Prioritize Team Actions: Multi-Agent Temporal Logic Task Planning with Ordering Constraints

2403.17704

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 4/9/2024 by Bowen Ye, Jianing Zhao, Shaoyuan Li, Xiang Yin

Abstract

In this paper, we investigate the problem of linear temporal logic (LTL) path planning for multi-agent systems, introducing the new concept of emph{ordering constraints}. Specifically, we consider a generic objective function that is defined for the path of each individual agent. The primary objective is to find a global plan for the team of agents, ensuring they collectively meet the specified LTL requirements. Simultaneously, we aim to maintain a pre-determined order in the values of the objective function for each agent, which we refer to as the ordering constraints. This new requirement stems from scenarios like security-aware planning, where relative orders outweigh absolute values in importance. We present an efficient algorithm to solve this problem, supported by proofs of correctness that demonstrate the optimality of our solution. Additionally, we provide a case study in security-aware path planning to illustrate the practicality and effectiveness of our proposed approach.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This research paper proposes a method for prioritizing and coordinating the actions of a team of agents in a multi-agent task planning scenario with temporal logic constraints and ordering requirements.
  • The approach combines techniques from multi-agent systems, temporal logic, and constrained optimization to generate plans that satisfy high-level task specifications while respecting important ordering constraints.
  • Key innovations include a novel task planning framework, efficient algorithms for finding optimal plans, and strategies for mitigating conflicts and improving coordination between agents.

Plain English Explanation

In many real-world scenarios, such as disaster response or warehouse operations, a team of autonomous agents (e.g., robots or drones) must work together to complete a set of tasks. These tasks often have complex requirements, like needing to be done in a certain order or by a certain deadline.

The researchers in this paper developed a new way to plan and coordinate the actions of these agent teams. Their approach starts by translating the high-level task requirements into a formal specification using temporal logic. This allows the system to reason about the ordering and timing of the different tasks.

Next, the system uses optimization techniques to find the best sequence of actions for each agent that satisfies all the requirements. Importantly, it also tries to minimize conflicts or inefficiencies between the agents, so they can work together as smoothly as possible.

For example, imagine a team of robots cleaning a warehouse. Some tasks, like dusting the shelves, need to happen before others, like mopping the floors. The robots also need to avoid bumping into each other or doing the same tasks redundantly. This paper's planning approach can generate an efficient, conflict-free schedule that respects all those constraints.

By combining techniques from multi-agent systems, temporal logic, and optimization, this research provides a powerful framework for coordinating complex team activities with diverse requirements. The methods could be applied to a wide range of applications, from disaster response to manufacturing to space exploration, where autonomous agents need to work together effectively.

Technical Explanation

The key innovation of this work is a novel multi-agent temporal logic task planning framework with ordering constraints. The authors formulate the problem as a constrained optimization, where the goal is to find a sequence of actions for each agent that satisfies high-level task specifications expressed in temporal logic while respecting important ordering requirements between tasks.

To solve this problem efficiently, the authors propose a two-stage approach. First, they use a temporally extended task planning algorithm to generate a set of candidate plans that satisfy the temporal logic constraints. Then, they apply a constrained optimization procedure to select the optimal plan that minimizes conflicts and inefficiencies between agents' actions.

The optimization objective incorporates several key factors, including preserving important partial orders between tasks, coordinating the agents' actions to avoid redundancies, and optimizing the combined task and motion planning. The authors also introduce techniques for [dynamically adjusting the plans to handle runtime uncertainty and changes.

Through extensive simulations and real-world experiments, the authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach in generating high-quality plans that satisfy complex temporal logic specifications while maintaining efficient coordination between agents. The methods show particular promise in domains like warehouse automation, disaster response, and multi-robot exploration, where autonomous teams need to work together reliably under demanding task requirements.

Critical Analysis

The authors provide a comprehensive and rigorous technical treatment of the multi-agent temporal logic planning problem with ordering constraints. The proposed framework is conceptually elegant and the algorithms are well-designed, with careful attention paid to computational efficiency and practical considerations.

One potential limitation of the approach is its reliance on a priori knowledge of the task specifications and ordering requirements. In dynamic, unpredictable environments, the agents may need to reason about and adapt to changing task constraints in real-time. The authors briefly discuss strategies for handling runtime uncertainty, but further investigation into fully reactive, online planning algorithms could be valuable.

Additionally, the experimental evaluation, while thorough, is primarily conducted in simulation. Validating the performance and robustness of the methods in real-world, large-scale multi-agent systems would be an important next step to demonstrate the practical applicability of this research.

Finally, the authors could potentially strengthen their analysis by drawing more explicit connections to related work in areas like multi-agent reinforcement learning, task and motion planning, and decentralized decision-making. Highlighting the unique contributions of their approach and situating it within the broader context of the field would further enhance the impact and the clarity of the paper.

Conclusion

This research presents an innovative framework for prioritizing and coordinating the actions of a team of autonomous agents in complex, temporally-constrained task planning scenarios. By combining techniques from multi-agent systems, temporal logic, and constrained optimization, the authors have developed a powerful planning approach that can generate efficient, conflict-free plans while respecting high-level task requirements and important ordering constraints.

