Do Pretrained Contextual Language Models Distinguish between Hebrew Homograph Analyses?
2405.07099
0
0
💬
Abstract
Semitic morphologically-rich languages (MRLs) are characterized by extreme word ambiguity. Because most vowels are omitted in standard texts, many of the words are homographs with multiple possible analyses, each with a different pronunciation and different morphosyntactic properties. This ambiguity goes beyond word-sense disambiguation (WSD), and may include token segmentation into multiple word units. Previous research on MRLs claimed that standardly trained pre-trained language models (PLMs) based on word-pieces may not sufficiently capture the internal structure of such tokens in order to distinguish between these analyses. Taking Hebrew as a case study, we investigate the extent to which Hebrew homographs can be disambiguated and analyzed using PLMs. We evaluate all existing models for contextualized Hebrew embeddings on a novel Hebrew homograph challenge sets that we deliver. Our empirical results demonstrate that contemporary Hebrew contextualized embeddings outperform non-contextualized embeddings; and that they are most effective for disambiguating segmentation and morphosyntactic features, less so regarding pure word-sense disambiguation. We show that these embeddings are more effective when the number of word-piece splits is limited, and they are more effective for 2-way and 3-way ambiguities than for 4-way ambiguity. We show that the embeddings are equally effective for homographs of both balanced and skewed distributions, whether calculated as masked or unmasked tokens. Finally, we show that these embeddings are as effective for homograph disambiguation with extensive supervised training as with a few-shot setup.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Semitic morphologically-rich languages (MRLs) like Hebrew have extreme word ambiguity due to missing vowels in standard texts.
- Many words are homographs with multiple possible analyses, each with different pronunciations and morphosyntactic properties.
- This ambiguity goes beyond just word-sense disambiguation (WSD) and may include segmenting a token into multiple word units.
- Previous research claims that standard pre-trained language models (PLMs) may not sufficiently capture the internal structure of these ambiguous tokens.
Plain English Explanation
In languages like Hebrew, the written text often leaves out vowels. This leads to a lot of ambiguity, where a single written word can have multiple possible meanings, pronunciations, and grammatical properties. This goes beyond just determining the specific sense or definition of a word, and can even involve breaking a single written word into multiple words.
For example, the Hebrew word "ספר" could be read as "sefer" (book), "saper" (barber), or "se'ifar" (to count), each with a different meaning, sound, and grammatical function. Standard language models trained on this type of text may struggle to fully capture these nuances and disambiguate the different possible interpretations of a single written word.
Technical Explanation
The paper investigates how well contemporary pre-trained language models (PLMs) can handle this extreme ambiguity in Hebrew, a Semitic morphologically-rich language (MRL). They evaluate various contextualized Hebrew embedding models on a novel Hebrew homograph challenge set, which tests the models' ability to disambiguate the segmentation, morphosyntactic features, and word senses of ambiguous Hebrew tokens.
The results show that the contextualized Hebrew embeddings outperform non-contextualized embeddings at these disambiguation tasks. However, they are more effective at disambiguating segmentation and morphosyntactic features than pure word-sense disambiguation. The embeddings work best when the number of possible word-piece splits is limited, and they are more effective for 2-way and 3-way ambiguities than 4-way. Importantly, the embeddings perform similarly well whether the homographs have a balanced or skewed distribution, and whether they are evaluated as masked or unmasked tokens.
Critical Analysis
The paper provides a valuable empirical analysis of how current language models handle the extreme ambiguity present in Semitic MRLs like Hebrew. However, it does not explore the underlying reasons for the models' relative strengths and weaknesses in this domain. Further research is needed to align language models to more explicitly handle this type of ambiguity.
Additionally, the paper focuses only on Hebrew, so it's unclear how generalizable the findings are to other Semitic MRLs. Expanding the evaluation to additional languages would help assess the broader applicability of the insights.
