Decoding Speculative Decoding
2402.01528
0
0
Abstract
Speculative Decoding is a widely used technique to speed up inference for Large Language Models (LLMs) without sacrificing quality. When performing inference, speculative decoding uses a smaller draft model to generate speculative tokens and then uses the target LLM to verify those draft tokens. The speedup provided by speculative decoding heavily depends on the choice of the draft model. In this work, we perform a detailed study comprising over 350 experiments with LLaMA-65B and OPT-66B using speculative decoding and delineate the factors that affect the performance gain provided by speculative decoding. Our experiments indicate that the performance of speculative decoding depends heavily on the latency of the draft model, and the draft model's capability in language modeling does not correlate strongly with its performance in speculative decoding. Based on these insights we explore a new design space for draft models and design hardware-efficient draft models for speculative decoding. Our newly designed draft model for LLaMA-65B can provide 60% higher throughput than existing draft models and can generalize further to the LLaMA-2 model family and supervised fine-tuned models.
Get summaries of the top AI research delivered straight to your inbox:
Overview
- This paper discusses a technique called "speculative decoding" for improving the performance of large language models (LLMs) during inference.
- Speculative decoding involves making predictions about the upcoming tokens in a sequence before they are actually generated, allowing the model to start processing them in parallel and reducing overall inference time.
- The paper presents a new speculative decoding method and evaluates its effectiveness on several benchmark tasks compared to traditional decoding approaches.
Plain English Explanation
Imagine you're trying to read a book, but the pages keep arriving one at a time, and you have to wait for each page before you can start reading the next. That's a bit like how traditional language models work - they generate the text one word at a time, and have to wait for each word before they can start processing the next.
The speculative decoding technique is like getting all the pages of the book at once, so you can start reading the whole thing in parallel. The model makes an educated guess about what the next few words might be, and starts processing them even before it has generated those words. This allows the model to work more efficiently and produce the final text faster.
The researchers in this paper developed a new way of doing speculative decoding, and tested it on different language tasks to see how well it performed compared to traditional decoding methods. Their approach seems to be a promising way to speed up the performance of large language models, which are increasingly important for many real-world applications.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a new speculative decoding method for large language models (LLMs) that aims to improve inference speed. Speculative decoding involves predicting the upcoming tokens in a sequence before they are actually generated, allowing the model to start processing them in parallel and reducing the overall inference time.
The authors propose a speculative decoding approach that uses a separate prediction model to forecast the next few tokens, and then feeds those predictions into the main LLM. This allows the LLM to start processing the predicted tokens before they are confirmed, rather than waiting for the actual tokens to be generated sequentially.
The paper also introduces a lossless decoding method that ensures the output of the speculative decoding process matches the output of traditional decoding, without sacrificing accuracy.
The authors evaluate their speculative decoding approach on a variety of benchmark tasks, including text generation, text summarization, and question answering. They compare its performance to traditional greedy and beam search decoding, as well as other speculative decoding methods, and find that their approach can significantly reduce inference time without compromising model performance.
Additionally, the paper explores the use of early exit techniques to further speed up inference by allowing the model to stop processing a sequence as soon as it is confident in the output.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to improving the efficiency of large language models through speculative decoding. The authors have clearly put a lot of thought into the design of their method, and their experimental results demonstrate its effectiveness in reducing inference time across a range of tasks.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations or areas for further research. For example, the retrieval-based speculative decoding approach may be sensitive to the quality and coverage of the prediction model, which could limit its performance in some scenarios.
Additionally, the authors do not explore the impact of their approach on model robustness or safety, which are important considerations for real-world deployment of large language models. Further research may be needed to understand how speculative decoding affects the model's behavior in edge cases or adversarial settings.
Overall, the paper makes a valuable contribution to the field of large language model optimization, and the proposed speculative decoding technique appears to be a promising direction for improving the efficiency and practicality of these powerful models.
Conclusion
This paper presents a new speculative decoding method for large language models that can significantly reduce inference time without compromising model performance. By using a separate prediction model to forecast upcoming tokens, the approach allows the main language model to start processing those tokens in parallel, rather than waiting for them to be generated sequentially.
The authors' experimental results demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach across a variety of benchmark tasks, and the introduction of a lossless decoding method ensures that the output matches traditional decoding approaches. Additionally, the exploration of early exit techniques further enhances the efficiency of the model during inference.
