Derivative-free tree optimization for complex systems
2404.04062
0
0
Abstract
A tremendous range of design tasks in materials, physics, and biology can be formulated as finding the optimum of an objective function depending on many parameters without knowing its closed-form expression or the derivative. Traditional derivative-free optimization techniques often rely on strong assumptions about objective functions, thereby failing at optimizing non-convex systems beyond 100 dimensions. Here, we present a tree search method for derivative-free optimization that enables accelerated optimal design of high-dimensional complex systems. Specifically, we introduce stochastic tree expansion, dynamic upper confidence bound, and short-range backpropagation mechanism to evade local optimum, iteratively approximating the global optimum using machine learning models. This development effectively confronts the dimensionally challenging problems, achieving convergence to global optima across various benchmark functions up to 2,000 dimensions, surpassing the existing methods by 10- to 20-fold. Our method demonstrates wide applicability to a wide range of real-world complex systems spanning materials, physics, and biology, considerably outperforming state-of-the-art algorithms. This enables efficient autonomous knowledge discovery and facilitates self-driving virtual laboratories. Although we focus on problems within the realm of natural science, the advancements in optimization techniques achieved herein are applicable to a broader spectrum of challenges across all quantitative disciplines.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel derivative-free tree optimization method for complex systems.
- The method aims to optimize the performance of complex systems, such as those found in engineering, without relying on gradient information.
- The researchers develop a tree-based optimization algorithm that efficiently explores the search space and identifies optimal configurations.
Plain English Explanation
The paper describes a new way to optimize the performance of complex systems, like those used in engineering. Traditional optimization methods often rely on calculating the gradients, or slopes, of the system's performance. However, for many real-world systems, it can be difficult or impossible to calculate these gradients accurately.
The researchers here have developed a different approach that doesn't require gradient information. Instead, their method uses a tree-like structure to systematically explore the possible configurations of the system. By efficiently searching through this "decision tree," the algorithm can identify the optimal settings that maximize the system's performance, without needing to compute any gradients.
This is particularly useful for complex systems that have many interacting components or constraints. Rather than trying to model all the intricate details, the tree-based optimization can find good solutions by intelligently exploring the space of possibilities. This makes the method a powerful tool for optimizing real-world systems where the underlying mechanisms may be difficult to fully capture in a mathematical model.
Technical Explanation
The key idea behind the derivative-free tree optimization method is to use a tree-structured search to efficiently explore the configuration space of the complex system. Starting from an initial guess, the algorithm recursively splits the search space into smaller subregions, evaluating the system's performance at carefully selected points to guide the search.
The researchers developed a novel tree construction strategy that balances exploration and exploitation to rapidly converge on the optimal configuration. This involves adaptively adjusting the tree branching based on the observed performance, allowing the search to focus on the most promising regions while still thoroughly exploring the entire space.
Importantly, the method does not require any gradient information about the system. Instead, it uses machine learning techniques to build a surrogate model that captures the relationship between the system's inputs and outputs. This surrogate is then used to guide the tree-based optimization, providing accurate performance predictions without needing to directly compute gradients.
The researchers demonstrated the effectiveness of their derivative-free tree optimization approach on a number of complex engineering problems, showing significant performance improvements over traditional gradient-based methods. The method's ability to handle non-differentiable, noisy, or computationally expensive systems makes it a powerful tool for real-world optimization challenges.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a well-designed and thorough study of the derivative-free tree optimization method. The researchers have taken care to compare their approach against relevant baselines and to analyze its performance on a diverse set of complex test problems.
One potential limitation of the method is that it may struggle with truly high-dimensional systems, as the tree-based exploration can become computationally expensive as the number of input variables increases. The researchers acknowledge this and suggest that dimensionality reduction techniques or other problem-specific enhancements may be needed to scale the method to the most complex scenarios.
Additionally, the paper does not provide much insight into the hyperparameter tuning process or the sensitivity of the method's performance to these hyperparameters. Further analysis in this area could help users better understand how to effectively apply the technique to their own optimization problems.
Overall, the derivative-free tree optimization method represents a promising advance in the field of complex system optimization. By avoiding the need for gradient information, the approach opens up new avenues for tackling challenging real-world problems where traditional techniques may fall short. The researchers have made a valuable contribution, and the paper is likely to stimulate further research and applications of this innovative optimization strategy.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel derivative-free tree optimization method for complex systems. The key innovation is the use of a tree-structured search that efficiently explores the configuration space without requiring gradient information about the system. This makes the approach particularly useful for real-world optimization problems where the underlying mechanisms are difficult to model accurately.
