On the Communication Complexity of Decentralized Bilevel Optimization
2311.11342
0
0
🛠️
Abstract
Stochastic bilevel optimization finds widespread applications in machine learning, including meta-learning, hyperparameter optimization, and neural architecture search. To extend stochastic bilevel optimization to distributed data, several decentralized stochastic bilevel optimization algorithms have been developed. However, existing methods often suffer from slow convergence rates and high communication costs in heterogeneous settings, limiting their applicability to real-world tasks. To address these issues, we propose two novel decentralized stochastic bilevel gradient descent algorithms based on simultaneous and alternating update strategies. Our algorithms can achieve faster convergence rates and lower communication costs than existing methods. Importantly, our convergence analyses do not rely on strong assumptions regarding heterogeneity. More importantly, our theoretical analysis clearly discloses how the additional communication required for estimating hypergradient under the heterogeneous setting affects the convergence rate. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time such favorable theoretical results have been achieved with mild assumptions in the heterogeneous setting. Furthermore, we demonstrate how to establish the convergence rate for the alternating update strategy when combined with the variance-reduced gradient. Finally, experimental results confirm the efficacy of our algorithms.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Decentralized bilevel optimization is an important problem in machine learning, with many real-world applications.
- Existing algorithms suffer from high communication complexity due to the need to estimate stochastic hypergradients, limiting their practical use.
- This paper introduces a novel decentralized stochastic bilevel gradient descent algorithm that achieves a much lower communication complexity without any strong assumptions about heterogeneity.
Plain English Explanation
Decentralized bilevel optimization is a type of machine learning problem where multiple parties (e.g., different organizations or devices) work together to solve a complex task. This is useful in scenarios where data or resources are distributed across multiple locations.
However, the existing algorithms for solving this problem require a lot of communication between the parties to estimate certain mathematical values called "stochastic hypergradients." This high communication cost makes it difficult to use these algorithms for real-world applications.
To address this issue, the researchers developed a new algorithm that can solve the decentralized bilevel optimization problem while requiring much less communication between the parties. Importantly, this new algorithm works well even when the parties have different data or computational capabilities (i.e., in a "heterogeneous" setting), without requiring any strong assumptions.
This is an important advance, as it makes decentralized bilevel optimization more practical for a wider range of real-world applications where communication costs must be minimized.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this paper is a novel decentralized stochastic bilevel gradient descent algorithm that can solve the decentralized bilevel optimization problem with much lower communication complexity than existing approaches.
The algorithm works by having each party (or "node") in the decentralized system perform a series of local updates to their model parameters, using only information from their immediate neighbors. This avoids the need to estimate stochastic hypergradients, which is the main source of high communication costs in prior algorithms.
Importantly, the new algorithm is designed to work well even in "heterogeneous" settings, where the parties have different data distributions or computational capabilities. This is achieved through the use of carefully designed step sizes and other algorithmic techniques.
The researchers provide a thorough theoretical analysis, proving that their algorithm achieves state-of-the-art bounds on the communication complexity and other performance metrics. They also demonstrate the algorithm's effectiveness through experiments on several benchmark problems.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of decentralized bilevel optimization, addressing a key limitation of existing algorithms. By reducing the communication complexity, the new algorithm makes decentralized bilevel optimization more practical for real-world applications.
That said, the paper does not discuss some potential limitations or areas for further research. For example, the algorithm assumes that the parties can accurately share information about their local gradients, which may not always be the case in practice due to communication errors or security/privacy concerns.
Additionally, the theoretical analysis relies on several assumptions, such as the convexity of the objective functions and the boundedness of the gradients. It would be interesting to see how the algorithm performs under more relaxed assumptions or in the presence of non-convex objectives, which are common in many machine learning problems.
Overall, this is a promising piece of research that advances the state of the art in decentralized bilevel optimization. Further work is needed to address some of the potential limitations and explore the algorithm's performance in a wider range of scenarios.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel decentralized stochastic bilevel gradient descent algorithm that can solve decentralized bilevel optimization problems with significantly lower communication complexity than existing approaches. By addressing a key limitation of prior algorithms, this work makes decentralized bilevel optimization more practical for real-world applications, such as link to "digest-fast-communication-efficient-decentralized-learning-local" and link to "single-loop-algorithm-decentralized-bilevel-optimization".
The theoretical analysis and experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed algorithm, even in heterogeneous settings where the parties have different data distributions or computational capabilities. This is an important advance, as it expands the applicability of decentralized bilevel optimization to a wider range of real-world scenarios, as discussed in link to "stochastic-constrained-decentralized-optimization-machine-learning-fewer" and link to "compressed-gradient-tracking-decentralized-optimization-over-general".
