Data-Aware Gradient Compression for DML in Communication-Constrained Mobile Computing
0
🖼️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Distributed machine learning (DML) in mobile environments faces significant communication bottlenecks.
- Gradient compression has proven effective in addressing this issue, providing substantial benefits in limited bandwidth and metered data environments.
- However, it encounters severe performance drops in non-IID (non-independent and identically distributed) environments due to a one-size-fits-all compression approach that does not account for varying data volumes across workers.
- Assigning varying compression ratios to workers with distinct data distributions and volumes is a promising solution.
Plain English Explanation
Distributed machine learning, where multiple devices work together to train a model, faces a major challenge in mobile environments: the limited internet connections and data plans of the devices. <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/flattened-one-bit-stochastic-gradient-descent-compressed">Gradient compression</a> has been used to address this issue, reducing the amount of data that needs to be transmitted between devices and saving on bandwidth and data usage.
However, this one-size-fits-all approach to compression doesn't work well in situations where the data on the different devices is not evenly distributed or representative of the overall dataset (known as non-IID data). In these cases, applying the same compression ratio to all devices can significantly slow down the training process.
The researchers propose a solution that assigns different compression ratios to each device, based on the size and distribution of the data it holds. This allows the system to optimize the compression for each device, speeding up the overall training process, especially in situations with limited communication resources and highly imbalanced data.
Technical Explanation
The paper derives the convergence rate of distributed stochastic gradient descent (SGD) with non-uniform compression, revealing the complex relationship between model convergence and the compression ratios applied to individual workers (devices).
The researchers then frame the problem of assigning relative compression ratios as an n-variable chi-squared nonlinear optimization problem, constrained by a limited communication budget. They propose two algorithms to address this:
-
DAGC-R: This assigns more conservative compression to workers handling larger data volumes, recognizing that these workers play a more important role in the overall convergence.
-
DAGC-A: This is a computationally less demanding version of DAGC-R, designed to enhance the robustness of compression in non-IID scenarios on resource-constrained mobile devices.
The experiments conducted confirm that DAGC-A and DAGC-R can speed up the training process by up to 16.65% and 25.43% respectively, compared to uniform compression, when dealing with highly imbalanced data volume distribution and restricted communication.
Critical Analysis
The paper addresses an important challenge in distributed machine learning, particularly in mobile environments with limited communication resources. The proposed solutions of adaptively assigning compression ratios based on data distribution and volume are a promising approach to mitigate the performance issues encountered in non-IID scenarios.
However, the paper does not discuss the potential computational overhead of the optimization problem used to determine the compression ratios. While the DAGC-A algorithm is designed to be less computationally demanding, the feasibility and scalability of these approaches on resource-constrained mobile devices may still be a concern.
Additionally, the paper focuses on gradient compression as the primary technique for reducing communication overhead. Other <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/global-momentum-compression-sparse-communication-distributed-learning">communication-efficient</a> or <a href="https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/beyond-throughput-compression-ratios-towards-high-end">data-efficient</a> approaches, such as gradient sparsification or selective communication, could be explored in conjunction with the proposed adaptive compression techniques to further enhance the performance of distributed machine learning in mobile environments.
Conclusion
This research proposes a novel approach to address the communication bottlenecks in distributed machine learning for mobile environments. By adaptively assigning varying compression ratios to workers based on their data distribution and volume, the researchers have shown significant improvements in training speed, particularly in scenarios with highly imbalanced data and limited communication resources.
