Decision Machines: An Extension of Decision Trees
2101.11347
0
0
🗣️
Abstract
Here is a compact representation of binary decision trees. We can explicitly draw the dependencies between prediction and binary tests in decision trees and construct a procedure to guide the input instance from the root to its exit leaf. And we provided a connection between decision trees and error-correcting output codes. Then we built a bridge from tree-based models to attention mechanisms.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Decision trees are an efficient way to handle tabular data.
- Conventional decision tree growth methods often result in suboptimal trees due to their greedy nature.
- The inherent structure of decision trees limits the options for parallel hardware implementation.
- The paper proposes a compact representation of binary decision trees to address these deficiencies.
Plain English Explanation
Decision trees are a popular machine learning technique for making predictions from tabular data. They work by repeatedly asking yes/no questions about the data, with each question leading to a different branch of the tree. This allows them to make complex predictions in an efficient and interpretable way.
However, the standard methods used to grow decision trees often result in suboptimal structures. They take a "greedy" approach, making locally optimal choices at each step without considering the long-term consequences. This can lead to trees that are larger and less accurate than necessary.
Additionally, the tree-like structure of decision trees makes it challenging to implement them efficiently on parallel hardware, such as GPUs. The inherent dependencies between the different branches of the tree make it difficult to take full advantage of the parallel processing capabilities of these hardware accelerators.
To address these issues, the paper proposes a new way of representing binary decision trees. By explicitly formulating the dependence of the prediction on the binary tests performed, the authors introduce a new interpretation of decision trees. This formulation can then be approximated using continuous functions, allowing the decision tree to be interpreted as a model combination method.
The authors also propose a "selection-prediction" scheme to unify various learning methods, including decision trees, within this new framework. This provides a more flexible and efficient way to leverage the strengths of different machine learning techniques.
Technical Explanation
The paper starts by observing that decision trees are an effective way to handle tabular data, as their tree-like structure allows for efficient traversal and prediction. However, the conventional methods used to grow decision trees often result in suboptimal trees due to their greedy nature. The authors also note that the inherent structure of decision trees limits the options for implementing them in parallel hardware.
To address these issues, the authors propose a compact representation of binary decision trees. They explicitly formulate the dependence of the prediction on the binary tests performed, and construct a function to guide the input sample from the root to the appropriate leaf node. This formulation allows for a new interpretation of binary decision trees.
The authors then approximate this formulation using continuous functions, which enables them to interpret the decision tree as a model combination method. They also propose a "selection-prediction" scheme to unify various learning methods, including decision trees, within this new framework.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel approach to representing and interpreting binary decision trees, which addresses some of the limitations of the conventional methods. By formulating the decision process as a continuous function, the authors open up new possibilities for optimizing the tree structure and implementing decision trees in parallel hardware.
However, the paper does not provide a detailed evaluation of the proposed approach, nor does it compare its performance to other state-of-the-art decision tree algorithms, such as those discussed in related works like Online Learning for Decision Trees, Data Selection: A General Principle for Building Small Interpretable Models, or Rethinking Decision Tree Traversal. Additionally, the authors do not address potential limitations or drawbacks of their approach, such as the computational overhead of the continuous function approximation or the impact on the interpretability of the decision trees.
Further research would be needed to fully assess the practical benefits and tradeoffs of the proposed method, particularly in comparison to existing decision tree algorithms and in the context of specific real-world applications. Nonetheless, the paper presents an intriguing new perspective on decision tree representation and opens up interesting avenues for future work in this area.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach to representing and interpreting binary decision trees, which aims to address some of the limitations of conventional decision tree growth methods. By explicitly formulating the dependence of the prediction on binary tests and approximating this formulation using continuous functions, the authors provide a new way of thinking about decision trees as a model combination method.
