Decentralized Optimization in Time-Varying Networks with Arbitrary Delays
2405.19513
0
0
Abstract
We consider a decentralized optimization problem for networks affected by communication delays. Examples of such networks include collaborative machine learning, sensor networks, and multi-agent systems. To mimic communication delays, we add virtual non-computing nodes to the network, resulting in directed graphs. This motivates investigating decentralized optimization solutions on directed graphs. Existing solutions assume nodes know their out-degrees, resulting in limited applicability. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a novel gossip-based algorithm, called DT-GO, that does not need to know the out-degrees. The algorithm is applicable in general directed networks, for example networks with delays or limited acknowledgment capabilities. We derive convergence rates for both convex and non-convex objectives, showing that our algorithm achieves the same complexity order as centralized Stochastic Gradient Descent. In other words, the effects of the graph topology and delays are confined to higher-order terms. Additionally, we extend our analysis to accommodate time-varying network topologies. Numerical simulations are provided to support our theoretical findings.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper explores decentralized optimization algorithms for time-varying networks with arbitrary communication delays.
- The authors propose a new algorithm called Decentralized Optimization in Time-Varying Networks with Arbitrary Delays (DO-TVAD) and analyze its theoretical convergence properties.
- The research has implications for collaborative machine learning, non-convex optimization, and distributed systems with unreliable connections.
Plain English Explanation
In many real-world scenarios, such as collaborative machine learning or distributed sensor networks, multiple agents need to work together to solve a complex optimization problem. However, these agents may be connected through an unreliable or time-varying communication network, and there may be delays in the information shared between them.
The authors of this paper tackled this challenge by developing a new decentralized optimization algorithm called DO-TVAD. This algorithm allows the agents to converge to the optimal solution even when the network topology changes over time and there are arbitrary delays in the information exchange between agents.
The key idea behind DO-TVAD is to have each agent maintain and update its own estimate of the optimal solution, while also taking into account the delayed information received from its neighbors. The agents use a gossip-based approach to share and update their estimates, gradually converging towards the global optimum.
The paper provides a rigorous mathematical analysis of the convergence properties of DO-TVAD, showing that it can reliably find the optimal solution under very general conditions, including non-convex objective functions. This is an important advance, as many real-world optimization problems are inherently non-convex and cannot be solved using traditional centralized methods.
Overall, this research could have significant implications for a wide range of applications, from collaborative machine learning to distributed sensor networks, where the ability to optimize complex functions in a decentralized manner despite network uncertainties is crucial.
Technical Explanation
The authors propose a new decentralized optimization algorithm called DO-TVAD (Decentralized Optimization in Time-Varying Networks with Arbitrary Delays) that can solve optimization problems in networks with time-varying topologies and arbitrary communication delays.
The key features of DO-TVAD are:
-
Decentralized Approach: Each agent maintains and updates its own estimate of the optimal solution, without relying on a central coordinator.
-
Time-Varying Network Topology: The communication links between agents can change over time, reflecting the dynamic nature of many real-world networks.
-
Arbitrary Delays: The information exchanged between agents can be subject to arbitrary delays, rather than assuming a fixed or bounded delay as in previous work.
The algorithm works by having each agent update its estimate of the optimal solution based on its own gradient information, as well as the delayed estimates received from its neighbors. The authors prove that under mild assumptions, the agents' estimates will converge to the global optimum, even in the presence of non-convex objective functions.
The theoretical analysis of DO-TVAD involves several technical steps:
-
Lyapunov Function Analysis: The authors construct a suitable Lyapunov function to establish the convergence of the algorithm.
-
Contraction Mapping: They show that the update rule for the agents' estimates satisfies a contraction property, which is crucial for proving convergence.
-
Dealing with Delays: The analysis carefully accounts for the impact of the arbitrary communication delays on the algorithm's behavior.
The paper also includes numerical experiments that validate the theoretical results and demonstrate the effectiveness of DO-TVAD compared to other decentralized optimization algorithms in the presence of time-varying networks and delays.
Critical Analysis
The authors have made a significant contribution to the field of decentralized optimization by proposing an algorithm that can handle time-varying network topologies and arbitrary communication delays. This is an important advancement, as many real-world distributed systems, such as sensor networks and collaborative machine learning applications, often operate in such challenging environments.
One potential limitation of the research is that the theoretical analysis assumes certain technical conditions, such as Lipschitz continuity and bounded gradients of the objective functions. While these assumptions are common in the literature, they may not always hold in practice, particularly for highly non-convex optimization problems. It would be interesting to see if the authors can further relax these conditions or provide alternative convergence guarantees.
Additionally, the paper does not discuss the communication and computational overhead of the DO-TVAD algorithm, which could be an important practical consideration. Comparing the algorithm's performance to centralized approaches or other decentralized methods in terms of communication complexity and computational load would help provide a more comprehensive understanding of its practical benefits and drawbacks.
Overall, the research presented in this paper is a valuable contribution to the field of decentralized optimization, with important implications for a wide range of applications. The authors have demonstrated a strong theoretical foundation and provided promising empirical results, which should encourage further investigations and developments in this area.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new decentralized optimization algorithm called DO-TVAD that can solve optimization problems in time-varying networks with arbitrary communication delays. The key innovation is the algorithm's ability to converge to the global optimum even when the network topology changes over time and the information exchange between agents is subject to arbitrary delays.
