Data Assimilation with Machine Learning Surrogate Models: A Case Study with FourCastNet
2405.13180
0
0
📊
Abstract
Modern data-driven surrogate models for weather forecasting provide accurate short-term predictions but inaccurate and nonphysical long-term forecasts. This paper investigates online weather prediction using machine learning surrogates supplemented with partial and noisy observations. We empirically demonstrate and theoretically justify that, despite the long-time instability of the surrogates and the sparsity of the observations, filtering estimates can remain accurate in the long-time horizon. As a case study, we integrate FourCastNet, a state-of-the-art weather surrogate model, within a variational data assimilation framework using partial, noisy ERA5 data. Our results show that filtering estimates remain accurate over a year-long assimilation window and provide effective initial conditions for forecasting tasks, including extreme event prediction.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper investigates using machine learning models, called "surrogates," to make accurate short-term weather predictions, even with limited and noisy observational data.
- The researchers demonstrate that despite the long-term instability of these surrogate models, they can still provide accurate forecasts over longer time periods by integrating them with a data assimilation framework that incorporates partial and noisy observational data.
- As a case study, the researchers integrate a state-of-the-art weather surrogate model, FourCastNet, within a variational data assimilation framework using partial, noisy ERA5 data.
- The results show that the filtering estimates remain accurate over a year-long assimilation window and provide effective initial conditions for forecasting tasks, including extreme event prediction.
Plain English Explanation
Weather forecasting is a complex and challenging task, as the Earth's atmosphere is a highly dynamic and chaotic system. Traditional weather models are based on physical principles and require vast computational resources to simulate the various processes that govern the atmosphere's behavior. However, these models often struggle to make accurate long-term predictions, as small errors can quickly amplify over time.
To address this issue, researchers have turned to machine learning techniques, which can learn patterns in weather data and use them to make predictions. These "surrogate" models are often more efficient and can provide accurate short-term forecasts. However, they can also exhibit instability over longer time horizons, leading to inaccurate and unrealistic predictions.
This paper presents a novel approach that combines the power of machine learning surrogates with the integration of partial and noisy observational data. The researchers show that by using a data assimilation framework, they can maintain the accuracy of the surrogate model's predictions even over extended time periods. In other words, the model can "correct" itself by incorporating real-world data, ensuring that its forecasts remain grounded in physical reality.
As a case study, the researchers use a state-of-the-art weather surrogate model called FourCastNet and integrate it into a data assimilation system that leverages partial and noisy observational data from the ERA5 dataset. The results demonstrate that this approach can provide accurate weather forecasts over a year-long period, even for extreme weather events.
Technical Explanation
The researchers in this paper investigate the use of machine learning-based surrogate models for weather forecasting, particularly in the context of long-term predictions. Surrogate models, such as deep generative models, have shown promise in providing accurate short-term weather forecasts, but they often struggle with long-term stability and can produce non-physical, inaccurate predictions.
To address this challenge, the researchers propose integrating these surrogate models within a variational data assimilation framework, which allows the model to continuously incorporate partial and noisy observational data (in this case, from the ERA5 dataset). This integration helps to correct the long-term instability of the surrogate model and ensure that its predictions remain grounded in physical reality.
As a case study, the researchers use the FourCastNet model, a state-of-the-art weather surrogate, and demonstrate its performance within the data assimilation framework. The results show that the filtering estimates provided by this approach remain accurate over a year-long assimilation window and can effectively serve as initial conditions for long-term forecasting tasks, including the prediction of extreme weather events.
The theoretical justification for the effectiveness of this approach is based on the concept of bounded errors in the surrogate model's predictions. Even though the surrogate model may exhibit long-term instability, the researchers show that the data assimilation framework can keep the errors within bounded limits, ensuring the accuracy of the final forecasts.
This research builds upon previous work on efficient learning of accurate surrogates for complex systems and contributes to the ongoing efforts in the field of end-to-end AI-driven weather forecasting.
Critical Analysis
The researchers have provided a compelling solution to the challenge of long-term weather forecasting using machine learning surrogates. By integrating the surrogate model within a data assimilation framework, they have demonstrated the ability to maintain the accuracy of the predictions over extended time periods, even with limited and noisy observational data.
One potential limitation of the study is the specific choice of the FourCastNet model and the ERA5 dataset. While the researchers have shown the effectiveness of this approach in this particular case, it would be valuable to see how the framework performs with other state-of-the-art surrogate models and observational datasets. Additionally, the paper does not explore the computational efficiency of the data assimilation process, which could be an important factor in real-world deployment.
Furthermore, the researchers mention that the data assimilation framework can effectively provide initial conditions for forecasting tasks, including extreme event prediction. However, the paper does not delve into the specific performance of the model in predicting extreme weather events, which is a crucial aspect of weather forecasting. Exploring this aspect in more depth would help solidify the practical implications of the research.
Despite these potential areas for further investigation, the overall approach presented in the paper represents a significant advancement in the field of weather forecasting using machine learning techniques. By bridging the gap between the short-term accuracy of surrogate models and the long-term stability required for reliable forecasts, the researchers have developed a promising strategy that could have far-reaching implications for weather prediction and its applications in various domains.
Conclusion
This research paper presents a novel approach to weather forecasting that combines the power of machine learning-based surrogate models with the integration of partial and noisy observational data. The researchers demonstrate that by incorporating a data assimilation framework, they can maintain the accuracy of the surrogate model's predictions over extended time periods, even in the face of long-term instability and limited observational data.