Conclusion
This research highlights the challenges that pre-trained language models face when dealing with the extreme ambiguity present in Semitic morphologically-rich languages like Hebrew. While current contextualized Hebrew embeddings outperform non-contextualized models, they still have room for improvement, particularly when it comes to pure word-sense disambiguation. Addressing this issue could lead to more robust and accurate natural language processing for these languages, with potential benefits for applications ranging from machine translation to question-answering.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Persian Homograph Disambiguation: Leveraging ParsBERT for Enhanced Sentence Understanding with a Novel Word Disambiguation Dataset
Seyed Moein Ayyoubzadeh
0
0
Homograph disambiguation, the task of distinguishing words with identical spellings but different meanings, poses a substantial challenge in natural language processing. In this study, we introduce a novel dataset tailored for Persian homograph disambiguation. Our work encompasses a thorough exploration of various embeddings, evaluated through the cosine similarity method and their efficacy in downstream tasks like classification. Our investigation entails training a diverse array of lightweight machine learning and deep learning models for phonograph disambiguation. We scrutinize the models' performance in terms of Accuracy, Recall, and F1 Score, thereby gaining insights into their respective strengths and limitations. The outcomes of our research underscore three key contributions. First, we present a newly curated Persian dataset, providing a solid foundation for future research in homograph disambiguation. Second, our comparative analysis of embeddings highlights their utility in different contexts, enriching the understanding of their capabilities. Third, by training and evaluating a spectrum of models, we extend valuable guidance for practitioners in selecting suitable strategies for homograph disambiguation tasks. In summary, our study unveils a new dataset, scrutinizes embeddings through diverse perspectives, and benchmarks various models for homograph disambiguation. These findings empower researchers and practitioners to navigate the intricate landscape of homograph-related challenges effectively.
6/4/2024
Bidirectional Transformer Representations of (Spanish) Ambiguous Words in Context: A New Lexical Resource and Empirical Analysis
Pamela D. Rivi`ere (Department of Cognitive Science UC San Diego), Anne L. Beatty-Mart'inez (Department of Cognitive Science UC San Diego), Sean Trott (Department of Cognitive Science UC San Diego, Computational Social Science UC San Diego)
0
0
Lexical ambiguity -- where a single wordform takes on distinct, context-dependent meanings -- serves as a useful tool to compare across different large language models' (LLMs') ability to form distinct, contextualized representations of the same stimulus. Few studies have systematically compared LLMs' contextualized word embeddings for languages beyond English. Here, we evaluate multiple bidirectional transformers' (BERTs') semantic representations of Spanish ambiguous nouns in context. We develop a novel dataset of minimal-pair sentences evoking the same or different sense for a target ambiguous noun. In a pre-registered study, we collect contextualized human relatedness judgments for each sentence pair. We find that various BERT-based LLMs' contextualized semantic representations capture some variance in human judgments but fall short of the human benchmark, and for Spanish -- unlike English -- model scale is uncorrelated with performance. We also identify stereotyped trajectories of target noun disambiguation as a proportion of traversal through a given LLM family's architecture, which we partially replicate in English. We contribute (1) a dataset of controlled, Spanish sentence stimuli with human relatedness norms, and (2) to our evolving understanding of the impact that LLM specification (architectures, training protocols) exerts on contextualized embeddings.
6/24/2024
🤔
Shortcomings of LLMs for Low-Resource Translation: Retrieval and Understanding are Both the Problem
Sara Court, Micha Elsner
0
0
This work investigates the in-context learning abilities of pretrained large language models (LLMs) when instructed to translate text from a low-resource language into a high-resource language as part of an automated machine translation pipeline. We conduct a set of experiments translating Southern Quechua to Spanish and examine the informativity of various types of information retrieved from a constrained database of digitized pedagogical materials (dictionaries and grammar lessons) and parallel corpora. Using both automatic and human evaluation of model output, we conduct ablation studies that manipulate (1) context type (morpheme translations, grammar descriptions, and corpus examples), (2) retrieval methods (automated vs. manual), and (3) model type. Our results suggest that even relatively small LLMs are capable of utilizing prompt context for zero-shot low-resource translation when provided a minimally sufficient amount of relevant linguistic information. However, the variable effects of prompt type, retrieval method, model type, and language-specific factors highlight the limitations of using even the best LLMs as translation systems for the majority of the world's 7,000+ languages and their speakers.
6/26/2024
🛸
Using Contextual Information for Sentence-level Morpheme Segmentation
Prabin Bhandari, Abhishek Paudel
0
0
Recent advancements in morpheme segmentation primarily emphasize word-level segmentation, often neglecting the contextual relevance within the sentence. In this study, we redefine the morpheme segmentation task as a sequence-to-sequence problem, treating the entire sentence as input rather than isolating individual words. Our findings reveal that the multilingual model consistently exhibits superior performance compared to monolingual counterparts. While our model did not surpass the performance of the current state-of-the-art, it demonstrated comparable efficacy with high-resource languages while revealing limitations in low-resource language scenarios.
5/15/2024