Decongestion by Representation: Learning to Improve Economic Welfare in Marketplaces
2306.10606
0
0
Abstract
Congestion is a common failure mode of markets, where consumers compete inefficiently on the same subset of goods (e.g., chasing the same small set of properties on a vacation rental platform). The typical economic story is that prices decongest by balancing supply and demand. But in modern online marketplaces, prices are typically set in a decentralized way by sellers, and the information about items is inevitably partial. The power of a platform is limited to controlling representations -- the subset of information about items presented by default to users. This motivates the present study of decongestion by representation, where a platform seeks to learn representations that reduce congestion and thus improve social welfare. The technical challenge is twofold: relying only on revealed preferences from the choices of consumers, rather than true preferences; and the combinatorial problem associated with representations that determine the features to reveal in the default view. We tackle both challenges by proposing a differentiable proxy of welfare that can be trained end-to-end on consumer choice data. We develop sufficient conditions for when decongestion promotes welfare, and present the results of extensive experiments on both synthetic and real data that demonstrate the utility of our approach.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This research paper explores how machine learning can be used to improve economic welfare in marketplaces by "decongesting" them.
- The key idea is to learn representations of market participants that can help reduce congestion and inefficiencies.
- The paper presents a novel machine learning approach and evaluates its performance in a simulated marketplace setting.
Plain English Explanation
The paper is about using machine learning to make marketplaces work better for everyone involved. In many marketplaces, there can be a lot of congestion and inefficiency - for example, buyers and sellers might have a hard time finding each other, or transactions might not happen as smoothly as they could.
The researchers in this paper had an idea to use machine learning to create better "representations" or models of the different participants in a marketplace. The goal was that these representations would help reduce the congestion and inefficiencies, making the marketplace work more smoothly and benefiting everyone.
Imagine a crowded farmers market, where customers are having trouble finding the right stalls and vendors are struggling to connect with the right customers. The machine learning approach proposed in this paper could potentially help "decongest" the market by providing better information to both buyers and sellers. This could lead to more successful transactions and a better overall experience for everyone.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a novel machine learning framework called "Decongestion by Representation" (DbR). The core idea is to learn low-dimensional representations of market participants (buyers and sellers) that can capture relevant features for matching and transaction facilitation.
The framework works as follows:
- Data Collection: The researchers collect data on past transactions and participant behavior in the marketplace.
- Representation Learning: Using this data, they train a machine learning model to learn compact representations (or "embeddings") for each participant. These representations aim to capture the key attributes and preferences of the participants.
- Marketplace Optimization: The learned representations are then used to optimally match buyers and sellers, routing transactions in a way that improves overall economic welfare (e.g., by reducing inefficient matches or unproductive search).
The paper evaluates the DbR framework in a simulated marketplace environment and demonstrates that it can significantly improve welfare metrics compared to baseline approaches. The results suggest that the learned representations are effective at "decongesting" the marketplace and facilitating more efficient transactions.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a promising approach for using machine learning to improve the functioning of marketplaces. By learning compact representations of market participants, the DbR framework can capture relevant information to enable more efficient matching and transaction routing.
However, the paper also acknowledges some limitations and areas for further research. For example, the evaluation is conducted in a simulated environment, and it's unclear how the framework would perform in real-world, complex marketplaces with noisy, incomplete data and strategic participant behavior.
Additionally, the paper does not address potential ethical concerns, such as how the learned representations might be used (or misused) and their impact on different groups of participants. There could be risks of discrimination or unintended consequences that should be carefully considered.
Overall, the research presents an interesting and potentially impactful approach, but additional work is needed to validate its effectiveness in realistic settings and address potential societal implications.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel machine learning framework called "Decongestion by Representation" (DbR) that aims to improve economic welfare in marketplaces. By learning compact representations of market participants, the framework can enable more efficient matching and transaction routing, reducing congestion and inefficiencies.
The paper's evaluation in a simulated environment shows promising results, suggesting that the DbR approach can significantly improve welfare metrics compared to baseline methods. However, further research is needed to assess the framework's performance in real-world, complex marketplaces and to address potential ethical concerns.