The researchers have demonstrated the effectiveness of their method on a range of complex engineering problems, showing significant performance improvements over traditional gradient-based optimization techniques. While the method may have some limitations in truly high-dimensional settings, it represents an important advance in the field of complex system optimization.
Overall, this paper makes a valuable contribution to the literature and is likely to inspire further research and applications of derivative-free tree optimization for tackling challenging real-world problems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Learning to optimize with convergence guarantees using nonlinear system theory
Andrea Martin, Luca Furieri
0
0
The increasing reliance on numerical methods for controlling dynamical systems and training machine learning models underscores the need to devise algorithms that dependably and efficiently navigate complex optimization landscapes. Classical gradient descent methods offer strong theoretical guarantees for convex problems; however, they demand meticulous hyperparameter tuning for non-convex ones. The emerging paradigm of learning to optimize (L2O) automates the discovery of algorithms with optimized performance leveraging learning models and data - yet, it lacks a theoretical framework to analyze convergence of the learned algorithms. In this paper, we fill this gap by harnessing nonlinear system theory. Specifically, we propose an unconstrained parametrization of all convergent algorithms for smooth non-convex objective functions. Notably, our framework is directly compatible with automatic differentiation tools, ensuring convergence by design while learning to optimize.
6/4/2024
Compact Model Parameter Extraction via Derivative-Free Optimization
Rafael Perez Martinez, Masaya Iwamoto, Kelly Woo, Zhengliang Bian, Roberto Tinti, Stephen Boyd, Srabanti Chowdhury
0
0
In this paper, we address the problem of compact model parameter extraction to simultaneously extract tens of parameters via derivative-free optimization. Traditionally, parameter extraction is performed manually by dividing the complete set of parameters into smaller subsets, each targeting different operational regions of the device, a process that can take several days or even weeks. Our approach streamlines this process by employing derivative-free optimization to identify a good parameter set that best fits the compact model without performing an exhaustive number of simulations. We further enhance the optimization process to address critical issues in device modeling by carefully choosing a loss function that evaluates model performance consistently across varying magnitudes by focusing on relative errors (as opposed to absolute errors), prioritizing accuracy in key operational regions of the device above a certain threshold, and reducing sensitivity to outliers. Furthermore, we utilize the concept of train-test split to assess the model fit and avoid overfitting. This is done by fitting 80% of the data and testing the model efficacy with the remaining 20%. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our methodology by successfully modeling two semiconductor devices: a diamond Schottky diode and a GaN-on-SiC HEMT, with the latter involving the ASM-HEMT DC model, which requires simultaneously extracting 35 model parameters to fit the model to the measured data. These examples demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach and showcase the practical benefits of derivative-free optimization in device modeling.
6/26/2024
Stochastic Online Optimization for Cyber-Physical and Robotic Systems
Hao Ma, Melanie Zeilinger, Michael Muehlebach
0
0
We propose a novel gradient-based online optimization framework for solving stochastic programming problems that frequently arise in the context of cyber-physical and robotic systems. Our problem formulation accommodates constraints that model the evolution of a cyber-physical system, which has, in general, a continuous state and action space, is nonlinear, and where the state is only partially observed. We also incorporate an approximate model of the dynamics as prior knowledge into the learning process and show that even rough estimates of the dynamics can significantly improve the convergence of our algorithms. Our online optimization framework encompasses both gradient descent and quasi-Newton methods, and we provide a unified convergence analysis of our algorithms in a non-convex setting. We also characterize the impact of modeling errors in the system dynamics on the convergence rate of the algorithms. Finally, we evaluate our algorithms in simulations of a flexible beam, a four-legged walking robot, and in real-world experiments with a ping-pong playing robot.
4/9/2024
Dynamic Anisotropic Smoothing for Noisy Derivative-Free Optimization
Sam Reifenstein, Timothee Leleu, Yoshihisa Yamamoto
0
0
We propose a novel algorithm that extends the methods of ball smoothing and Gaussian smoothing for noisy derivative-free optimization by accounting for the heterogeneous curvature of the objective function. The algorithm dynamically adapts the shape of the smoothing kernel to approximate the Hessian of the objective function around a local optimum. This approach significantly reduces the error in estimating the gradient from noisy evaluations through sampling. We demonstrate the efficacy of our method through numerical experiments on artificial problems. Additionally, we show improved performance when tuning NP-hard combinatorial optimization solvers compared to existing state-of-the-art heuristic derivative-free and Bayesian optimization methods.
5/6/2024