DecoderLens: Layerwise Interpretation of Encoder-Decoder Transformers

Overview

• Researchers propose a new method called DecoderLens to interpret the internal workings of encoder-decoder Transformer models.
• DecoderLens allows the decoder to cross-attend to representations from intermediate encoder layers, instead of just the final encoder output.
• The method maps the model's internal vector representations to human-interpretable sequences of words or symbols.
• The researchers apply DecoderLens to models trained on tasks like question answering, logical reasoning, speech recognition, and machine translation.
• DecoderLens reveals specific subtasks that are solved at low or intermediate encoder layers, providing new insights into the information flow within these models.

Plain English Explanation

Transformer models have become very powerful for tasks like language understanding and generation. However, it can be challenging to understand how these complex models work internally. Researchers have developed various "interpretability" methods to try to shed light on the inner workings of Transformers.

In this paper, the researchers propose a new approach called DecoderLens. The key idea is to give the decoder part of the Transformer model the ability to "look" at the representations generated by the intermediate layers of the encoder, not just the final output. This allows the researchers to map the model's internal vector representations to sequences of words or symbols that humans can interpret.

The researchers apply DecoderLens to Transformer models trained on tasks like question answering, logical reasoning, speech recognition, and machine translation. By doing this, they're able to see specific subtasks that the models solve at different layers of the encoder. This provides valuable insights into how information flows through these powerful but complex models.

For example, the DecoderLens method might reveal that the lower encoder layers are focused on basic language understanding, while the higher layers are tackling more complex reasoning. This type of granular insight can help researchers and engineers better understand and improve Transformer-based models.

Technical Explanation

The researchers propose a new interpretability method called DecoderLens to analyze encoder-decoder Transformer models. Typically, these models use the final output of the encoder as the input to the decoder. In contrast, DecoderLens allows the decoder to attend to representations from intermediate encoder layers.

This approach maps the model's internal vector representations to human-interpretable sequences of words or symbols, similar to how the LogitLens method works for decoder-only Transformers. The researchers apply DecoderLens to Transformer models trained on a variety of tasks, including question answering, logical reasoning, speech recognition, and machine translation.

By analyzing the outputs of the DecoderLens, the researchers are able to identify specific subtasks that are solved at different layers of the encoder. For example, they find that lower encoder layers focus on basic language understanding, while higher layers tackle more complex reasoning. This provides valuable insights into the information flow and internal workings of these important model architectures.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that DecoderLens is a relatively simple method compared to some more complex interpretability techniques. However, they demonstrate that it is effective at revealing meaningful insights about the inner workings of encoder-decoder Transformer models.

One potential limitation is that the method relies on the ability of the decoder to accurately interpret the intermediate encoder representations. If there are significant mismatches between the encoder and decoder, the DecoderLens outputs may not fully capture the true nature of the encoder's internal processing.

Additionally, the researchers only apply DecoderLens to a limited set of tasks and model architectures. Further research would be needed to understand how well the method generalizes to a broader range of Transformer-based models and applications.

That said, the core idea of giving the decoder access to intermediate encoder representations is a clever and relatively simple approach to model interpretability. The insights gleaned from the DecoderLens experiments provide a valuable contribution to our understanding of how these powerful models function.

Conclusion

The DecoderLens method offers a new way to peek inside the "black box" of encoder-decoder Transformer models. By allowing the decoder to attend to intermediate encoder representations, the researchers are able to map the model's internal vector states to human-interpretable sequences of words or symbols.

Applying DecoderLens to a variety of Transformer-based models and tasks reveals specific subtasks that are solved at different layers of the encoder. This provides valuable insights into the information flow and internal workings of these important models, which can in turn help researchers and engineers better understand and improve them.

While DecoderLens is a relatively simple approach compared to some other interpretability techniques, its effectiveness in uncovering meaningful insights suggests it is a useful tool for analyzing the complex inner workings of Transformer-based architectures.