DASA: Delay-Adaptive Multi-Agent Stochastic Approximation
2403.17247
0
0
Abstract
We consider a setting in which $N$ agents aim to speedup a common Stochastic Approximation (SA) problem by acting in parallel and communicating with a central server. We assume that the up-link transmissions to the server are subject to asynchronous and potentially unbounded time-varying delays. To mitigate the effect of delays and stragglers while reaping the benefits of distributed computation, we propose texttt{DASA}, a Delay-Adaptive algorithm for multi-agent Stochastic Approximation. We provide a finite-time analysis of texttt{DASA} assuming that the agents' stochastic observation processes are independent Markov chains. Significantly advancing existing results, texttt{DASA} is the first algorithm whose convergence rate depends only on the mixing time $tau_{mix}$ and on the average delay $tau_{avg}$ while jointly achieving an $N$-fold convergence speedup under Markovian sampling. Our work is relevant for various SA applications, including multi-agent and distributed temporal difference (TD) learning, Q-learning and stochastic optimization with correlated data.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a new algorithm called DASA (Delay-Adaptive Multi-Agent Stochastic Approximation) for solving distributed optimization problems in the presence of communication delays.
- DASA aims to address the challenges of stale gradients and gradient delays in multi-agent systems, which can lead to slow convergence or even divergence.
- The algorithm dynamically adjusts the step size based on the observed delays, allowing it to efficiently navigate the tradeoff between delay-aware gradient updates and unbiased gradient estimations.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a common problem in distributed systems, where multiple agents (like computers or robots) need to work together to optimize some shared objective. For example, a group of self-driving cars might need to coordinate to find the fastest route through a city.
One challenge in these multi-agent systems is that there can be delays in the communication between the agents. If an agent acts on outdated information from its neighbors, it can slow down or even prevent the entire system from converging to an optimal solution.
DASA is a new algorithm that tries to address this challenge. It works by dynamically adjusting the "step size" that each agent uses when updating its own part of the solution. The step size controls how much the agent is willing to change its solution based on new information.
The key insight is that when communication delays are high, the agent should take smaller steps to avoid acting on stale information. Conversely, when delays are low, the agent can take larger steps to converge faster. DASA continuously monitors the delays and adjusts the step sizes accordingly.
By doing this, DASA aims to find a sweet spot - it can take full advantage of the available information without being thrown off track by outdated data. This allows the overall system to converge to an optimal solution more efficiently, even in the presence of communication delays.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the distributed optimization problem as a stochastic optimization task, where each agent maintains a local copy of the shared optimization variable. The agents communicate with their neighbors to exchange gradient information, but this communication is subject to random delays.
DASA is designed to address the challenges posed by these communication delays. The key components of the algorithm are:
-
Delay-Aware Gradient Estimation: Each agent maintains a history of its own past gradients and the gradients received from its neighbors. It then uses this history to construct a delay-aware gradient estimate, which accounts for the varying delays.
-
Adaptive Step Size: DASA dynamically adjusts the step size used by each agent based on the observed delays. Agents experiencing higher delays will use smaller step sizes to avoid divergence, while agents with lower delays can take larger steps to accelerate convergence.
-
Asynchronous Updates: The algorithm allows agents to perform updates asynchronously, without requiring strict coordination or synchronization. This makes DASA more robust to the communication delays and failures that can occur in real-world distributed systems.
The paper provides a rigorous convergence analysis of DASA, proving that it can converge to the optimal solution under mild technical assumptions. The analysis also characterizes the impact of the communication delays on the convergence rate and provides guidance on how to choose the algorithm's parameters.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed algorithm that addresses an important problem in distributed optimization. The key strength of DASA is its ability to dynamically adapt to communication delays, allowing it to maintain convergence even in the presence of stale gradient information.
One potential limitation is that the analysis assumes the delays are bounded and follow certain statistical properties. In practice, communication delays can be highly unpredictable, and the algorithm's performance may degrade if the delays do not match these assumptions.
Additionally, the paper does not consider the potential impact of network topology or agent failures on the algorithm's performance. In real-world distributed systems, the connectivity and reliability of the communication network can have a significant effect on the convergence of the optimization process.
Further research could explore extending DASA to handle more realistic delay models, as well as investigating its behavior in dynamic network settings with changing topologies and agent failures. Incorporating these aspects would help strengthen the practical applicability of the algorithm.
Conclusion
The DASA algorithm represents an important contribution to the field of distributed optimization, as it addresses a critical challenge posed by communication delays in multi-agent systems. By dynamically adapting the step sizes used by the agents, DASA can maintain convergence to the optimal solution even when faced with stale gradient information.
