Decomposition-based Hierarchical Task Allocation and Planning for Multi-Robots under Hierarchical Temporal Logic Specifications
2308.10393
0
0
🔮
Abstract
Past research into robotic planning with temporal logic specifications, notably Linear Temporal Logic (LTL), was largely based on a single formula for individual or groups of robots. But with increasing task complexity, LTL formulas unavoidably grow lengthy, complicating interpretation and specification generation, and straining the computational capacities of the planners. A recent development has been the hierarchical representation of LTL~cite{luo2024simultaneous} that contains multiple temporal logic specifications, providing a more interpretable framework. However, the proposed planning algorithm assumes the independence of robots within each specification, limiting their application to multi-robot coordination with complex temporal constraints. In this work, we formulated a decomposition-based hierarchical framework. At the high level, each specification is first decomposed into a set of atomic sub-tasks. We further infer the temporal relations among the sub-tasks of different specifications to construct a task network. Subsequently, a Mixed Integer Linear Program is used to assign sub-tasks to various robots. At the lower level, domain-specific controllers are employed to execute sub-tasks. Our approach was experimentally applied to domains of navigation and manipulation. The simulation demonstrated that our approach can find better solutions using less runtimes.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper addresses the challenge of creating robotic planning algorithms that can handle complex temporal logic specifications, such as Linear Temporal Logic (LTL).
- Traditional LTL-based planning approaches struggle as the specifications grow more complex, leading to lengthy formulas that are difficult to interpret and computationally demanding.
- The paper proposes a hierarchical representation of LTL specifications that decomposes them into smaller, more manageable sub-tasks.
- The approach also considers the temporal relationships between sub-tasks across different specifications to enable more effective multi-robot coordination.
Plain English Explanation
Robotic planning algorithms often use temporal logic to specify complex tasks and coordinate the actions of multiple robots. One common type of temporal logic is Linear Temporal Logic (LTL). However, as the tasks become more complex, the LTL formulas used to describe them can become very long and difficult to understand. This makes it hard for the planning algorithm to interpret the specifications and generate effective plans.
The researchers in this paper developed a new approach that breaks down the LTL specifications into smaller, more manageable pieces called "sub-tasks." This hierarchical representation allows the planning algorithm to more easily understand the overall task and how the different sub-tasks fit together. The algorithm also considers how the sub-tasks from different specifications are related in time, which is important for coordinating multiple robots.
By decomposing the LTL specifications and modeling the temporal relationships between sub-tasks, the researchers were able to find better solutions to the planning problems using less computational time. This could be useful for applications like navigation and manipulation tasks that require complex coordinated actions between multiple robots.
Technical Explanation
The key innovation in this paper is the development of a decomposition-based hierarchical framework for robotic planning with temporal logic specifications. At the high level, the approach first decomposes each LTL specification into a set of atomic sub-tasks. It then infers the temporal relations among the sub-tasks of different specifications to construct a task network.
This task network is used to formulate a Mixed Integer Linear Program that assigns the sub-tasks to the available robots. At the lower level, domain-specific controllers are employed to execute the individual sub-tasks.
The researchers experimentally evaluated their approach in simulation, applying it to navigation and manipulation domains. The results showed that their decomposition-based hierarchical framework could find better solutions using less computational time compared to previous LTL-based planning methods.
Critical Analysis
The proposed hierarchical representation and decomposition-based planning approach appears to be a promising solution for addressing the challenge of complex temporal logic specifications in multi-robot coordination tasks. By breaking down the LTL formulas into smaller, more manageable sub-tasks and modeling their temporal relationships, the algorithm can better handle the inherent complexity of these types of problems.
However, the paper does note that the approach assumes the independence of robots within each specification, which may limit its applicability to scenarios with more complex multi-robot coordination requirements. Additionally, the evaluation was conducted in simulation, and further testing on real-world robotic systems would be necessary to validate the practicality and scalability of the method.
Future research could explore ways to relax the assumption of robot independence, perhaps by incorporating more sophisticated multi-agent planning techniques. Investigating the performance of the approach on larger-scale, more challenging problem instances would also help assess its limits and potential areas for improvement.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel hierarchical framework for robotic planning with complex temporal logic specifications. By decomposing the LTL formulas into smaller sub-tasks and modeling their temporal relationships, the proposed approach can generate more interpretable and computationally efficient planning solutions compared to traditional LTL-based methods.
