Describe-then-Reason: Improving Multimodal Mathematical Reasoning through Visual Comprehension Training

Overview

• Open-source multimodal large language models (MLLMs) excel at many tasks involving text and images, but struggle with complex mathematical reasoning compared to proprietary models
• Fine-tuning MLLMs with intermediate steps (rationales) can improve their mathematical reasoning, but they still lack in visual comprehension due to inadequate visual-centric training
• The proposed VCAR approach aims to address this by first improving the visual comprehension of MLLMs through visual description generation, then training on generating rationales with the help of these descriptions

Plain English Explanation

Large language models trained on both text and images (multimodal models) are very capable at a wide variety of tasks involving both text and visuals. However, when it comes to complex mathematical reasoning, they still lag behind more specialized proprietary models like GPT-4V and Gemini-Pro.

Researchers have tried to improve the mathematical reasoning skills of these multimodal models by providing them with additional training on explaining their reasoning step-by-step (called "rationales"). This does help, but the models still struggle with accurately interpreting visual elements like mathematical figures and diagrams. This is likely because they haven't received enough targeted training on visual comprehension.

To address this, the researchers propose a new two-step training approach called VCAR. First, they train the multimodal model to get better at describing visual content in general. Then, they train it again, this time on generating those step-by-step rationales, but with the help of the visual descriptions it learned earlier.

The idea is that by first mastering the skill of understanding and describing visual information, the model will be better equipped to reason about and explain mathematical concepts that rely heavily on visual elements. The researchers' experiments show that this VCAR approach significantly outperforms previous methods, especially on problems that require strong visual comprehension.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a new two-step training pipeline called VCAR (Visual Comprehension and Reasoning) to improve the multimodal mathematical reasoning capabilities of open-source large language models (MLLMs).

In the first step, the model is trained on a visual description generation task to enhance its visual comprehension abilities. This helps the model develop a stronger understanding of visual elements like diagrams and figures, which are crucial for reasoning about mathematical concepts.

In the second step, the model is further trained on generating rationales - step-by-step explanations of its reasoning process. Crucially, this rationale generation is assisted by the visual descriptions the model learned in the first step. This allows the model to better ground its mathematical reasoning in the relevant visual information.

The researchers evaluate VCAR on two popular benchmarks for multimodal mathematical reasoning. They find that VCAR substantially outperforms baseline methods that only use rationale supervision, especially on problems that have high visual demands. This suggests that the two-stage training approach of first improving visual comprehension, and then using that to aid reasoning, is an effective way to boost the multimodal mathematical skills of large language models.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a compelling case for the importance of visual comprehension in enabling robust multimodal mathematical reasoning. By systematically addressing this shortcoming in existing open-source models, the VCAR approach represents an important step forward.

However, the paper does not explore the limitations of the visual description generation task used in the first training stage. It's possible that models trained on this task may still struggle to fully capture the nuances and contextual information required for complex mathematical reasoning. Additional research may be needed to identify the optimal visual pretraining objectives and architectures.

Furthermore, the experiments are conducted on a relatively narrow set of benchmarks. It would be valuable to see how VCAR performs on a wider range of multimodal reasoning tasks, including those that involve more diverse visual inputs beyond just mathematical figures.

Finally, the paper does not discuss the computational and training resource requirements of the VCAR approach compared to other methods. This information would be useful for evaluating the scalability and practical applicability of the proposed technique.

Overall, the VCAR framework is a promising direction, but further research is needed to fully understand its strengths, weaknesses, and broader implications for advancing the state of the art in multimodal reasoning.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel two-step training approach called VCAR that significantly improves the multimodal mathematical reasoning capabilities of open-source large language models. By first enhancing the models' visual comprehension through a description generation task, and then leveraging those visual understanding skills to aid in step-by-step reasoning, VCAR is able to outperform previous methods that solely relied on rationale supervision.

The key insight is that strong visual comprehension is crucial for tackling complex mathematical problems that involve interpreting and reasoning about various visual elements. The VCAR framework provides a principled way to address this shortcoming in existing open-source multimodal models, paving the way for more robust and capable reasoning systems.

While further research is needed to fully understand the limitations and broader applicability of this approach, the results presented in this paper represent an important advancement in the field of multimodal artificial intelligence. As the demand for AI systems that can seamlessly integrate and reason about both textual and visual information continues to grow, techniques like VCAR will become increasingly valuable.