DiskGNN: Bridging I/O Efficiency and Model Accuracy for Out-of-Core GNN Training
0
📈
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Graph neural networks (GNNs) are a type of machine learning model specialized for processing graph-structured data
- To train GNNs on large graphs that exceed CPU memory, some systems store data on disk and conduct out-of-core processing
- However, these systems suffer from either read amplification or degraded model accuracy
- The paper introduces a system called DiskGNN that aims to achieve high I/O efficiency and fast training without hurting model accuracy
Plain English Explanation
Graph neural networks (GNNs) are a type of machine learning model that are particularly good at working with data that is structured like a graph, such as social networks or the internet. To train these models on really large graphs that are too big to fit in a computer's memory, some systems store the data on a hard drive instead and process it from there.
However, these systems that use the hard drive have some issues. They either end up reading a lot more data from the disk than they need to (called "read amplification"), or they have to treat the graph as if it's broken up into separate pieces, which can reduce the accuracy of the model.
To solve this problem, the researchers created a system called DiskGNN. The key idea behind DiskGNN is to do the process of selecting which parts of the graph to look at (called "graph sampling") separately from the actual model computation. This allows them to organize the data on the disk in a way that avoids the read amplification problem and doesn't hurt the model's accuracy.
DiskGNN also has some other clever design choices, like using the computer's memory hierarchy more effectively to reduce disk access, and overlapping the disk reading with other computation to make the whole process faster.
When the researchers compared DiskGNN to other state-of-the-art systems for training GNNs on large graphs, they found that DiskGNN could be over 8 times faster while still getting the same high level of accuracy.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces DiskGNN, a system designed to enable efficient out-of-core training of graph neural networks (GNNs) on large graphs that exceed CPU memory.
The key innovation in DiskGNN is offline sampling, which decouples the graph sampling process from the model computation. By conducting the graph sampling beforehand, DiskGNN can pack the node features that will be accessed by the model computation contiguously on disk, avoiding the read amplification issue that plagues other out-of-core GNN training systems.
In addition, DiskGNN employs several other techniques to improve efficiency:
- A four-level feature store that leverages the memory hierarchy to cache node features and reduce disk access.
- Batched packing to accelerate the process of packing node features on disk.
- Pipelined training to overlap disk access with other operations.
The paper compares DiskGNN with two state-of-the-art out-of-core GNN training systems, Ginex and MariusGNN. The results show that DiskGNN can speed up these baselines by over 8x while matching their best model accuracy.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a thorough evaluation of DiskGNN's performance against strong baselines, demonstrating its effectiveness at enabling efficient out-of-core GNN training. However, the authors acknowledge some limitations:
- The current implementation of DiskGNN is focused on transductive learning tasks, where the full graph is available during training. Extending it to inductive learning tasks, where the model needs to generalize to unseen nodes or graphs, may require additional research.
- The offline sampling process introduces some overhead, and the authors suggest exploring ways to further optimize this step.
- DiskGNN currently only supports homogeneous graphs, and extending it to handle heterogeneous graphs could be an interesting direction for future work.
Additionally, while the paper covers the core technical details of DiskGNN, it would be valuable to see more discussion on the broader implications and potential real-world applications of this work. For example, how might DiskGNN enable the use of GNNs in domains with extremely large graph-structured datasets, such as social network analysis or dynamic graph modeling?
Conclusion
The DiskGNN system presented in this paper represents an important advancement in enabling efficient out-of-core training of graph neural networks on large-scale graph data. By decoupling graph sampling from model computation and employing various optimization techniques, DiskGNN achieves significant speedups over state-of-the-art baselines without sacrificing model accuracy.
This work has the potential to unlock the use of GNNs in a wider range of applications that involve massive graph-structured datasets, such as distributed matrix-based sampling for GNNs or cost-efficient scalable distributed training of GNNs. As the field of graph machine learning continues to evolve, innovations like DiskGNN will be crucial for pushing the boundaries of what is possible with these powerful techniques.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📈
0
DiskGNN: Bridging I/O Efficiency and Model Accuracy for Out-of-Core GNN Training
Renjie Liu, Yichuan Wang, Xiao Yan, Zhenkun Cai, Minjie Wang, Haitian Jiang, Bo Tang, Jinyang Li
Graph neural networks (GNNs) are machine learning models specialized for graph data and widely used in many applications. To train GNNs on large graphs that exceed CPU memory, several systems store data on disk and conduct out-of-core processing. However, these systems suffer from either read amplification when reading node features that are usually smaller than a disk page or degraded model accuracy by treating the graph as disconnected partitions. To close this gap, we build a system called DiskGNN, which achieves high I/O efficiency and thus fast training without hurting model accuracy. The key technique used by DiskGNN is offline sampling, which helps decouple graph sampling from model computation. In particular, by conducting graph sampling beforehand, DiskGNN acquires the node features that will be accessed by model computation, and such information is utilized to pack the target node features contiguously on disk to avoid read amplification. Besides, name{} also adopts designs including four-level feature store to fully utilize the memory hierarchy to cache node features and reduce disk access, batched packing to accelerate the feature packing process, and pipelined training to overlap disk access with other operations. We compare DiskGNN with Ginex and MariusGNN, which are state-of-the-art systems for out-of-core GNN training. The results show that DiskGNN can speed up the baselines by over 8x while matching their best model accuracy.
