Disordered-DABS: A Benchmark for Dynamic Aspect-Based Summarization in Disordered Texts
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new benchmark dataset called Disordered-DABS for evaluating dynamic aspect-based summarization (DABS) models on disordered text.
- DABS aims to automatically generate summaries that highlight key aspects and their changes over time in a given text.
- The Disordered-DABS dataset consists of customer reviews with randomly shuffled sentences, simulating the challenges of processing disorganized text.
Plain English Explanation
The paper presents a new dataset called Disordered-DABS that can be used to test how well AI models can summarize key information from text that is out of order. Aspect-based summarization is a technique that tries to identify the main topics or "aspects" in a piece of text and summarize how they change over time. This is a useful skill for things like analyzing customer reviews, where people may jump around between different aspects of a product or service.
However, most current aspect-based summarization models assume the text is in a normal, organized order. The Disordered-DABS dataset challenges these models by randomly shuffling the sentences, simulating text that is disorganized or disjointed. This allows researchers to better understand how well these models can handle real-world scenarios where the information isn't presented in a clear, linear fashion.
By creating this new benchmark, the paper aims to spur the development of more robust and practical dynamic aspect-based summarization models that can summarize key information even from messy, disordered text. This could have applications in areas like customer service, market research, or medical records analysis.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces a new benchmark dataset called Disordered-DABS for evaluating dynamic aspect-based summarization (DABS) models on disorganized text. DABS is a task that aims to automatically generate summaries highlighting key aspects and their changes over time in a given text.
To create Disordered-DABS, the authors start with an existing DABS dataset of customer reviews and randomly shuffle the order of the sentences. This simulates the challenges of processing text that is out of sequence, such as in real-world scenarios where information may be presented in a disjointed manner.
The paper also provides baseline results using several state-of-the-art DABS models, including MoDabs and JADS. These models show a significant performance drop when evaluated on the Disordered-DABS dataset compared to the original ordered version, highlighting the need for more robust DABS techniques.
The authors propose that the Disordered-DABS benchmark can spur further research into improving aspect-based summarization for disordered or disorganized text, which has important real-world applications in areas like customer service, market research, and medical informatics.
Critical Analysis
The Disordered-DABS benchmark provides a valuable new testing ground for DABS models, as it captures the challenges of processing text that is out of sequence. However, the authors acknowledge that the random shuffling of sentences may not fully reflect the complexities of real-world disordered text, which may exhibit more subtle patterns or structures.
Additionally, while the baseline results demonstrate the performance drop of existing DABS models on Disordered-DABS, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the specific weaknesses or failure modes of these models. Further research is needed to understand the root causes of the performance degradation and develop more targeted solutions.
The paper also does not explore the potential trade-offs or design considerations in creating DABS models that are robust to disordered text. For example, it's unclear whether techniques that improve performance on Disordered-DABS may come at the cost of reduced accuracy on well-structured text.
Overall, the Disordered-DABS benchmark is a useful contribution to the field, but further research is needed to fully understand the challenges of dynamic aspect-based summarization in real-world, disorganized text and develop effective solutions.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a new benchmark dataset called Disordered-DABS for evaluating dynamic aspect-based summarization (DABS) models on disorganized text. The dataset consists of customer reviews with randomly shuffled sentences, simulating the challenges of processing information that is out of sequence.
By providing this benchmark, the authors aim to spur the development of more robust and practical DABS models that can effectively summarize key aspects and their changes even in the presence of disorganized or messy text. This has important applications in areas like customer service, market research, and medical informatics, where information is often presented in a non-linear or fragmented manner.
The baseline results on Disordered-DABS demonstrate the limitations of existing DABS techniques, which struggle to maintain performance when faced with disordered text. Further research is needed to understand the specific weaknesses of these models and develop more effective solutions for this important real-world challenge.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Disordered-DABS: A Benchmark for Dynamic Aspect-Based Summarization in Disordered Texts
Xiaobo Guo, Soroush Vosoughi
Aspect-based summarization has seen significant advancements, especially in structured text. Yet, summarizing disordered, large-scale texts, like those found in social media and customer feedback, remains a significant challenge. Current research largely targets predefined aspects within structured texts, neglecting the complexities of dynamic and disordered environments. Addressing this gap, we introduce Disordered-DABS, a novel benchmark for dynamic aspect-based summarization tailored to unstructured text. Developed by adapting existing datasets for cost-efficiency and scalability, our comprehensive experiments and detailed human evaluations reveal that Disordered-DABS poses unique challenges to contemporary summarization models, including state-of-the-art language models such as GPT-3.5.
Read more6/19/2024
0
MODABS: Multi-Objective Learning for Dynamic Aspect-Based Summarization
Xiaobo Guo, Soroush Vosoughi
The rapid proliferation of online content necessitates effective summarization methods, among which dynamic aspect-based summarization stands out. Unlike its traditional counterpart, which assumes a fixed set of known aspects, this approach adapts to the varied aspects of the input text. We introduce a novel multi-objective learning framework employing a Longformer-Encoder-Decoder for this task. The framework optimizes aspect number prediction, minimizes disparity between generated and reference summaries for each aspect, and maximizes dissimilarity across aspect-specific summaries. Extensive experiments show our method significantly outperforms baselines on three diverse datasets, largely due to the effective alignment of generated and reference aspect counts without sacrificing single-aspect summarization quality.
Read more6/19/2024
0
Dynamic Order Template Prediction for Generative Aspect-Based Sentiment Analysis
Yonghyun Jun, Hwanhee Lee
Aspect-based sentiment analysis (ABSA) assesses sentiments towards specific aspects within texts, resulting in detailed sentiment tuples. Previous ABSA models often use static templates to predict all of the elements in the tuples, and these models often fail to accurately capture dependencies between elements. Multi-view prompting method improves the performance of ABSA by predicting tuples with various templates and then ensembling the results. However, this method suffers from inefficiencies and out-of-distribution errors. In this paper, we propose a Dynamic Order Template (DOT) method for ABSA, which dynamically generates necessary views for each instance based on instance-level entropy. Ensuring the diverse and relevant view generation, our proposed method improves F1-scores on ASQP and ACOS datasets while significantly reducing inference time.
Read more6/18/2024
0
JADS: A Framework for Self-supervised Joint Aspect Discovery and Summarization
Xiaobo Guo, Jay Desai, Srinivasan H. Sengamedu
To generate summaries that include multiple aspects or topics for text documents, most approaches use clustering or topic modeling to group relevant sentences and then generate a summary for each group. These approaches struggle to optimize the summarization and clustering algorithms jointly. On the other hand, aspect-based summarization requires known aspects. Our solution integrates topic discovery and summarization into a single step. Given text data, our Joint Aspect Discovery and Summarization algorithm (JADS) discovers aspects from the input and generates a summary of the topics, in one step. We propose a self-supervised framework that creates a labeled dataset by first mixing sentences from multiple documents (e.g., CNN/DailyMail articles) as the input and then uses the article summaries from the mixture as the labels. The JADS model outperforms the two-step baselines. With pretraining, the model achieves better performance and stability. Furthermore, embeddings derived from JADS exhibit superior clustering capabilities. Our proposed method achieves higher semantic alignment with ground truth and is factual.
Read more5/30/2024