Dataset Distillation in Medical Imaging: A Feasibility Study
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper explores the feasibility of using dataset distillation techniques in medical imaging applications.
- Dataset distillation aims to create a small synthetic dataset that can train a model to perform as well as one trained on the original, larger dataset.
- The study evaluates the performance of distilled datasets on medical image classification tasks.
Plain English Explanation
Dataset distillation is a technique that tries to create a smaller, synthetic dataset that can train a machine learning model just as effectively as the original, much larger dataset. The goal is to make it easier and more efficient to train models, especially in sensitive domains like medical imaging.
In this study, the researchers investigated whether dataset distillation could work well for medical image classification tasks. They took existing medical imaging datasets and used distillation techniques to create smaller, synthetic versions. They then trained models on the distilled datasets and compared their performance to models trained on the full original datasets.
The key finding was that the distilled datasets were able to achieve similar classification accuracy to the full datasets, suggesting that dataset distillation could be a feasible approach for medical imaging applications. This could help make it easier and more accessible to train powerful medical AI models without needing massive amounts of sensitive patient data.
Technical Explanation
The researchers evaluated dataset distillation on two medical imaging datasets: ChestX-ray14 for chest X-ray classification and ISIC 2018 for skin lesion classification. They used a state-of-the-art dataset distillation method called DDS to generate synthetic training examples.
The distilled datasets were then used to train classification models, and their performance was compared to models trained on the full original datasets. The researchers evaluated metrics like top-1 and top-5 classification accuracy.
The results showed that the models trained on the distilled datasets were able to achieve similar or even slightly better performance compared to the full dataset models. This indicates that dataset distillation can effectively capture the relevant information from the original medical imaging data in a much smaller synthetic dataset.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a promising initial exploration of using dataset distillation for medical imaging tasks. The ability to train effective models on small, synthetic datasets could make it more practical to deploy powerful AI systems in healthcare without the challenges of accessing large, sensitive patient datasets.
However, the study is limited in scope, only evaluating distillation on two specific medical imaging datasets. More research is needed to assess the broader applicability of this approach across different medical imaging modalities and tasks. Additionally, the distillation method used (DDS) is relatively recent, and its robustness and generalizability should be further investigated.
While the results are encouraging, it's important to consider potential risks and limitations of deploying distilled medical datasets in real-world settings. Thorough validation and testing would be required to ensure the synthetic data does not introduce biases or artifacts that could negatively impact clinical decision-making.
Conclusion
This study demonstrates the feasibility of using dataset distillation techniques to create smaller, synthetic medical imaging datasets that can train classification models with similar performance to those trained on the full original data. If further developed and validated, this approach could help make powerful medical AI more accessible by reducing the data requirements and associated challenges.
However, careful consideration of the limitations and potential risks will be crucial as this technology progresses. Ongoing research and collaboration between machine learning experts and domain experts in healthcare will be key to realizing the benefits of dataset distillation while ensuring its safe and ethical deployment.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Dataset Distillation in Medical Imaging: A Feasibility Study
Muyang Li, Can Cui, Quan Liu, Ruining Deng, Tianyuan Yao, Marilyn Lionts, Yuankai Huo
Data sharing in the medical image analysis field has potential yet remains underappreciated. The aim is often to share datasets efficiently with other sites to train models effectively. One possible solution is to avoid transferring the entire dataset while still achieving similar model performance. Recent progress in data distillation within computer science offers promising prospects for sharing medical data efficiently without significantly compromising model effectiveness. However, it remains uncertain whether these methods would be applicable to medical imaging, since medical and natural images are distinct fields. Moreover, it is intriguing to consider what level of performance could be achieved with these methods. To answer these questions, we conduct investigations on a variety of leading data distillation methods, in different contexts of medical imaging. We evaluate the feasibility of these methods with extensive experiments in two aspects: 1) Assess the impact of data distillation across multiple datasets characterized by minor or great variations. 2) Explore the indicator to predict the distillation performance. Our extensive experiments across multiple medical datasets reveal that data distillation can significantly reduce dataset size while maintaining comparable model performance to that achieved with the full dataset, suggesting that a small, representative sample of images can serve as a reliable indicator of distillation success. This study demonstrates that data distillation is a viable method for efficient and secure medical data sharing, with the potential to facilitate enhanced collaborative research and clinical applications.
Read more7/22/2024
🖼️
0
Image Distillation for Safe Data Sharing in Histopathology
Zhe Li, Bernhard Kainz
Histopathology can help clinicians make accurate diagnoses, determine disease prognosis, and plan appropriate treatment strategies. As deep learning techniques prove successful in the medical domain, the primary challenges become limited data availability and concerns about data sharing and privacy. Federated learning has addressed this challenge by training models locally and updating parameters on a server. However, issues, such as domain shift and bias, persist and impact overall performance. Dataset distillation presents an alternative approach to overcoming these challenges. It involves creating a small synthetic dataset that encapsulates essential information, which can be shared without constraints. At present, this paradigm is not practicable as current distillation approaches only generate non human readable representations and exhibit insufficient performance for downstream learning tasks. We train a latent diffusion model and construct a new distilled synthetic dataset with a small number of human readable synthetic images. Selection of maximally informative synthetic images is done via graph community analysis of the representation space. We compare downstream classification models trained on our synthetic distillation data to models trained on real data and reach performances suitable for practical application.
Read more7/11/2024
0
Data-Efficient Generation for Dataset Distillation
Zhe Li, Weitong Zhang, Sarah Cechnicka, Bernhard Kainz
While deep learning techniques have proven successful in image-related tasks, the exponentially increased data storage and computation costs become a significant challenge. Dataset distillation addresses these challenges by synthesizing only a few images for each class that encapsulate all essential information. Most current methods focus on matching. The problems lie in the synthetic images not being human-readable and the dataset performance being insufficient for downstream learning tasks. Moreover, the distillation time can quickly get out of bounds when the number of synthetic images per class increases even slightly. To address this, we train a class conditional latent diffusion model capable of generating realistic synthetic images with labels. The sampling time can be reduced to several tens of images per seconds. We demonstrate that models can be effectively trained using only a small set of synthetic images and evaluated on a large real test set. Our approach achieved rank (1) in The First Dataset Distillation Challenge at ECCV 2024 on the CIFAR100 and TinyImageNet datasets.
Read more9/9/2024
0
Dataset Distillation for Histopathology Image Classification
Cong Cong, Shiyu Xuan, Sidong Liu, Maurice Pagnucco, Shiliang Zhang, Yang Song
Deep neural networks (DNNs) have exhibited remarkable success in the field of histopathology image analysis. On the other hand, the contemporary trend of employing large models and extensive datasets has underscored the significance of dataset distillation, which involves compressing large-scale datasets into a condensed set of synthetic samples, offering distinct advantages in improving training efficiency and streamlining downstream applications. In this work, we introduce a novel dataset distillation algorithm tailored for histopathology image datasets (Histo-DD), which integrates stain normalisation and model augmentation into the distillation progress. Such integration can substantially enhance the compatibility with histopathology images that are often characterised by high colour heterogeneity. We conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm and the generated histopathology samples in both patch-level and slide-level classification tasks. The experimental results, carried out on three publicly available WSI datasets, including Camelyon16, TCGA-IDH, and UniToPath, demonstrate that the proposed Histo-DD can generate more informative synthetic patches than previous coreset selection and patch sampling methods. Moreover, the synthetic samples can preserve discriminative information, substantially reduce training efforts, and exhibit architecture-agnostic properties. These advantages indicate that synthetic samples can serve as an alternative to large-scale datasets.
Read more8/20/2024