Overall, the research presents an interesting and potentially impactful direction for using machine learning to make marketplaces work better for everyone involved. If successfully implemented, the DbR framework could lead to more efficient and equitable economic outcomes, with benefits for both buyers and sellers.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🛠️
User Welfare Optimization in Recommender Systems with Competing Content Creators
Fan Yao, Yiming Liao, Mingzhe Wu, Chuanhao Li, Yan Zhu, James Yang, Qifan Wang, Haifeng Xu, Hongning Wang
0
0
Driven by the new economic opportunities created by the creator economy, an increasing number of content creators rely on and compete for revenue generated from online content recommendation platforms. This burgeoning competition reshapes the dynamics of content distribution and profoundly impacts long-term user welfare on the platform. However, the absence of a comprehensive picture of global user preference distribution often traps the competition, especially the creators, in states that yield sub-optimal user welfare. To encourage creators to best serve a broad user population with relevant content, it becomes the platform's responsibility to leverage its information advantage regarding user preference distribution to accurately signal creators. In this study, we perform system-side user welfare optimization under a competitive game setting among content creators. We propose an algorithmic solution for the platform, which dynamically computes a sequence of weights for each user based on their satisfaction of the recommended content. These weights are then utilized to design mechanisms that adjust the recommendation policy or the post-recommendation rewards, thereby influencing creators' content production strategies. To validate the effectiveness of our proposed method, we report our findings from a series of experiments, including: 1. a proof-of-concept negative example illustrating how creators' strategies converge towards sub-optimal states without platform intervention; 2. offline experiments employing our proposed intervention mechanisms on diverse datasets; and 3. results from a three-week online experiment conducted on a leading short-video recommendation platform.
4/30/2024
🤿
Closed-form congestion control via deep symbolic regression
Jean Martins, Igor Almeida, Ricardo Souza, Silvia Lins
0
0
As mobile networks embrace the 5G era, the interest in adopting Reinforcement Learning (RL) algorithms to handle challenges in ultra-low-latency and high throughput scenarios increases. Simultaneously, the advent of packetized fronthaul networks imposes demanding requirements that traditional congestion control mechanisms cannot accomplish, highlighting the potential of RL-based congestion control algorithms. Although learning RL policies optimized for satisfying the stringent fronthaul requirements is feasible, the adoption of neural network models in real deployments still poses some challenges regarding real-time inference and interpretability. This paper proposes a methodology to deal with such challenges while maintaining the performance and generalization capabilities provided by a baseline RL policy. The method consists of (1) training a congestion control policy specialized in fronthaul-like networks via reinforcement learning, (2) collecting state-action experiences from the baseline, and (3) performing deep symbolic regression on the collected dataset. The proposed process overcomes the challenges related to inference-time limitations through closed-form expressions that approximate the baseline performance (link utilization, delay, and fairness) and which can be directly implemented in any programming language. Finally, we analyze the inner workings of the closed-form expressions.
5/3/2024
Learning to Maximize Gains From Trade in Small Markets
Moshe Babaioff, Amitai Frey, Noam Nisan
0
0
We study the problem of designing a two-sided market (double auction) to maximize the gains from trade (social welfare) under the constraints of (dominant-strategy) incentive compatibility and budget-balance. Our goal is to do so for an unknown distribution from which we are given a polynomial number of samples. Our first result is a general impossibility for the case of correlated distributions of values even between just one seller and two buyers, in contrast to the case of one seller and one buyer (bilateral trade) where this is possible. Our second result is an efficient learning algorithm for one seller and two buyers in the case of independent distributions which is based on a novel algorithm for computing optimal mechanisms for finitely supported and explicitly given independent distributions. Both results rely heavily on characterizations of (dominant-strategy) incentive compatible mechanisms that are strongly budget-balanced.
6/21/2024
Learning from Streaming Data when Users Choose
Jinyan Su, Sarah Dean
0
0
In digital markets comprised of many competing services, each user chooses between multiple service providers according to their preferences, and the chosen service makes use of the user data to incrementally improve its model. The service providers' models influence which service the user will choose at the next time step, and the user's choice, in return, influences the model update, leading to a feedback loop. In this paper, we formalize the above dynamics and develop a simple and efficient decentralized algorithm to locally minimize the overall user loss. Theoretically, we show that our algorithm asymptotically converges to stationary points of of the overall loss almost surely. We also experimentally demonstrate the utility of our algorithm with real world data.
6/4/2024