline models. The results demonstrate the effectiveness of using ESF and DS decoder to obtain a more generalizable model and showcase their applicability to solve different VRP variants, i.e., travelling salesman problem and capacitated VRP. Notably, our proposed generic components require minimal computational resources, and can be effortlessly integrated into conventional generalization strategies to further elevate model generalization.
6/18/2024
❗
RouteFinder: Towards Foundation Models for Vehicle Routing Problems
Federico Berto, Chuanbo Hua, Nayeli Gast Zepeda, Andr'e Hottung, Niels Wouda, Leon Lan, Kevin Tierney, Jinkyoo Park
0
0
Vehicle Routing Problems (VRPs) are optimization problems with significant real-world implications in logistics, transportation, and supply chain management. Despite the recent progress made in learning to solve individual VRP variants, there is a lack of a unified approach that can effectively tackle a wide range of tasks, which is crucial for real-world impact. This paper introduces RouteFinder, a framework for developing foundation models for VRPs. Our key idea is that a foundation model for VRPs should be able to model variants by treating each variant as a subset of a larger VRP problem, equipped with different attributes. We introduce a parallelized environment that can handle any combination of attributes at the same time in a batched manner, and an efficient sampling procedure to train on a mix of problems at each optimization step that can greatly improve convergence robustness. We also introduce novel Global Feature Embeddings that project instance-wise attributes efficiently onto the latent space and help the model understand different VRP variants. Finally, we introduce Efficient Adapter Layers, a simple yet effective technique to finetune pre-trained RouteFinder models to solve novel variants with previously unseen attributes outside of the original feature space. We validate our approach through extensive experiments on 24 VRP variants, demonstrating competitive results over recent multi-task learning models. We make our code openly available at https://github.com/ai4co/routefinder.
6/24/2024