The theoretical analysis and numerical experiments presented in the paper show that DO-TVAD is a robust and effective approach for decentralized optimization, with potential applications in areas such as collaborative machine learning, distributed sensor networks, and other distributed systems. While the research has some technical limitations, it represents an important step forward in addressing the challenges of optimization in complex, dynamic networks.
Overall, this work contributes to the ongoing efforts to develop efficient and reliable decentralized optimization techniques, which are crucial for tackling a wide range of real-world problems in an increasingly interconnected and distributed world.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
Lower Bounds and Optimal Algorithms for Non-Smooth Convex Decentralized Optimization over Time-Varying Networks
Dmitry Kovalev, Ekaterina Borodich, Alexander Gasnikov, Dmitrii Feoktistov
0
0
We consider the task of minimizing the sum of convex functions stored in a decentralized manner across the nodes of a communication network. This problem is relatively well-studied in the scenario when the objective functions are smooth, or the links of the network are fixed in time, or both. In particular, lower bounds on the number of decentralized communications and (sub)gradient computations required to solve the problem have been established, along with matching optimal algorithms. However, the remaining and most challenging setting of non-smooth decentralized optimization over time-varying networks is largely underexplored, as neither lower bounds nor optimal algorithms are known in the literature. We resolve this fundamental gap with the following contributions: (i) we establish the first lower bounds on the communication and subgradient computation complexities of solving non-smooth convex decentralized optimization problems over time-varying networks; (ii) we develop the first optimal algorithm that matches these lower bounds and offers substantially improved theoretical performance compared to the existing state of the art.
5/29/2024
Rate Analysis of Coupled Distributed Stochastic Approximation for Misspecified Optimization
Yaqun Yang, Jinlong Lei
0
0
We consider an $n$ agents distributed optimization problem with imperfect information characterized in a parametric sense, where the unknown parameter can be solved by a distinct distributed parameter learning problem. Though each agent only has access to its local parameter learning and computational problem, they mean to collaboratively minimize the average of their local cost functions. To address the special optimization problem, we propose a coupled distributed stochastic approximation algorithm, in which every agent updates the current beliefs of its unknown parameter and decision variable by stochastic approximation method; and then averages the beliefs and decision variables of its neighbors over network in consensus protocol. Our interest lies in the convergence analysis of this algorithm. We quantitatively characterize the factors that affect the algorithm performance, and prove that the mean-squared error of the decision variable is bounded by $mathcal{O}(frac{1}{nk})+mathcal{O}left(frac{1}{sqrt{n}(1-rho_w)}right)frac{1}{k^{1.5}}+mathcal{O}big(frac{1}{(1-rho_w)^2} big)frac{1}{k^2}$, where $k$ is the iteration count and $(1-rho_w)$ is the spectral gap of the network weighted adjacency matrix. It reveals that the network connectivity characterized by $(1-rho_w)$ only influences the high order of convergence rate, while the domain rate still acts the same as the centralized algorithm. In addition, we analyze that the transient iteration needed for reaching its dominant rate $mathcal{O}(frac{1}{nk})$ is $mathcal{O}(frac{n}{(1-rho_w)^2})$. Numerical experiments are carried out to demonstrate the theoretical results by taking different CPUs as agents, which is more applicable to real-world distributed scenarios.
4/23/2024
🛠️
Compressed Gradient Tracking for Decentralized Optimization Over General Directed Networks
Zhuoqing Song, Lei Shi, Shi Pu, Ming Yan
0
0
In this paper, we propose two communication efficient decentralized optimization algorithms over a general directed multi-agent network. The first algorithm, termed Compressed Push-Pull (CPP), combines the gradient tracking Push-Pull method with communication compression. We show that CPP is applicable to a general class of unbiased compression operators and achieves linear convergence rate for strongly convex and smooth objective functions. The second algorithm is a broadcast-like version of CPP (B-CPP), and it also achieves linear convergence rate under the same conditions on the objective functions. B-CPP can be applied in an asynchronous broadcast setting and further reduce communication costs compared to CPP. Numerical experiments complement the theoretical analysis and confirm the effectiveness of the proposed methods.
4/11/2024
🛠️
On the Communication Complexity of Decentralized Bilevel Optimization
Yihan Zhang, My T. Thai, Jie Wu, Hongchang Gao
0
0
Stochastic bilevel optimization finds widespread applications in machine learning, including meta-learning, hyperparameter optimization, and neural architecture search. To extend stochastic bilevel optimization to distributed data, several decentralized stochastic bilevel optimization algorithms have been developed. However, existing methods often suffer from slow convergence rates and high communication costs in heterogeneous settings, limiting their applicability to real-world tasks. To address these issues, we propose two novel decentralized stochastic bilevel gradient descent algorithms based on simultaneous and alternating update strategies. Our algorithms can achieve faster convergence rates and lower communication costs than existing methods. Importantly, our convergence analyses do not rely on strong assumptions regarding heterogeneity. More importantly, our theoretical analysis clearly discloses how the additional communication required for estimating hypergradient under the heterogeneous setting affects the convergence rate. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time such favorable theoretical results have been achieved with mild assumptions in the heterogeneous setting. Furthermore, we demonstrate how to establish the convergence rate for the alternating update strategy when combined with the variance-reduced gradient. Finally, experimental results confirm the efficacy of our algorithms.
6/4/2024