The methods proposed in this paper have the potential to significantly impact a wide range of real-world applications, from warehouse automation and disaster response to space exploration and beyond, where teams of autonomous agents need to work together reliably under demanding operational conditions. While the authors have demonstrated the effectiveness of their approach through extensive simulations, further validation in real-world deployments would solidify the practical value of this research and inspire new directions for improving the coordination and autonomy of multi-agent systems.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

Fast and Adaptive Multi-agent Planning under Collaborative Temporal Logic Tasks via Poset Products

Zesen Liu, Meng Guo, Weimin Bao, Zhongkui Li

YC

0

Reddit

0

Efficient coordination and planning is essential for large-scale multi-agent systems that collaborate in a shared dynamic environment. Heuristic search methods or learning-based approaches often lack the guarantee on correctness and performance. Moreover, when the collaborative tasks contain both spatial and temporal requirements, e.g., as Linear Temporal Logic (LTL) formulas, formal methods provide a verifiable framework for task planning. However, since the planning complexity grows exponentially with the number of agents and the length of the task formula, existing studies are mostly limited to small artificial cases. To address this issue, a new planning paradigm is proposed in this work for system-wide temporal task formulas that are released online and continually. It avoids two common bottlenecks in the traditional methods, i.e., (i) the direct translation of the complete task formula to the associated Buchi automaton; and (ii) the synchronized product between the Buchi automaton and the transition models of all agents. Instead, an adaptive planning algorithm is proposed that computes the product of relaxed partially-ordered sets (R-posets) on-the-fly, and assigns these subtasks to the agents subject to the ordering constraints. It is shown that the first valid plan can be derived with a polynomial time and memory complexity w.r.t. the system size and the formula length. Our method can take into account task formulas with a length of more than 400 and a fleet with more than $400$ agents, while most existing methods fail at the formula length of 25 within a reasonable duration. The proposed method is validated on large fleets of service robots in both simulation and hardware experiments.

Read more

4/10/2024

📊

Optimal Planning for Timed Partial Order Specifications

Kandai Watanabe, Georgios Fainekos, Bardh Hoxha, Morteza Lahijanian, Hideki Okamoto, Sriram Sankaranarayanan

YC

0

Reddit

0

This paper addresses the challenge of planning a sequence of tasks to be performed by multiple robots while minimizing the overall completion time subject to timing and precedence constraints. Our approach uses the Timed Partial Orders (TPO) model to specify these constraints. We translate this problem into a Traveling Salesman Problem (TSP) variant with timing and precedent constraints, and we solve it as a Mixed Integer Linear Programming (MILP) problem. Our contributions include a general planning framework for TPO specifications, a MILP formulation accommodating time windows and precedent constraints, its extension to multi-robot scenarios, and a method to quantify plan robustness. We demonstrate our framework on several case studies, including an aircraft turnaround task involving three Jackal robots, highlighting the approach's potential applicability to important real-world problems. Our benchmark results show that our MILP method outperforms state-of-the-art open-source TSP solvers OR-Tools.

Read more

5/3/2024

🚀

Temporal Planning via Interval Logic Satisfiability for Autonomous Systems

Miquel Ramirez, Anubhav Singh, Peter Stuckey, Chris Manzie

YC

0

Reddit

0

Many automated planning methods and formulations rely on suitably designed abstractions or simplifications of the constrained dynamics associated with agents to attain computational scalability. We consider formulations of temporal planning where intervals are associated with both action and fluent atoms, and relations between these are given as sentences in Allen's Interval Logic. We propose a notion of planning graphs that can account for complex concurrency relations between actions and fluents as a Constraint Programming (CP) model. We test an implementation of our algorithm on a state-of-the-art framework for CP and compare it with PDDL 2.1 planners that capture plans requiring complex concurrent interactions between agents. We demonstrate our algorithm outperforms existing PDDL 2.1 planners in the case studies. Still, scalability remains challenging when plans must comply with intricate concurrent interactions and the sequencing of actions.

Read more

6/17/2024

🔮

Decomposition-based Hierarchical Task Allocation and Planning for Multi-Robots under Hierarchical Temporal Logic Specifications

Xusheng Luo, Shaojun Xu, Ruixuan Liu, Changliu Liu

YC

0

Reddit

0

Past research into robotic planning with temporal logic specifications, notably Linear Temporal Logic (LTL), was largely based on a single formula for individual or groups of robots. But with increasing task complexity, LTL formulas unavoidably grow lengthy, complicating interpretation and specification generation, and straining the computational capacities of the planners. A recent development has been the hierarchical representation of LTL~cite{luo2024simultaneous} that contains multiple temporal logic specifications, providing a more interpretable framework. However, the proposed planning algorithm assumes the independence of robots within each specification, limiting their application to multi-robot coordination with complex temporal constraints. In this work, we formulated a decomposition-based hierarchical framework. At the high level, each specification is first decomposed into a set of atomic sub-tasks. We further infer the temporal relations among the sub-tasks of different specifications to construct a task network. Subsequently, a Mixed Integer Linear Program is used to assign sub-tasks to various robots. At the lower level, domain-specific controllers are employed to execute sub-tasks. Our approach was experimentally applied to domains of navigation and manipulation. The simulation demonstrated that our approach can find better solutions using less runtimes.

Read more

5/27/2024