The simulation results demonstrate the potential of this decomposition-based technique to tackle challenging multi-robot coordination problems, particularly in domains like navigation and manipulation. While the current limitations suggest areas for future research, this work represents an important step forward in addressing the growing complexity of temporal logic specifications in robotics.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
➖
Fast and Adaptive Multi-agent Planning under Collaborative Temporal Logic Tasks via Poset Products
Zesen Liu, Meng Guo, Weimin Bao, Zhongkui Li
0
0
Efficient coordination and planning is essential for large-scale multi-agent systems that collaborate in a shared dynamic environment. Heuristic search methods or learning-based approaches often lack the guarantee on correctness and performance. Moreover, when the collaborative tasks contain both spatial and temporal requirements, e.g., as Linear Temporal Logic (LTL) formulas, formal methods provide a verifiable framework for task planning. However, since the planning complexity grows exponentially with the number of agents and the length of the task formula, existing studies are mostly limited to small artificial cases. To address this issue, a new planning paradigm is proposed in this work for system-wide temporal task formulas that are released online and continually. It avoids two common bottlenecks in the traditional methods, i.e., (i) the direct translation of the complete task formula to the associated Buchi automaton; and (ii) the synchronized product between the Buchi automaton and the transition models of all agents. Instead, an adaptive planning algorithm is proposed that computes the product of relaxed partially-ordered sets (R-posets) on-the-fly, and assigns these subtasks to the agents subject to the ordering constraints. It is shown that the first valid plan can be derived with a polynomial time and memory complexity w.r.t. the system size and the formula length. Our method can take into account task formulas with a length of more than 400 and a fleet with more than $400$ agents, while most existing methods fail at the formula length of 25 within a reasonable duration. The proposed method is validated on large fleets of service robots in both simulation and hardware experiments.
4/10/2024
➖
Reactive Temporal Logic-based Planning and Control for Interactive Robotic Tasks
Farhad Nawaz, Shaoting Peng, Lars Lindemann, Nadia Figueroa, Nikolai Matni
0
0
Robots interacting with humans must be safe, reactive and adapt online to unforeseen environmental and task changes. Achieving these requirements concurrently is a challenge as interactive planners lack formal safety guarantees, while safe motion planners lack flexibility to adapt. To tackle this, we propose a modular control architecture that generates both safe and reactive motion plans for human-robot interaction by integrating temporal logic-based discrete task level plans with continuous Dynamical System (DS)-based motion plans. We formulate a reactive temporal logic formula that enables users to define task specifications through structured language, and propose a planning algorithm at the task level that generates a sequence of desired robot behaviors while being adaptive to environmental changes. At the motion level, we incorporate control Lyapunov functions and control barrier functions to compute stable and safe continuous motion plans for two types of robot behaviors: (i) complex, possibly periodic motions given by autonomous DS and (ii) time-critical tasks specified by Signal Temporal Logic~(STL). Our methodology is demonstrated on the Franka robot arm performing wiping tasks on a whiteboard and a mannequin that is compliant to human interactions and adaptive to environmental changes.
5/1/2024
🏅
Logical Specifications-guided Dynamic Task Sampling for Reinforcement Learning Agents
Yash Shukla, Tanushree Burman, Abhishek Kulkarni, Robert Wright, Alvaro Velasquez, Jivko Sinapov
0
0
Reinforcement Learning (RL) has made significant strides in enabling artificial agents to learn diverse behaviors. However, learning an effective policy often requires a large number of environment interactions. To mitigate sample complexity issues, recent approaches have used high-level task specifications, such as Linear Temporal Logic (LTL$_f$) formulas or Reward Machines (RM), to guide the learning progress of the agent. In this work, we propose a novel approach, called Logical Specifications-guided Dynamic Task Sampling (LSTS), that learns a set of RL policies to guide an agent from an initial state to a goal state based on a high-level task specification, while minimizing the number of environmental interactions. Unlike previous work, LSTS does not assume information about the environment dynamics or the Reward Machine, and dynamically samples promising tasks that lead to successful goal policies. We evaluate LSTS on a gridworld and show that it achieves improved time-to-threshold performance on complex sequential decision-making problems compared to state-of-the-art RM and Automaton-guided RL baselines, such as Q-Learning for Reward Machines and Compositional RL from logical Specifications (DIRL). Moreover, we demonstrate that our method outperforms RM and Automaton-guided RL baselines in terms of sample-efficiency, both in a partially observable robotic task and in a continuous control robotic manipulation task.
4/4/2024
✨
Prioritize Team Actions: Multi-Agent Temporal Logic Task Planning with Ordering Constraints
Bowen Ye, Jianing Zhao, Shaoyuan Li, Xiang Yin
0
0
In this paper, we investigate the problem of linear temporal logic (LTL) path planning for multi-agent systems, introducing the new concept of emph{ordering constraints}. Specifically, we consider a generic objective function that is defined for the path of each individual agent. The primary objective is to find a global plan for the team of agents, ensuring they collectively meet the specified LTL requirements. Simultaneously, we aim to maintain a pre-determined order in the values of the objective function for each agent, which we refer to as the ordering constraints. This new requirement stems from scenarios like security-aware planning, where relative orders outweigh absolute values in importance. We present an efficient algorithm to solve this problem, supported by proofs of correctness that demonstrate the optimality of our solution. Additionally, we provide a case study in security-aware path planning to illustrate the practicality and effectiveness of our proposed approach.
4/9/2024