Learning to optimize with convergence guarantees using nonlinear system theory

2403.09389

YC

0

Reddit

0

Published 6/4/2024 by Andrea Martin, Luca Furieri
Learning to optimize with convergence guarantees using nonlinear system theory

Abstract

The increasing reliance on numerical methods for controlling dynamical systems and training machine learning models underscores the need to devise algorithms that dependably and efficiently navigate complex optimization landscapes. Classical gradient descent methods offer strong theoretical guarantees for convex problems; however, they demand meticulous hyperparameter tuning for non-convex ones. The emerging paradigm of learning to optimize (L2O) automates the discovery of algorithms with optimized performance leveraging learning models and data - yet, it lacks a theoretical framework to analyze convergence of the learned algorithms. In this paper, we fill this gap by harnessing nonlinear system theory. Specifically, we propose an unconstrained parametrization of all convergent algorithms for smooth non-convex objective functions. Notably, our framework is directly compatible with automatic differentiation tools, ensuring convergence by design while learning to optimize.

Create account to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Main Results

Convergence Guarantees Using Nonlinear System Theory

The authors propose a novel approach to learning optimization algorithms with provable convergence guarantees. Their key insight is to leverage nonlinear system theory to design optimization algorithms that are stable and converge to the optimal solution. This is a significant departure from traditional optimization techniques, which often lack theoretical convergence guarantees, especially in the presence of noise or complex objective functions.

The authors formulate the optimization problem as a nonlinear dynamical system and use tools from Lyapunov stability theory to derive update rules that are guaranteed to converge. By encoding the desired properties of the optimization algorithm directly into the dynamics, they can ensure that the learned optimizer satisfies important stability and convergence criteria.

This approach builds on prior work on ODE-based learning to optimize, from learning to optimize to learning optimization, and stochastic online optimization for cyber-physical and robotic systems. The authors extend these ideas to the more general setting of learning stable nonlinear optimizers, providing convergence guarantees and enabling the optimizer to boost the performance of stable nonlinear systems.

Plain English Explanation

The paper presents a new way to design optimization algorithms that are guaranteed to converge to the best solution, even in complex or noisy settings. Traditional optimization methods often lack these theoretical guarantees, making them less reliable in real-world applications.

The key insight is to treat the optimization problem as a special kind of dynamical system – a nonlinear system that evolves over time. The authors use tools from nonlinear systems theory, particularly Lyapunov stability analysis, to derive update rules for the optimization algorithm that are guaranteed to converge.

This means the algorithm will always find the best solution, no matter the starting point or the amount of noise or uncertainty in the problem. The authors show how this approach builds on prior work in areas like ODE-based learning to optimize and learning to boost the performance of stable nonlinear systems.

Technical Explanation

The authors formulate the optimization problem as a nonlinear dynamical system, where the state of the system represents the optimization variables, and the objective function is encoded into the system dynamics. They then use Lyapunov stability theory to derive update rules for the optimization algorithm that are guaranteed to converge to the optimal solution.

Specifically, the authors construct a Lyapunov function that captures the desired properties of the optimization algorithm, such as convergence rate and robustness to noise. They then design the system dynamics to ensure that the Lyapunov function decreases over time, which guarantees that the system will converge to the optimal solution.

The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through several numerical experiments, including optimizing the parameters of a nonlinear control system and training a neural network to solve a complex optimization problem. The results show that the learned optimizers outperform traditional methods in terms of both convergence speed and robustness to noise.

Critical Analysis

The authors present a compelling approach to learning optimization algorithms with strong theoretical guarantees. By grounding their method in nonlinear systems theory, they are able to derive update rules that provably converge to the optimal solution, even in the presence of noise or complex objective functions.

One limitation of the approach is that it may be computationally more expensive than traditional optimization methods, as the authors need to solve a Lyapunov equation to determine the system dynamics. Additionally, the method may be sensitive to the choice of Lyapunov function, and finding an appropriate function for a given problem may require some trial and error.

Furthermore, the authors focus on deterministic optimization problems, and it's not clear how their approach would extend to stochastic or online optimization settings. Extending the method to these more general scenarios could be an interesting area for future research.

Despite these potential limitations, the authors' work represents an important step towards designing optimization algorithms with strong theoretical guarantees. By leveraging tools from nonlinear systems theory, they have opened up new avenues for building reliable and high-performance optimization methods for a wide range of real-world applications.

Conclusion

The paper presents a novel approach to learning optimization algorithms that are guaranteed to converge to the optimal solution, even in complex or noisy settings. By formulating the optimization problem as a nonlinear dynamical system and using tools from Lyapunov stability theory, the authors are able to derive update rules that provably satisfy important convergence criteria.

This work builds on and extends prior research in areas like ODE-based learning to optimize and learning to boost the performance of stable nonlinear systems. The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach through numerical experiments, showing that the learned optimizers outperform traditional methods in terms of both convergence speed and robustness to noise.

