Differentiable Logic Programming for Distant Supervision
0
🏋️
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- A new method is introduced for integrating neural networks with logic programming in Neural-Symbolic AI (NeSy).
- The method aims to enable learning with distant supervision, where direct labels are unavailable.
- Unlike prior methods, this approach does not rely on symbolic solvers for reasoning about missing labels.
- Instead, it evaluates logical implications and constraints in a differentiable manner by embedding both neural network outputs and logic programs into matrices.
- This approach facilitates more efficient learning under distant supervision.
Plain English Explanation
This new method combines neural networks and logic programming in a way that allows for more effective learning when direct labels for the training data are not available.
Rather than relying on specialized symbolic solvers to reason about the missing labels, this technique represents both the neural network outputs and the logic programs as matrices. This allows the system to evaluate the logical implications and constraints in a way that can be optimized using standard machine learning techniques.
The key advantage of this approach is that it can learn more efficiently when only indirect or "distant" supervision is available, rather than requiring fully labeled training data. This makes it a potentially useful tool for transferring knowledge and reasoning in situations where direct labels are hard to obtain.
Technical Explanation
The core innovation of this method is the way it integrates neural networks and logic programming in a differentiable framework. Rather than using symbolic solvers to reason about logical constraints and missing labels, the system represents both the neural network outputs and the logic programs as matrices.
This allows the logical implications to be evaluated in a continuous, differentiable manner, which facilitates more efficient optimization during the learning process. The authors show that this approach not only matches or exceeds the accuracy of other NeSy methods across various tasks, but also speeds up the overall learning.
Importantly, this technique does not require access to fully labeled training data. Instead, it can work with "distant supervision", where the direct labels may be incomplete or unavailable. By reasoning about the logical constraints in a differentiable way, the system can still learn effectively from this type of indirect supervision.
Critical Analysis
The key strengths of this approach are its ability to learn efficiently from distant supervision, and its integration of neural networks and logic programming in a unified, differentiable framework. This addresses important limitations of prior NeSy methods that relied on symbolic solvers and required fully labeled training data.
However, the paper does not provide a deep analysis of the limitations or potential issues with this technique. For example, it's not clear how the matrix-based representation of logic programs scales to more complex or higher-order logical constraints. There may also be challenges in interpreting the learned models and ensuring they behave as intended from a logical perspective.
Additionally, the experiments in the paper focus on a relatively narrow set of tasks. Further research would be needed to assess the broader applicability of this method and its robustness to different types of distant supervision signals or more complex reasoning requirements.
Conclusion
This new method for integrating neural networks and logic programming in NeSy represents an important step forward in enabling more efficient and effective learning from indirect or incomplete supervision. By embedding the logical constraints in a differentiable framework, it avoids the limitations of prior symbolic approaches and opens up new possibilities for reliable reasoning in a wide range of real-world applications.
While the paper does not fully explore the potential issues or limitations of this technique, the core ideas and results suggest it is a promising direction for further research and development in the field of Neural-Symbolic AI.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏋️
0
Differentiable Logic Programming for Distant Supervision
Akihiro Takemura, Katsumi Inoue
We introduce a new method for integrating neural networks with logic programming in Neural-Symbolic AI (NeSy), aimed at learning with distant supervision, in which direct labels are unavailable. Unlike prior methods, our approach does not depend on symbolic solvers for reasoning about missing labels. Instead, it evaluates logical implications and constraints in a differentiable manner by embedding both neural network outputs and logic programs into matrices. This method facilitates more efficient learning under distant supervision. We evaluated our approach against existing methods while maintaining a constant volume of training data. The findings indicate that our method not only matches or exceeds the accuracy of other methods across various tasks but also speeds up the learning process. These results highlight the potential of our approach to enhance both accuracy and learning efficiency in NeSy applications.
Read more8/27/2024
🤿
0
Semantic Objective Functions: A distribution-aware method for adding logical constraints in deep learning
Miguel Angel Mendez-Lucero, Enrique Bojorquez Gallardo, Vaishak Belle
Issues of safety, explainability, and efficiency are of increasing concern in learning systems deployed with hard and soft constraints. Symbolic Constrained Learning and Knowledge Distillation techniques have shown promising results in this area, by embedding and extracting knowledge, as well as providing logical constraints during neural network training. Although many frameworks exist to date, through an integration of logic and information geometry, we provide a construction and theoretical framework for these tasks that generalize many approaches. We propose a loss-based method that embeds knowledge-enforces logical constraints-into a machine learning model that outputs probability distributions. This is done by constructing a distribution from the external knowledge/logic formula and constructing a loss function as a linear combination of the original loss function with the Fisher-Rao distance or Kullback-Leibler divergence to the constraint distribution. This construction includes logical constraints in the form of propositional formulas (Boolean variables), formulas of a first-order language with finite variables over a model with compact domain (categorical and continuous variables), and in general, likely applicable to any statistical model that was pretrained with semantic information. We evaluate our method on a variety of learning tasks, including classification tasks with logic constraints, transferring knowledge from logic formulas, and knowledge distillation from general distributions.
Read more5/28/2024
0
Simple and Effective Transfer Learning for Neuro-Symbolic Integration
Alessandro Daniele, Tommaso Campari, Sagar Malhotra, Luciano Serafini
Deep Learning (DL) techniques have achieved remarkable successes in recent years. However, their ability to generalize and execute reasoning tasks remains a challenge. A potential solution to this issue is Neuro-Symbolic Integration (NeSy), where neural approaches are combined with symbolic reasoning. Most of these methods exploit a neural network to map perceptions to symbols and a logical reasoner to predict the output of the downstream task. These methods exhibit superior generalization capacity compared to fully neural architectures. However, they suffer from several issues, including slow convergence, learning difficulties with complex perception tasks, and convergence to local minima. This paper proposes a simple yet effective method to ameliorate these problems. The key idea involves pretraining a neural model on the downstream task. Then, a NeSy model is trained on the same task via transfer learning, where the weights of the perceptual part are injected from the pretrained network. The key observation of our work is that the neural network fails to generalize only at the level of the symbolic part while being perfectly capable of learning the mapping from perceptions to symbols. We have tested our training strategy on various SOTA NeSy methods and datasets, demonstrating consistent improvements in the aforementioned problems.
Read more7/16/2024
0
Sisteme Hibride de Invatare Automata si Aplicatii
Eduard Hogea, Darian Onchis
In this paper, a deep neural network approach and a neuro-symbolic one are proposed for classification and regression. The neuro-symbolic predictive models based on Logic Tensor Networks are capable of discriminating and in the same time of explaining the characterization of bad connections, called alerts or attacks, and of normal connections. The proposed hybrid systems incorporate both the ability of deep neural networks to improve on their own through experience and the interpretability of the results provided by symbolic artificial intelligence approach. To justify the need for shifting towards hybrid systems, explanation, implementation, and comparison of the dense neural network and the neuro-symbolic network is performed in detail. For the comparison to be relevant, the same datasets were used in training and the metrics resulted have been compared. A review of the resulted metrics shows that while both methods have similar precision in their predictive models, with Logic Tensor Networks being also possible to have interactive accuracy and deductive reasoning over data. Other advantages and disadvantages such as overfitting mitigation and scalability issues are also further discussed.
Read more6/19/2024