The theoretical analysis and experimental results presented in the paper suggest that DASA could be a valuable tool for a wide range of distributed optimization problems, from coordinating autonomous vehicles to optimizing the operations of large-scale industrial systems. As the field of distributed optimization continues to grow in importance, algorithms like DASA will play an increasingly crucial role in enabling efficient and robust solutions to complex real-world problems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Rate Analysis of Coupled Distributed Stochastic Approximation for Misspecified Optimization
Yaqun Yang, Jinlong Lei
0
0
We consider an $n$ agents distributed optimization problem with imperfect information characterized in a parametric sense, where the unknown parameter can be solved by a distinct distributed parameter learning problem. Though each agent only has access to its local parameter learning and computational problem, they mean to collaboratively minimize the average of their local cost functions. To address the special optimization problem, we propose a coupled distributed stochastic approximation algorithm, in which every agent updates the current beliefs of its unknown parameter and decision variable by stochastic approximation method; and then averages the beliefs and decision variables of its neighbors over network in consensus protocol. Our interest lies in the convergence analysis of this algorithm. We quantitatively characterize the factors that affect the algorithm performance, and prove that the mean-squared error of the decision variable is bounded by $mathcal{O}(frac{1}{nk})+mathcal{O}left(frac{1}{sqrt{n}(1-rho_w)}right)frac{1}{k^{1.5}}+mathcal{O}big(frac{1}{(1-rho_w)^2} big)frac{1}{k^2}$, where $k$ is the iteration count and $(1-rho_w)$ is the spectral gap of the network weighted adjacency matrix. It reveals that the network connectivity characterized by $(1-rho_w)$ only influences the high order of convergence rate, while the domain rate still acts the same as the centralized algorithm. In addition, we analyze that the transient iteration needed for reaching its dominant rate $mathcal{O}(frac{1}{nk})$ is $mathcal{O}(frac{n}{(1-rho_w)^2})$. Numerical experiments are carried out to demonstrate the theoretical results by taking different CPUs as agents, which is more applicable to real-world distributed scenarios.
4/23/2024
❗
Optimal and instance-dependent guarantees for Markovian linear stochastic approximation
Wenlong Mou, Ashwin Pananjady, Martin J. Wainwright, Peter L. Bartlett
0
0
We study stochastic approximation procedures for approximately solving a $d$-dimensional linear fixed point equation based on observing a trajectory of length $n$ from an ergodic Markov chain. We first exhibit a non-asymptotic bound of the order $t_{mathrm{mix}} tfrac{d}{n}$ on the squared error of the last iterate of a standard scheme, where $t_{mathrm{mix}}$ is a mixing time. We then prove a non-asymptotic instance-dependent bound on a suitably averaged sequence of iterates, with a leading term that matches the local asymptotic minimax limit, including sharp dependence on the parameters $(d, t_{mathrm{mix}})$ in the higher order terms. We complement these upper bounds with a non-asymptotic minimax lower bound that establishes the instance-optimality of the averaged SA estimator. We derive corollaries of these results for policy evaluation with Markov noise -- covering the TD($lambda$) family of algorithms for all $lambda in [0, 1)$ -- and linear autoregressive models. Our instance-dependent characterizations open the door to the design of fine-grained model selection procedures for hyperparameter tuning (e.g., choosing the value of $lambda$ when running the TD($lambda$) algorithm).
5/14/2024
SCAFFLSA: Taming Heterogeneity in Federated Linear Stochastic Approximation and TD Learning
Paul Mangold, Sergey Samsonov, Safwan Labbi, Ilya Levin, Reda Alami, Alexey Naumov, Eric Moulines
0
0
In this paper, we analyze the sample and communication complexity of the federated linear stochastic approximation (FedLSA) algorithm. We explicitly quantify the effects of local training with agent heterogeneity. We show that the communication complexity of FedLSA scales polynomially with the inverse of the desired accuracy $epsilon$. To overcome this, we propose SCAFFLSA a new variant of FedLSA that uses control variates to correct for client drift, and establish its sample and communication complexities. We show that for statistically heterogeneous agents, its communication complexity scales logarithmically with the desired accuracy, similar to Scaffnew. An important finding is that, compared to the existing results for Scaffnew, the sample complexity scales with the inverse of the number of agents, a property referred to as linear speed-up. Achieving this linear speed-up requires completely new theoretical arguments. We apply the proposed method to federated temporal difference learning with linear function approximation and analyze the corresponding complexity improvements.
5/28/2024
Distributed Stochastic Gradient Descent with Staleness: A Stochastic Delay Differential Equation Based Framework
Siyuan Yu, Wei Chen, H. Vincent Poor
0
0
Distributed stochastic gradient descent (SGD) has attracted considerable recent attention due to its potential for scaling computational resources, reducing training time, and helping protect user privacy in machine learning. However, the staggers and limited bandwidth may induce random computational/communication delays, thereby severely hindering the learning process. Therefore, how to accelerate asynchronous SGD by efficiently scheduling multiple workers is an important issue. In this paper, a unified framework is presented to analyze and optimize the convergence of asynchronous SGD based on stochastic delay differential equations (SDDEs) and the Poisson approximation of aggregated gradient arrivals. In particular, we present the run time and staleness of distributed SGD without a memorylessness assumption on the computation times. Given the learning rate, we reveal the relevant SDDE's damping coefficient and its delay statistics, as functions of the number of activated clients, staleness threshold, the eigenvalues of the Hessian matrix of the objective function, and the overall computational/communication delay. The formulated SDDE allows us to present both the distributed SGD's convergence condition and speed by calculating its characteristic roots, thereby optimizing the scheduling policies for asynchronous/event-triggered SGD. It is interestingly shown that increasing the number of activated workers does not necessarily accelerate distributed SGD due to staleness. Moreover, a small degree of staleness does not necessarily slow down the convergence, while a large degree of staleness will result in the divergence of distributed SGD. Numerical results demonstrate the potential of our SDDE framework, even in complex learning tasks with non-convex objective functions.
6/18/2024