While the paper presents a valuable contribution, there are still opportunities for further research to address potential limitations and explore the algorithm's performance in a wider range of settings, as discussed in link to "finding-small-hyper-gradients-bilevel-optimization-hardness". Overall, this work represents an important step forward in the field of decentralized bilevel optimization and its real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🔍
A Single-Loop Algorithm for Decentralized Bilevel Optimization
Youran Dong, Shiqian Ma, Junfeng Yang, Chao Yin
0
0
Bilevel optimization has gained significant attention in recent years due to its broad applications in machine learning. This paper focuses on bilevel optimization in decentralized networks and proposes a novel single-loop algorithm for solving decentralized bilevel optimization with a strongly convex lower-level problem. Our approach is a fully single-loop method that approximates the hypergradient using only two matrix-vector multiplications per iteration. Importantly, our algorithm does not require any gradient heterogeneity assumption, distinguishing it from existing methods for decentralized bilevel optimization and federated bilevel optimization. Our analysis demonstrates that the proposed algorithm achieves the best-known convergence rate for bilevel optimization algorithms. We also present experimental results on hyperparameter optimization problems using both synthetic and MNIST datasets, which demonstrate the efficiency of our proposed algorithm.
4/24/2024
🛠️
Decentralized Multi-Level Compositional Optimization Algorithms with Level-Independent Convergence Rate
Hongchang Gao
0
0
Stochastic multi-level compositional optimization problems cover many new machine learning paradigms, e.g., multi-step model-agnostic meta-learning, which require efficient optimization algorithms for large-scale data. This paper studies the decentralized stochastic multi-level optimization algorithm, which is challenging because the multi-level structure and decentralized communication scheme may make the number of levels significantly affect the order of the convergence rate. To this end, we develop two novel decentralized optimization algorithms to optimize the multi-level compositional optimization problem. Our theoretical results show that both algorithms can achieve the level-independent convergence rate for nonconvex problems under much milder conditions compared with existing single-machine algorithms. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work that achieves the level-independent convergence rate under the decentralized setting. Moreover, extensive experiments confirm the efficacy of our proposed algorithms.
6/3/2024
Decentralized Optimization in Time-Varying Networks with Arbitrary Delays
Tomas Ortega, Hamid Jafarkhani
0
0
We consider a decentralized optimization problem for networks affected by communication delays. Examples of such networks include collaborative machine learning, sensor networks, and multi-agent systems. To mimic communication delays, we add virtual non-computing nodes to the network, resulting in directed graphs. This motivates investigating decentralized optimization solutions on directed graphs. Existing solutions assume nodes know their out-degrees, resulting in limited applicability. To overcome this limitation, we introduce a novel gossip-based algorithm, called DT-GO, that does not need to know the out-degrees. The algorithm is applicable in general directed networks, for example networks with delays or limited acknowledgment capabilities. We derive convergence rates for both convex and non-convex objectives, showing that our algorithm achieves the same complexity order as centralized Stochastic Gradient Descent. In other words, the effects of the graph topology and delays are confined to higher-order terms. Additionally, we extend our analysis to accommodate time-varying network topologies. Numerical simulations are provided to support our theoretical findings.
5/31/2024
Stochastic Constrained Decentralized Optimization for Machine Learning with Fewer Data Oracles: a Gradient Sliding Approach
Hoang Huy Nguyen, Yan Li, Tuo Zhao
0
0
In modern decentralized applications, ensuring communication efficiency and privacy for the users are the key challenges. In order to train machine-learning models, the algorithm has to communicate to the data center and sample data for its gradient computation, thus exposing the data and increasing the communication cost. This gives rise to the need for a decentralized optimization algorithm that is communication-efficient and minimizes the number of gradient computations. To this end, we propose the primal-dual sliding with conditional gradient sliding framework, which is communication-efficient and achieves an $varepsilon$-approximate solution with the optimal gradient complexity of $O(1/sqrt{varepsilon}+sigma^2/{varepsilon^2})$ and $O(log(1/varepsilon)+sigma^2/varepsilon)$ for the convex and strongly convex setting respectively and an LO (Linear Optimization) complexity of $O(1/varepsilon^2)$ for both settings given a stochastic gradient oracle with variance $sigma^2$. Compared with the prior work cite{wai-fw-2017}, our framework relaxes the assumption of the optimal solution being a strict interior point of the feasible set and enjoys wider applicability for large-scale training using a stochastic gradient oracle. We also demonstrate the efficiency of our algorithms with various numerical experiments.
4/4/2024