Do Pre-trained Models Benefit Equally in Continual Learning?

Overview

• Existing continual learning (CL) algorithms focus on training models from scratch, but they perform poorly in real-world scenarios.
• This paper advocates for the systematic introduction of pre-training to CL, which can help transfer knowledge to downstream tasks.
• The paper explores the complexity of exploiting pre-trained models for CL, including the interaction between pre-trained models, CL algorithms, and CL scenarios.
• Interestingly, improvements in CL algorithms from pre-training are inconsistent, and a previously underperforming algorithm can become state-of-the-art when starting from a pre-trained model.
• The paper makes several other important observations, such as the benefits of less regularization and the limitations of stronger pre-trained models.

Plain English Explanation

Continual learning (CL) is the ability of AI systems to learn new tasks or information without forgetting what they've learned before. Most existing CL algorithms focus on training models from scratch, but these models often struggle in real-world scenarios.

This paper suggests that we should systematically incorporate pre-training into CL. Pre-training is a common technique in AI where a model is first trained on a large, general dataset and then fine-tuned for a specific task. The paper argues that pre-training could help CL models transfer knowledge more effectively to new tasks.

The paper explores the complexities of using pre-trained models for CL. It looks at how the choice of pre-trained model, the CL algorithm, and the CL scenario all interact to impact performance. Interestingly, the paper finds that a CL algorithm that performs poorly when trained from scratch can become highly competitive when starting from a pre-trained model. This suggests that the current practice of comparing CL methods in a from-scratch setting may not accurately reflect their real-world potential.

The paper also makes several other observations. For example, CL algorithms that use less regularization (constraints on the model) tend to benefit more from pre-training. Additionally, a stronger pre-trained model, like the CLIP model, does not necessarily guarantee better improvements in CL performance.

Based on these findings, the paper introduces a simple yet effective CL baseline that uses minimal regularization and leverages a beneficial pre-trained model. The researchers recommend that this baseline be included in future CL algorithm development, as it has shown state-of-the-art performance.

Technical Explanation

The paper starts by highlighting the limitations of existing continual learning (CL) algorithms, which are primarily designed for training models from scratch. Despite their impressive performance on artificial benchmarks, these algorithms struggle in real-world scenarios.

To address this, the paper advocates for the systematic introduction of pre-training to CL. Pre-training is a well-established technique for transferring knowledge from large, general datasets to downstream tasks, but it has been largely underexplored in the CL community.

The core of the paper's investigation is the multifaceted complexity of exploiting pre-trained models for CL. The authors examine this complexity along three key axes: pre-trained models, CL algorithms, and CL scenarios.

One of the most intriguing findings is that improvements in CL algorithms from pre-training are highly inconsistent. The paper shows that a previously underperforming CL algorithm can become competitive or even state-of-the-art when all algorithms start from a pre-trained model. This suggests that the current practice of comparing CL methods in a from-scratch setting may not accurately reflect their true potential.

The paper also makes several other important observations. For example, CL algorithms that use less regularization tend to benefit more from a pre-trained model. Additionally, the authors find that a stronger pre-trained model, such as CLIP, does not necessarily guarantee better improvements in CL performance.

Based on these insights, the paper introduces a simple yet effective CL baseline that employs minimal regularization and leverages a beneficial pre-trained model, using a two-stage training pipeline. The researchers recommend including this baseline in future CL algorithm development, as it has demonstrated state-of-the-art performance.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a comprehensive and thought-provoking investigation into the role of pre-training in continual learning (CL). The authors rightly point out the limitations of existing CL algorithms, which have been primarily evaluated in a from-scratch training setting. By systematically exploring the interaction between pre-trained models, CL algorithms, and CL scenarios, the paper offers valuable insights that challenge the current CL research paradigm.

One potential limitation of the paper is the scope of the experiments, which mainly focus on image classification tasks. While these tasks are commonly used in CL research, it would be interesting to see how the findings translate to other domains, such as natural language processing or reinforcement learning.

Additionally, the paper does not delve into the specific mechanisms by which pre-training can benefit CL. A deeper analysis of the transfer learning dynamics and the role of different pre-training objectives could provide further insights and guide the development of more effective CL algorithms.

Despite these minor limitations, the paper's key contributions are significant. The finding that a previously underperforming CL algorithm can become competitive or even state-of-the-art when starting from a pre-trained model is particularly intriguing and highlights the need to reconsider the current CL evaluation paradigm.

The introduction of the simple yet effective CL baseline is also noteworthy, as it demonstrates the potential for leveraging pre-training to improve CL performance. This baseline can serve as a valuable reference point for future CL research and development.

Conclusion

This paper advocates for the systematic incorporation of pre-training into continual learning (CL) research, arguing that it can help transfer knowledge more effectively to downstream tasks. The authors' investigation reveals the complex interplay between pre-trained models, CL algorithms, and CL scenarios, leading to several important observations.

Perhaps the most striking finding is that improvements in CL algorithms from pre-training are highly inconsistent, with a previously underperforming algorithm becoming competitive or even state-of-the-art when starting from a pre-trained model. This suggests that the current practice of comparing CL methods in a from-scratch setting may not accurately reflect their true potential.

Based on these insights, the paper introduces a simple yet effective CL baseline that employs minimal regularization and leverages a beneficial pre-trained model. The researchers recommend including this baseline in future CL algorithm development, as it has demonstrated state-of-the-art performance.

Overall, this paper makes a compelling case for the systematic integration of pre-training into CL research, opening up new avenues for developing more robust and effective CL systems that can better adapt to real-world scenarios.