Rate Analysis of Coupled Distributed Stochastic Approximation for Misspecified Optimization
2404.13669
0
0
Abstract
We consider an $n$ agents distributed optimization problem with imperfect information characterized in a parametric sense, where the unknown parameter can be solved by a distinct distributed parameter learning problem. Though each agent only has access to its local parameter learning and computational problem, they mean to collaboratively minimize the average of their local cost functions. To address the special optimization problem, we propose a coupled distributed stochastic approximation algorithm, in which every agent updates the current beliefs of its unknown parameter and decision variable by stochastic approximation method; and then averages the beliefs and decision variables of its neighbors over network in consensus protocol. Our interest lies in the convergence analysis of this algorithm. We quantitatively characterize the factors that affect the algorithm performance, and prove that the mean-squared error of the decision variable is bounded by $mathcal{O}(frac{1}{nk})+mathcal{O}left(frac{1}{sqrt{n}(1-rho_w)}right)frac{1}{k^{1.5}}+mathcal{O}big(frac{1}{(1-rho_w)^2} big)frac{1}{k^2}$, where $k$ is the iteration count and $(1-rho_w)$ is the spectral gap of the network weighted adjacency matrix. It reveals that the network connectivity characterized by $(1-rho_w)$ only influences the high order of convergence rate, while the domain rate still acts the same as the centralized algorithm. In addition, we analyze that the transient iteration needed for reaching its dominant rate $mathcal{O}(frac{1}{nk})$ is $mathcal{O}(frac{n}{(1-rho_w)^2})$. Numerical experiments are carried out to demonstrate the theoretical results by taking different CPUs as agents, which is more applicable to real-world distributed scenarios.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a rate analysis of a coupled distributed stochastic approximation method for optimizing a misspecified objective function.
- The method involves multiple agents collaboratively solving an optimization problem in a decentralized manner, with each agent maintaining its own model and updating it based on its local data and interactions with its neighbors.
- The authors analyze the convergence rate of this method and show that it can achieve a faster convergence rate compared to standard decentralized optimization approaches, even when the optimization problem is misspecified.
Plain English Explanation
This research paper looks at a way for multiple computers or "agents" to work together to solve a complex optimization problem, even if the problem is not fully understood or specified correctly. The key idea is that each agent maintains its own model of the problem, and they update their models by sharing information with their neighboring agents. This allows them to collaboratively find a good solution, even if the original problem definition was not quite right.
The researchers analyze how fast this approach can converge to a good solution, and they show that it can actually be faster than traditional decentralized optimization methods, even when the problem is not perfectly specified. This is an important result, as real-world optimization problems often have some level of uncertainty or imperfect understanding, and being able to still make progress efficiently is valuable.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a coupled distributed stochastic approximation (CDSA) method for solving a misspecified optimization problem in a decentralized setting. In this approach, multiple agents collaborate to optimize a shared objective function, with each agent maintaining its own local model and updating it based on its own data and interactions with its neighbors.
The authors analyze the convergence rate of this CDSA method and show that it can achieve a faster rate compared to standard decentralized optimization approaches, even when the optimization problem is misspecified, i.e., the objective function does not accurately reflect the true underlying problem.
The key technical contributions include:
- Formulating the misspecified optimization problem and the CDSA algorithm
- Establishing non-asymptotic convergence rate bounds for the CDSA method
- Comparing the convergence rate to that of standard decentralized stochastic approximation approaches
The analysis leverages tools from stochastic approximation, optimization, and graph theory to derive the convergence guarantees.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough theoretical analysis of the CDSA method and its advantages over traditional decentralized optimization approaches in the presence of model misspecification. However, the analysis is limited to the theoretical setting and does not include any empirical evaluations or comparisons to other state-of-the-art decentralized optimization techniques.
While the authors mention that the CDSA method can be applied to a variety of real-world optimization problems, they do not discuss any specific application domains or the practical challenges that may arise in implementing the method in realistic scenarios. Additionally, the paper does not address the sensitivity of the method to the choice of hyperparameters or the impact of network topology on the convergence behavior.
Further research could explore the empirical performance of the CDSA method, its robustness to various sources of model misspecification, and its applicability to a wider range of optimization problems and real-world use cases. Investigating the communication and computational efficiency of the method, as well as its scalability to large-scale distributed systems, would also be valuable extensions of this work.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel coupled distributed stochastic approximation (CDSA) method for solving misspecified optimization problems in a decentralized setting. The key contribution is the theoretical analysis demonstrating that the CDSA approach can achieve faster convergence rates compared to standard decentralized optimization techniques, even when the underlying optimization problem is not perfectly specified.