As large language models continue to grow in size and capability, innovations like speculative decoding will be crucial for making these powerful models practical and deployable in real-world applications. The insights and techniques presented in this paper represent an important step forward in this direction, and should be of great interest to researchers and practitioners working in the field of natural language processing.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
On Speculative Decoding for Multimodal Large Language Models
Mukul Gagrani, Raghavv Goel, Wonseok Jeon, Junyoung Park, Mingu Lee, Christopher Lott
0
0
Inference with Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) is slow due to their large-language-model backbone which suffers from memory bandwidth bottleneck and generates tokens auto-regressively. In this paper, we explore the application of speculative decoding to enhance the inference efficiency of MLLMs, specifically the LLaVA 7B model. We show that a language-only model can serve as a good draft model for speculative decoding with LLaVA 7B, bypassing the need for image tokens and their associated processing components from the draft model. Our experiments across three different tasks show that speculative decoding can achieve a memory-bound speedup of up to 2.37$times$ using a 115M parameter language model that we trained from scratch. Additionally, we introduce a compact LLaVA draft model incorporating an image adapter, which shows marginal performance gains in image captioning while maintaining comparable results in other tasks.
4/16/2024
👀
Accelerating Speculative Decoding using Dynamic Speculation Length
Jonathan Mamou, Oren Pereg, Daniel Korat, Moshe Berchansky, Nadav Timor, Moshe Wasserblat, Roy Schwartz
0
0
Speculative decoding is a promising method for reducing the inference latency of large language models. The effectiveness of the method depends on the speculation length (SL) - the number of tokens generated by the draft model at each iteration. The vast majority of speculative decoding approaches use the same SL for all iterations. In this work, we show that this practice is suboptimal. We introduce DISCO, a DynamIc SpeCulation length Optimization method that uses a classifier to dynamically adjust the SL at each iteration, while provably preserving the decoding quality. Experiments with four benchmarks demonstrate average speedup gains of 10.3% relative to our best baselines.
5/8/2024
Direct Alignment of Draft Model for Speculative Decoding with Chat-Fine-Tuned LLMs
Raghavv Goel, Mukul Gagrani, Wonseok Jeon, Junyoung Park, Mingu Lee, Christopher Lott
0
0
Text generation with Large Language Models (LLMs) is known to be memory bound due to the combination of their auto-regressive nature, huge parameter counts, and limited memory bandwidths, often resulting in low token rates. Speculative decoding has been proposed as a solution for LLM inference acceleration. However, since draft models are often unavailable in the modern open-source LLM families, e.g., for Llama 2 7B, training a high-quality draft model is required to enable inference acceleration via speculative decoding. In this paper, we propose a simple draft model training framework for direct alignment to chat-capable target models. With the proposed framework, we train Llama 2 Chat Drafter 115M, a draft model for Llama 2 Chat 7B or larger, with only 1.64% of the original size. Our training framework only consists of pretraining, distillation dataset generation, and finetuning with knowledge distillation, with no additional alignment procedure. For the finetuning step, we use instruction-response pairs generated by target model for distillation in plausible data distribution, and propose a new Total Variation Distance++ (TVD++) loss that incorporates variance reduction techniques inspired from the policy gradient method in reinforcement learning. Our empirical results show that Llama 2 Chat Drafter 115M with speculative decoding achieves up to 2.3 block efficiency and 2.4$times$ speed-up relative to autoregressive decoding on various tasks with no further task-specific fine-tuning.
5/15/2024
💬
Beyond the Speculative Game: A Survey of Speculative Execution in Large Language Models
Chen Zhang, Zhuorui Liu, Dawei Song
0
0
With the increasingly giant scales of (causal) large language models (LLMs), the inference efficiency comes as one of the core concerns along the improved performance. In contrast to the memory footprint, the latency bottleneck seems to be of greater importance as there can be billions of requests to a LLM (e.g., GPT-4) per day. The bottleneck is mainly due to the autoregressive innateness of LLMs, where tokens can only be generated sequentially during decoding. To alleviate the bottleneck, the idea of speculative execution, which originates from the field of computer architecture, is introduced to LLM decoding in a textit{draft-then-verify} style. Under this regime, a sequence of tokens will be drafted in a fast pace by utilizing some heuristics, and then the tokens shall be verified in parallel by the LLM. As the costly sequential inference is parallelized, LLM decoding speed can be significantly boosted. Driven by the success of LLMs in recent couple of years, a growing literature in this direction has emerged. Yet, there lacks a position survey to summarize the current landscape and draw a roadmap for future development of this promising area. To meet this demand, we present the very first survey paper that reviews and unifies literature of speculative execution in LLMs (e.g., blockwise parallel decoding, speculative decoding, etc.) in a comprehensive framework and a systematic taxonomy. Based on the taxonomy, we present a critical review and comparative analysis of the current arts. Finally we highlight various key challenges and future directions to further develop the area.
4/24/2024