The proposed approach has the potential to enable more efficient and flexible implementation of decision trees, particularly in parallel hardware. However, further research is needed to fully evaluate the practical benefits and tradeoffs of this method compared to existing decision tree algorithms. Nonetheless, this work represents an intriguing and potentially transformative contribution to the field of machine learning and decision tree modeling.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Learning accurate and interpretable decision trees
Maria-Florina Balcan, Dravyansh Sharma
0
0
Decision trees are a popular tool in machine learning and yield easy-to-understand models. Several techniques have been proposed in the literature for learning a decision tree classifier, with different techniques working well for data from different domains. In this work, we develop approaches to design decision tree learning algorithms given repeated access to data from the same domain. We propose novel parameterized classes of node splitting criteria in top-down algorithms, which interpolate between popularly used entropy and Gini impurity based criteria, and provide theoretical bounds on the number of samples needed to learn the splitting function appropriate for the data at hand. We also study the sample complexity of tuning prior parameters in Bayesian decision tree learning, and extend our results to decision tree regression. We further consider the problem of tuning hyperparameters in pruning the decision tree for classical pruning algorithms including min-cost complexity pruning. We also study the interpretability of the learned decision trees and introduce a data-driven approach for optimizing the explainability versus accuracy trade-off using decision trees. Finally, we demonstrate the significance of our approach on real world datasets by learning data-specific decision trees which are simultaneously more accurate and interpretable.
5/28/2024
✨
Optimized Feature Generation for Tabular Data via LLMs with Decision Tree Reasoning
Jaehyun Nam, Kyuyoung Kim, Seunghyuk Oh, Jihoon Tack, Jaehyung Kim, Jinwoo Shin
0
0
Learning effective representations from raw data is crucial for the success of deep learning methods. However, in the tabular domain, practitioners often prefer augmenting raw column features over using learned representations, as conventional tree-based algorithms frequently outperform competing approaches. As a result, feature engineering methods that automatically generate candidate features have been widely used. While these approaches are often effective, there remains ambiguity in defining the space over which to search for candidate features. Moreover, they often rely solely on validation scores to select good features, neglecting valuable feedback from past experiments that could inform the planning of future experiments. To address the shortcomings, we propose a new tabular learning framework based on large language models (LLMs), coined Optimizing Column feature generator with decision Tree reasoning (OCTree). Our key idea is to leverage LLMs' reasoning capabilities to find good feature generation rules without manually specifying the search space and provide language-based reasoning information highlighting past experiments as feedback for iterative rule improvements. Here, we choose a decision tree as reasoning as it can be interpreted in natural language, effectively conveying knowledge of past experiments (i.e., the prediction models trained with the generated features) to the LLM. Our empirical results demonstrate that this simple framework consistently enhances the performance of various prediction models across diverse tabular benchmarks, outperforming competing automatic feature engineering methods.
6/14/2024
Improving the Validity of Decision Trees as Explanations
Jiri Nemecek, Tomas Pevny, Jakub Marecek
0
0
In classification and forecasting with tabular data, one often utilizes tree-based models. Those can be competitive with deep neural networks on tabular data and, under some conditions, explainable. The explainability depends on the depth of the tree and the accuracy in each leaf of the tree. We point out that decision trees containing leaves with unbalanced accuracy can provide misleading explanations. Low-accuracy leaves give less valid explanations, which could be interpreted as unfairness among subgroups utilizing these explanations. Here, we train a shallow tree with the objective of minimizing the maximum misclassification error across all leaf nodes. The shallow tree provides a global explanation, while the overall statistical performance of the shallow tree can become comparable to state-of-the-art methods (e.g., well-tuned XGBoost) by extending the leaves with further models.
6/5/2024
Online Learning of Decision Trees with Thompson Sampling
Ayman Chaouki, Jesse Read, Albert Bifet
0
0
Decision Trees are prominent prediction models for interpretable Machine Learning. They have been thoroughly researched, mostly in the batch setting with a fixed labelled dataset, leading to popular algorithms such as C4.5, ID3 and CART. Unfortunately, these methods are of heuristic nature, they rely on greedy splits offering no guarantees of global optimality and often leading to unnecessarily complex and hard-to-interpret Decision Trees. Recent breakthroughs addressed this suboptimality issue in the batch setting, but no such work has considered the online setting with data arriving in a stream. To this end, we devise a new Monte Carlo Tree Search algorithm, Thompson Sampling Decision Trees (TSDT), able to produce optimal Decision Trees in an online setting. We analyse our algorithm and prove its almost sure convergence to the optimal tree. Furthermore, we conduct extensive experiments to validate our findings empirically. The proposed TSDT outperforms existing algorithms on several benchmarks, all while presenting the practical advantage of being tailored to the online setting.
4/10/2024