The results suggest that the CDSA method can be a promising approach for tackling complex real-world optimization problems, where perfect model knowledge may not be available. Further empirical and practical investigations are needed to fully understand the strengths and limitations of this method and its potential impact on various application domains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Scalable Decentralized Algorithms for Online Personalized Mean Estimation
Franco Galante, Giovanni Neglia, Emilio Leonardi
0
0
In numerous settings, agents lack sufficient data to directly learn a model. Collaborating with other agents may help, but it introduces a bias-variance trade-off, when local data distributions differ. A key challenge is for each agent to identify clients with similar distributions while learning the model, a problem that remains largely unresolved. This study focuses on a simplified version of the overarching problem, where each agent collects samples from a real-valued distribution over time to estimate its mean. Existing algorithms face impractical space and time complexities (quadratic in the number of agents A). To address scalability challenges, we propose a framework where agents self-organize into a graph, allowing each agent to communicate with only a selected number of peers r. We introduce two collaborative mean estimation algorithms: one draws inspiration from belief propagation, while the other employs a consensus-based approach, with complexity of O( r |A| log |A|) and O(r |A|), respectively. We establish conditions under which both algorithms yield asymptotically optimal estimates and offer a theoretical characterization of their performance.
5/9/2024
Decentralized Optimization in Time-Varying Networks with Arbitrary Delays
Tomas Ortega, Hamid Jafarkhani
0
0
We consider a decentralized optimization problem for networks affected by communication delays. Examples of such networks include collaborative machine learning, sensor networks, and multi-agent systems. To mimic communication delays, we add virtual non-computing nodes to the network, resulting in directed graphs. This motivates investigating decentralized optimization solutions on directed graphs. Existing solutions assume nodes know their out-degrees, resulting in limited applicability. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a novel gossip-based algorithm, called DT-GO, that does not need to know the out-degrees. The algorithm is applicable in general directed networks, for example networks with delays or limited acknowledgment capabilities. We derive convergence rates for both convex and non-convex objectives, showing that our algorithm achieves the same complexity order as centralized Stochastic Gradient Descent. In other words, the effects of the graph topology and delays are confined to higher-order terms. Additionally, we extend our analysis to accommodate time-varying network topologies. Numerical simulations are provided to support our theoretical findings.
5/31/2024
🛠️
Resilient Distributed Optimization for Multi-Agent Cyberphysical Systems
Michal Yemini, Angelia Nedi'c, Andrea J. Goldsmith, Stephanie Gil
0
0
This work focuses on the problem of distributed optimization in multi-agent cyberphysical systems, where a legitimate agents' iterates are influenced both by the values it receives from potentially malicious neighboring agents, and by its own self-serving target function. We develop a new algorithmic and analytical framework to achieve resilience for the class of problems where stochastic values of trust between agents exist and can be exploited. In this case we show that convergence to the true global optimal point can be recovered, both in mean and almost surely, even in the presence of malicious agents. Furthermore, we provide expected convergence rate guarantees in the form of upper bounds on the expected squared distance to the optimal value. Finally, numerical results are presented that validate our analytical convergence guarantees even when the malicious agents compose the majority of agents in the network and where existing methods fail to converge to the optimal nominal points.
6/7/2024
🛠️
A cutting-surface consensus approach for distributed robust optimization of multi-agent systems
Jun Fu, Xunhao Wu
0
0
A novel and fully distributed optimization method is proposed for the distributed robust convex program (DRCP) over a time-varying unbalanced directed network under the uniformly jointly strongly connected (UJSC) assumption. Firstly, a tractable approximated DRCP (ADRCP) is introduced by discretizing the semi-infinite constraints into a finite number of inequality constraints and restricting the right-hand side of the constraints with a positive parameter. This problem is iteratively solved by a distributed projected gradient algorithm proposed in this paper, which is based on epigraphic reformulation and subgradient projected algorithms. Secondly, a cutting-surface consensus approach is proposed for locating an approximately optimal consensus solution of the DRCP with guaranteed feasibility. This approach is based on iteratively approximating the DRCP by successively reducing the restriction parameter of the right-hand constraints and populating the cutting-surfaces into the existing finite set of constraints. Thirdly, to ensure finite-time termination of the distributed optimization, a distributed termination algorithm is developed based on consensus and zeroth-order stopping conditions under UJSC graphs. Fourthly, it is proved that the cutting-surface consensus approach terminates finitely and yields a feasible and approximate optimal solution for each agent. Finally, the effectiveness of the approach is illustrated through a numerical example.
6/18/2024