Read more5/9/2024
0
Reducing Memory Contention and I/O Congestion for Disk-based GNN Training
Qisheng Jiang, Lei Jia, Chundong Wang
Graph neural networks (GNNs) gain wide popularity. Large graphs with high-dimensional features become common and training GNNs on them is non-trivial on an ordinary machine. Given a gigantic graph, even sample-based GNN training cannot work efficiently, since it is difficult to keep the graph's entire data in memory during the training process. Leveraging a solid-state drive (SSD) or other storage devices to extend the memory space has been studied in training GNNs. Memory and I/Os are hence critical for effectual disk-based training. We find that state-of-the-art (SoTA) disk-based GNN training systems severely suffer from issues like the memory contention between a graph's topological and feature data, and severe I/O congestion upon loading data from SSD for training. We accordingly develop GNNDrive. GNNDrive 1) minimizes the memory footprint with holistic buffer management across sampling and extracting, and 2) avoids I/O congestion through a strategy of asynchronous feature extraction. It also avoids costly data preparation on the critical path and makes the most of software and hardware resources. Experiments show that GNNDrive achieves superior performance. For example, when training with the Papers100M dataset and GraphSAGE model, GNNDrive is faster than SoTA PyG+, Ginex, and MariusGNN by 16.9x, 2.6x, and 2.7x, respectively.
Read more6/21/2024
0
Slicing Input Features to Accelerate Deep Learning: A Case Study with Graph Neural Networks
Zhengjia Xu, Dingyang Lyu, Jinghui Zhang
As graphs grow larger, full-batch GNN training becomes hard for single GPU memory. Therefore, to enhance the scalability of GNN training, some studies have proposed sampling-based mini-batch training and distributed graph learning. However, these methods still have drawbacks, such as performance degradation and heavy communication. This paper introduces SliceGCN, a feature-sliced distributed large-scale graph learning method. SliceGCN slices the node features, with each computing device, i.e., GPU, handling partial features. After each GPU processes its share, partial representations are obtained and concatenated to form complete representations, enabling a single GPU's memory to handle the entire graph structure. This aims to avoid the accuracy loss typically associated with mini-batch training (due to incomplete graph structures) and to reduce inter-GPU communication during message passing (the forward propagation process of GNNs). To study and mitigate potential accuracy reductions due to slicing features, this paper proposes feature fusion and slice encoding. Experiments were conducted on six node classification datasets, yielding some interesting analytical results. These results indicate that while SliceGCN does not enhance efficiency on smaller datasets, it does improve efficiency on larger datasets. Additionally, we found that SliceGCN and its variants have better convergence, feature fusion and slice encoding can make training more stable, reduce accuracy fluctuations, and this study also discovered that the design of SliceGCN has a potentially parameter-efficient nature.
Read more8/22/2024
🏋️
0
GraNNDis: Efficient Unified Distributed Training Framework for Deep GNNs on Large Clusters
Jaeyong Song, Hongsun Jang, Jaewon Jung, Youngsok Kim, Jinho Lee
Graph neural networks (GNNs) are one of the rapidly growing fields within deep learning. While many distributed GNN training frameworks have been proposed to increase the training throughput, they face three limitations when applied to multi-server clusters. 1) They suffer from an inter-server communication bottleneck because they do not consider the inter-/intra-server bandwidth gap, a representative characteristic of multi-server clusters. 2) Redundant memory usage and computation hinder the scalability of the distributed frameworks. 3) Sampling methods, de facto standard in mini-batch training, incur unnecessary errors in multi-server clusters. We found that these limitations can be addressed by exploiting the characteristics of multi-server clusters. Here, we propose GraNNDis, a fast distributed GNN training framework for multi-server clusters. Firstly, we present Flexible Preloading, which preloads the essential vertex dependencies server-wise to reduce the low-bandwidth inter-server communications. Secondly, we introduce Cooperative Batching, which enables memory-efficient, less redundant mini-batch training by utilizing high-bandwidth intra-server communications. Thirdly, we propose Expansion-aware Sampling, a cluster-aware sampling method, which samples the edges that affect the system speedup. As sampling the intra-server dependencies does not contribute much to the speedup as they are communicated through fast intra-server links, it only targets a server boundary to be sampled. Lastly, we introduce One-Hop Graph Masking, a computation and communication structure to realize the above methods in multi-server environments. We evaluated GraNNDis on multi-server clusters, and it provided significant speedup over the state-of-the-art distributed GNN training frameworks. GraNNDis is open-sourced at https://github.com/AIS-SNU/GraNNDis_Artifact to facilitate its use.
Read more8/14/2024