Dataset Decomposition: Faster LLM Training with Variable Sequence Length Curriculum

Overview

• Large language models (LLMs) are commonly trained on datasets of fixed-length token sequences
• These datasets are created by randomly concatenating documents and then dividing them into sequences of a predetermined length
• This method can lead to cross-document attention within a sequence, which is not desirable and is computationally inefficient
• Training on long sequences is also computationally prohibitive due to the quadratic cost of attention

Plain English Explanation

Large AI language models are typically trained on datasets of text that have been chopped up into small, uniform-length pieces. This is done by taking many different documents, mashing them together randomly, and then cutting the resulting jumble into sequences of a fixed length.

However, this approach has some issues. When a sequence includes content from multiple documents, the model can end up "paying attention" to connections between those documents, even though that's not really what we want it to learn. This cross-document attention is both unhelpful and computationally expensive.

Additionally, training models on very long sequences of text is just plain costly from a computational perspective, due to the way the attention mechanism works under the hood.

Technical Explanation

To address these challenges, the researchers introduce a new technique called "dataset decomposition." Instead of randomly concatenating documents, they decompose the dataset into a collection of "buckets," where each bucket contains sequences of the same length extracted from a single document.

During training, the model samples sequences of variable length from these buckets, rather than using fixed-length sequences. This avoids the cross-document attention issue and also reduces the overall computational cost, since the attention calculation is only performed on the actual length of each sequence, rather than a fixed maximum length.

The researchers show that this approach allows them to train an 8,000-token-context model at the same computational cost as a 2,000-token-context model using the traditional concatenation method. Experiments demonstrate that their technique significantly boosts performance on standard language tasks and long-context benchmarks, while also scaling effectively as the dataset size increases.

The paper also highlights the importance of the distribution and curriculum of sequence lengths during training, which can have a non-trivial impact on model performance.

Critical Analysis

The researchers present a thoughtful and well-designed solution to the challenges of training large language models on long sequences of text. By decomposing the dataset and using variable-length sequences, they are able to address the issues of cross-document attention and computational efficiency.

However, one potential limitation of the approach is that it may require more careful engineering and data preparation upfront, as the dataset needs to be organized into the appropriate buckets. This could add complexity and overhead compared to the simpler concatenation-and-chunking method.

Additionally, the paper does not explore the potential drawbacks or downsides of the variable-length training approach, such as any potential negative impacts on model performance or generalization. Further research may be needed to fully understand the tradeoffs and edge cases.

Overall, the researchers have made a valuable contribution to the field of large language model training, and their work highlights the importance of carefully designing the training data and process to optimize both performance and efficiency.

Conclusion

The paper introduces a novel dataset decomposition technique that addresses key challenges in training large language models on long sequences of text. By using variable-length sequences and a curriculum-based sampling approach, the researchers are able to avoid cross-document attention and significantly reduce the computational cost of training.

The results show that this method leads to substantial improvements in model performance on standard language tasks and long-context benchmarks, while also scaling effectively as the dataset size increases. The work underscores the importance of thoughtful dataset design and training approaches for large language models, and provides a promising direction for future research in this area.