The case study using the FourCastNet model and ERA5 dataset provides a compelling proof-of-concept, showcasing the potential of this approach to deliver accurate weather forecasts, including for extreme weather events. While further research is needed to explore the generalizability of the framework and its computational efficiency, this work represents a significant step forward in the field of end-to-end AI-driven weather forecasting.
By bridging the gap between the short-term accuracy of machine learning surrogates and the long-term stability required for reliable weather predictions, this research paves the way for more robust and effective weather forecasting systems that can have a profound impact on various sectors, from disaster preparedness to agriculture and beyond.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Neural Incremental Data Assimilation
Matthieu Blanke, Ronan Fablet, Marc Lelarge
0
0
Data assimilation is a central problem in many geophysical applications, such as weather forecasting. It aims to estimate the state of a potentially large system, such as the atmosphere, from sparse observations, supplemented by prior physical knowledge. The size of the systems involved and the complexity of the underlying physical equations make it a challenging task from a computational point of view. Neural networks represent a promising method of emulating the physics at low cost, and therefore have the potential to considerably improve and accelerate data assimilation. In this work, we introduce a deep learning approach where the physical system is modeled as a sequence of coarse-to-fine Gaussian prior distributions parametrized by a neural network. This allows us to define an assimilation operator, which is trained in an end-to-end fashion to minimize the reconstruction error on a dataset with different observation processes. We illustrate our approach on chaotic dynamical physical systems with sparse observations, and compare it to traditional variational data assimilation methods.
6/24/2024
Urban Air Pollution Forecasting: a Machine Learning Approach leveraging Satellite Observations and Meteorological Forecasts
Giacomo Blanco, Luca Barco, Lorenzo Innocenti, Claudio Rossi
0
0
Air pollution poses a significant threat to public health and well-being, particularly in urban areas. This study introduces a series of machine-learning models that integrate data from the Sentinel-5P satellite, meteorological conditions, and topological characteristics to forecast future levels of five major pollutants. The investigation delineates the process of data collection, detailing the combination of diverse data sources utilized in the study. Through experiments conducted in the Milan metropolitan area, the models demonstrate their efficacy in predicting pollutant levels for the forthcoming day, achieving a percentage error of around 30%. The proposed models are advantageous as they are independent of monitoring stations, facilitating their use in areas without existing infrastructure. Additionally, we have released the collected dataset to the public, aiming to stimulate further research in this field. This research contributes to advancing our understanding of urban air quality dynamics and emphasizes the importance of amalgamating satellite, meteorological, and topographical data to develop robust pollution forecasting models.
5/31/2024
📈
Beyond Ensemble Averages: Leveraging Climate Model Ensembles for Subseasonal Forecasting
Elena Orlova, Haokun Liu, Raphael Rossellini, Benjamin A. Cash, Rebecca Willett
0
0
Producing high-quality forecasts of key climate variables, such as temperature and precipitation, on subseasonal time scales has long been a gap in operational forecasting. This study explores an application of machine learning (ML) models as post-processing tools for subseasonal forecasting. Lagged numerical ensemble forecasts (i.e., an ensemble where the members have different initialization dates) and observational data, including relative humidity, pressure at sea level, and geopotential height, are incorporated into various ML methods to predict monthly average precipitation and two-meter temperature two weeks in advance for the continental United States. For regression, quantile regression, and tercile classification tasks, we consider using linear models, random forests, convolutional neural networks, and stacked models (a multi-model approach based on the prediction of the individual ML models). Unlike previous ML approaches that often use ensemble mean alone, we leverage information embedded in the ensemble forecasts to enhance prediction accuracy. Additionally, we investigate extreme event predictions that are crucial for planning and mitigation efforts. Considering ensemble members as a collection of spatial forecasts, we explore different approaches to using spatial information. Trade-offs between different approaches may be mitigated with model stacking. Our proposed models outperform standard baselines such as climatological forecasts and ensemble means. In addition, we investigate feature importance, trade-offs between using the full ensemble or only the ensemble mean, and different modes of accounting for spatial variability.
6/5/2024
Validating Deep-Learning Weather Forecast Models on Recent High-Impact Extreme Events
Olivier C. Pasche, Jonathan Wider, Zhongwei Zhang, Jakob Zscheischler, Sebastian Engelke
0
0
The forecast accuracy of deep-learning-based weather prediction models is improving rapidly, leading many to speak of a second revolution in weather forecasting. With numerous methods being developed, and limited physical guarantees offered by deep-learning models, there is a critical need for comprehensive evaluation of these emerging techniques. While this need has been partly fulfilled by benchmark datasets, they provide little information on rare and impactful extreme events, or on compound impact metrics, for which model accuracy might degrade due to misrepresented dependencies between variables. To address these issues, we compare deep-learning weather prediction models (GraphCast, PanguWeather, FourCastNet) and ECMWF's high-resolution forecast (HRES) system in three case studies: the 2021 Pacific Northwest heatwave, the 2023 South Asian humid heatwave, and the North American winter storm in 2021. We find evidence that machine learning (ML) weather prediction models can locally achieve similar accuracy to HRES on record-shattering events such as the 2021 Pacific Northwest heatwave and even forecast the compound 2021 North American winter storm substantially better. However, extrapolating to extreme conditions may impact machine learning models more severely than HRES, as evidenced by the comparable or superior spatially- and temporally-aggregated forecast accuracy of HRES for the two heatwaves studied. The ML forecasts also lack variables required to assess the health risks of events such as the 2023 South Asian humid heatwave. Generally, case-study-driven, impact-centric evaluation can complement existing research, increase public trust, and aid in developing reliable ML weather prediction models.
4/30/2024