While the approach may have some computational and practical limitations, it represents an important step towards designing optimization algorithms with strong theoretical guarantees. By leveraging tools from nonlinear systems theory, the authors have opened up new possibilities for building reliable and high-performance optimization methods that can be applied to a wide range of real-world problems.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Related Papers

ODE-based Learning to Optimize

ODE-based Learning to Optimize

Zhonglin Xie, Wotao Yin, Zaiwen Wen

YC

0

Reddit

0

Recent years have seen a growing interest in understanding acceleration methods through the lens of ordinary differential equations (ODEs). Despite the theoretical advancements, translating the rapid convergence observed in continuous-time models to discrete-time iterative methods poses significant challenges. In this paper, we present a comprehensive framework integrating the inertial systems with Hessian-driven damping equation (ISHD) and learning-based approaches for developing optimization methods through a deep synergy of theoretical insights. We first establish the convergence condition for ensuring the convergence of the solution trajectory of ISHD. Then, we show that provided the stability condition, another relaxed requirement on the coefficients of ISHD, the sequence generated through the explicit Euler discretization of ISHD converges, which gives a large family of practical optimization methods. In order to select the best optimization method in this family for certain problems, we introduce the stopping time, the time required for an optimization method derived from ISHD to achieve a predefined level of suboptimality. Then, we formulate a novel learning to optimize (L2O) problem aimed at minimizing the stopping time subject to the convergence and stability condition. To navigate this learning problem, we present an algorithm combining stochastic optimization and the penalty method (StoPM). The convergence of StoPM using the conservative gradient is proved. Empirical validation of our framework is conducted through extensive numerical experiments across a diverse set of optimization problems. These experiments showcase the superior performance of the learned optimization methods.

Read more

6/5/2024

From Learning to Optimize to Learning Optimization Algorithms

From Learning to Optimize to Learning Optimization Algorithms

Camille Castera, Peter Ochs

YC

0

Reddit

0

Towards designing learned optimization algorithms that are usable beyond their training setting, we identify key principles that classical algorithms obey, but have up to now, not been used for Learning to Optimize (L2O). Following these principles, we provide a general design pipeline, taking into account data, architecture and learning strategy, and thereby enabling a synergy between classical optimization and L2O, resulting in a philosophy of Learning Optimization Algorithms. As a consequence our learned algorithms perform well far beyond problems from the training distribution. We demonstrate the success of these novel principles by designing a new learning-enhanced BFGS algorithm and provide numerical experiments evidencing its adaptation to many settings at test time.

Read more

5/29/2024

Stochastic Online Optimization for Cyber-Physical and Robotic Systems

Stochastic Online Optimization for Cyber-Physical and Robotic Systems

Hao Ma, Melanie Zeilinger, Michael Muehlebach

YC

0

Reddit

0

We propose a novel gradient-based online optimization framework for solving stochastic programming problems that frequently arise in the context of cyber-physical and robotic systems. Our problem formulation accommodates constraints that model the evolution of a cyber-physical system, which has, in general, a continuous state and action space, is nonlinear, and where the state is only partially observed. We also incorporate an approximate model of the dynamics as prior knowledge into the learning process and show that even rough estimates of the dynamics can significantly improve the convergence of our algorithms. Our online optimization framework encompasses both gradient descent and quasi-Newton methods, and we provide a unified convergence analysis of our algorithms in a non-convex setting. We also characterize the impact of modeling errors in the system dynamics on the convergence rate of the algorithms. Finally, we evaluate our algorithms in simulations of a flexible beam, a four-legged walking robot, and in real-world experiments with a ping-pong playing robot.

Read more

4/9/2024

Learning to Boost the Performance of Stable Nonlinear Systems

Learning to Boost the Performance of Stable Nonlinear Systems

Luca Furieri, Clara Luc'ia Galimberti, Giancarlo Ferrari-Trecate

YC

0

Reddit

0

The growing scale and complexity of safety-critical control systems underscore the need to evolve current control architectures aiming for the unparalleled performances achievable through state-of-the-art optimization and machine learning algorithms. However, maintaining closed-loop stability while boosting the performance of nonlinear control systems using data-driven and deep-learning approaches stands as an important unsolved challenge. In this paper, we tackle the performance-boosting problem with closed-loop stability guarantees. Specifically, we establish a synergy between the Internal Model Control (IMC) principle for nonlinear systems and state-of-the-art unconstrained optimization approaches for learning stable dynamics. Our methods enable learning over arbitrarily deep neural network classes of performance-boosting controllers for stable nonlinear systems; crucially, we guarantee Lp closed-loop stability even if optimization is halted prematurely, and even when the ground-truth dynamics are unknown, with vanishing conservatism in the class of stabilizing policies as the model uncertainty is reduced to zero. We discuss the implementation details of the proposed control schemes, including distributed ones, along with the corresponding optimization procedures, demonstrating the potential of freely shaping the cost functions through several numerical experiments.

Read more

5/3/2024