These findings have important implications for the deployment of distributed machine learning models on mobile devices, where bandwidth and data constraints are a significant challenge. The paper's insights could inform the development of more efficient and robust distributed learning systems, paving the way for a new generation of mobile AI applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🖼️
0
Data-Aware Gradient Compression for DML in Communication-Constrained Mobile Computing
Rongwei Lu, Yutong Jiang, Yinan Mao, Chen Tang, Bin Chen, Laizhong Cui, Zhi Wang
Distributed machine learning (DML) in mobile environments faces significant communication bottlenecks. Gradient compression has proven as an effective solution to this issue, offering substantial benefits in environments with limited bandwidth and metered data. Yet, it encounters severe performance drops in non-IID environments due to a one-size-fits-all compression approach, which does not account for the varying data volumes across workers. Assigning varying compression ratios to workers with distinct data distributions and volumes is therefore a promising solution. This work derives the convergence rate of distributed SGD with non-uniform compression, which reveals the intricate relationship between model convergence and the compression ratios applied to individual workers. Accordingly, we frame the relative compression ratio assignment as an $n$-variable chi-squared nonlinear optimization problem, constrained by a limited communication budget. We propose DAGC-R, which assigns conservative compression to workers handling larger data volumes. Recognizing the computational limitations of mobile devices, we propose the DAGC-A, which is computationally less demanding and enhances the robustness of compression in non-IID scenarios. Our experiments confirm that the DAGC-A and DAGC-R can speed up the training speed by up to $16.65%$ and $25.43%$ compared to the uniform compression respectively, when dealing with highly imbalanced data volume distribution and restricted communication.
Read more9/4/2024
0
Flattened one-bit stochastic gradient descent: compressed distributed optimization with controlled variance
Alexander Stollenwerk, Laurent Jacques
We propose a novel algorithm for distributed stochastic gradient descent (SGD) with compressed gradient communication in the parameter-server framework. Our gradient compression technique, named flattened one-bit stochastic gradient descent (FO-SGD), relies on two simple algorithmic ideas: (i) a one-bit quantization procedure leveraging the technique of dithering, and (ii) a randomized fast Walsh-Hadamard transform to flatten the stochastic gradient before quantization. As a result, the approximation of the true gradient in this scheme is biased, but it prevents commonly encountered algorithmic problems, such as exploding variance in the one-bit compression regime, deterioration of performance in the case of sparse gradients, and restrictive assumptions on the distribution of the stochastic gradients. In fact, we show SGD-like convergence guarantees under mild conditions. The compression technique can be used in both directions of worker-server communication, therefore admitting distributed optimization with full communication compression.
Read more5/21/2024
0
Beyond Throughput and Compression Ratios: Towards High End-to-end Utility of Gradient Compression
Wenchen Han, Shay Vargaftik, Michael Mitzenmacher, Brad Karp, Ran Ben Basat
Gradient aggregation has long been identified as a major bottleneck in today's large-scale distributed machine learning training systems. One promising solution to mitigate such bottlenecks is gradient compression, directly reducing communicated gradient data volume. However, in practice, many gradient compression schemes do not achieve acceleration of the training process while also preserving accuracy. In this work, we identify several common issues in previous gradient compression systems and evaluation methods. These issues include excessive computational overheads; incompatibility with all-reduce; and inappropriate evaluation metrics, such as not using an end-to-end metric or using a 32-bit baseline instead of a 16-bit baseline. We propose several general design and evaluation techniques to address these issues and provide guidelines for future work. Our preliminary evaluation shows that our techniques enhance the system's performance and provide a clearer understanding of the end-to-end utility of gradient compression methods.
Read more7/2/2024
0
Distributed Training of Large Graph Neural Networks with Variable Communication Rates
Juan Cervino, Md Asadullah Turja, Hesham Mostafa, Nageen Himayat, Alejandro Ribeiro
Training Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) on large graphs presents unique challenges due to the large memory and computing requirements. Distributed GNN training, where the graph is partitioned across multiple machines, is a common approach to training GNNs on large graphs. However, as the graph cannot generally be decomposed into small non-interacting components, data communication between the training machines quickly limits training speeds. Compressing the communicated node activations by a fixed amount improves the training speeds, but lowers the accuracy of the trained GNN. In this paper, we introduce a variable compression scheme for reducing the communication volume in distributed GNN training without compromising the accuracy of the learned model. Based on our theoretical analysis, we derive a variable compression method that converges to a solution equivalent to the full communication case, for all graph partitioning schemes. Our empirical results show that our method attains a comparable performance to the one obtained with full communication. We outperform full communication at any fixed compression ratio for any communication budget.
Read more6/26/2024