Design Fiction as Breaching Experiment: An Interdisciplinary Methodology for Understanding the Acceptability and Adoption of Future Technologies

Overview

• This paper explores an interdisciplinary approach to understanding the acceptability and adoption challenges of future and emerging technologies.
• The approach leverages design fiction as a method for breaching experiments to surface the taken-for-granted expectations that people have about how technology should function in everyday life.
• Both design fiction and breaching experiments have been used in human-computer interaction (HCI) research before, but this is the first time they have been combined for this purpose.

Plain English Explanation

The paper looks at the challenges of getting people to accept and adopt new and future technologies. It uses a combination of two research approaches - design fiction and breaching experiments - to better understand these challenges.

Design fiction is an artistic way of exploring the future and imagining how new technologies might be used. Breaching experiments are a social science method that reveal the hidden assumptions and expectations people have about how things should work in their daily lives.

By bringing these two approaches together, the researchers aim to provoke and surface the issues that arise when people encounter unfamiliar or unexpected technologies in their everyday routines. This can help identify potential barriers to the acceptance and adoption of future technologies.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes an interdisciplinary approach that combines design fiction and breaching experiments to understand the acceptability and adoption challenges of future and emerging technologies.

Design fiction is used to create speculative prototypes that depict possible future technological scenarios. These prototypes are then used as the basis for breaching experiments, where researchers introduce them into people's everyday lives to observe how they react and the assumptions they make about how the technology should function.

By combining these two HCI research methods, the researchers aim to provoke and surface the taken-for-granted expectations that people have about technology and how it should be integrated into their daily routines. This provides insights into the potential barriers to acceptance and adoption that new technologies may face.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a compelling case for using this combined approach of design fiction and breaching experiments to better understand the challenges of technology adoption. By focusing on the situated, everyday context of technology use, the researchers are able to uncover tacit assumptions and expectations that may not be readily apparent through other research methods.

However, the paper does not address potential limitations or caveats of this approach. For example, the small-scale, qualitative nature of breaching experiments may limit the generalizability of the findings. There is also the risk of confirmation bias if the design fiction prototypes are too narrowly framed to elicit certain reactions.

Additionally, the paper does not discuss how the insights from this research could be translated into actionable design strategies for shaping the realities of future technologies to better align with user expectations and promote greater acceptability and adoption.

Conclusion

This paper presents a novel, interdisciplinary approach that combines design fiction and breaching experiments to better understand the challenges of technology acceptance and adoption. By provoking reactions to speculative future scenarios, the researchers are able to surface the taken-for-granted assumptions and expectations that people have about how technology should function in their everyday lives.

The insights gained from this approach can inform the design and development of future technologies, helping to address potential barriers to acceptance and adoption before they become significant issues. This research contributes to the broader HCI goal of understanding and shaping human-technology assemblages in the age of emerging and generative technologies.