Does End-to-End Autonomous Driving Really Need Perception Tasks?

Read original: arXiv:2409.18341 - Published 9/30/2024 by Peidong Li, Dixiao Cui

🌐

Overview

Autonomous driving systems typically rely on supervised perception tasks to understand the driving environment
This approach requires expensive data annotations and limits scalability in real-time applications
This paper introduces a novel framework called SSR that uses a sparse scene representation to efficiently extract crucial information for autonomous driving
SSR eliminates the need for supervised sub-tasks, allowing resources to focus on navigation-related elements
The framework also includes a temporal enhancement module that aligns predicted future scenes with actual future scenes through self-supervision
SSR achieves state-of-the-art performance on the nuScenes dataset, with significant reductions in planning error and collision rate compared to the leading end-to-end autonomous driving method
SSR also offers much faster inference and training times, making it a promising approach for real-time autonomous driving systems

Plain English Explanation

The paper presents a new method called SSR (Sparse Scene Representation) for end-to-end autonomous driving. Typical autonomous driving systems rely on complex perception algorithms to understand the driving environment, such as detecting objects, roads, and other scene elements. This approach requires a lot of detailed data annotations, which can be expensive and time-consuming to obtain.

The researchers behind SSR recognized that not all scene information is equally important for driving. Instead of trying to understand everything about the environment, SSR focuses on extracting just the essential elements needed for navigation, using only 16 "navigation-guided tokens" as a sparse representation of the scene. This allows the system to concentrate its computational resources on the key pieces of information directly relevant to driving, rather than getting bogged down in unnecessary details.

Additionally, SSR includes a "temporal enhancement module" that helps the system better understand how the driving environment will change over time. By learning to predict future scenes and aligning those predictions with what actually happens, the system can make more accurate decisions about how to navigate.

The results show that SSR outperforms other end-to-end autonomous driving methods, reducing planning errors by over 27% and collision rates by over 51% compared to the previous state-of-the-art. Importantly, SSR also runs much faster, with 10.9x faster inference and 13x faster training than other approaches. This makes it a promising candidate for real-world autonomous driving systems that need to operate in real-time.

Technical Explanation

The core innovation of the SSR framework is its use of a Sparse Scene Representation (SSR) to extract crucial information for autonomous driving. Rather than relying on complex, supervised perception tasks to build a detailed understanding of the environment, SSR uses only 16 "navigation-guided tokens" to capture the essential elements needed for navigation.

This sparse representation is learned through a self-supervised process that directly links the scene information to the vehicle's navigation intent, without the need for expensive manual annotations. By focusing computational resources on these key elements, SSR is able to achieve high performance while significantly reducing the overall complexity of the system.

To further enhance the system's temporal understanding, SSR incorporates a Temporal Enhancement Module that learns to predict future scenes and align those predictions with the actual future state of the environment. This self-supervised learning process helps the system better anticipate how the driving situation will evolve, allowing it to make more informed decisions about how to navigate.

In experiments on the nuScenes dataset, SSR demonstrated state-of-the-art performance, outperforming the leading end-to-end autonomous driving method (UniAD) by a significant margin. Specifically, SSR achieved a 27.2% reduction in L2 planning error and a 51.6% decrease in collision rate, while also offering much faster inference (10.9x) and training (13x) times.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge that the SSR framework has some limitations. For example, the sparse scene representation may not capture all the nuances of the driving environment, and the system's performance may be sensitive to the quality and diversity of the training data. Additionally, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the types of errors or failure cases that the system may encounter in real-world driving scenarios.

That said, the results presented in the paper are quite impressive, and the significant improvements in planning accuracy and inference/training speed suggest that SSR represents a meaningful advancement in the field of end-to-end autonomous driving. The self-supervised learning approach and focus on essential scene elements are particularly noteworthy, as they demonstrate the potential for more efficient and scalable autonomous driving systems.

As the researchers note, future work could explore ways to further enhance the temporal understanding of the system, perhaps by incorporating more advanced world modeling or prediction techniques. Additionally, it would be valuable to see more extensive real-world testing and validation of the SSR framework to better understand its strengths, weaknesses, and potential failure modes.

Conclusion

The SSR framework introduced in this paper represents a significant step forward in the development of end-to-end autonomous driving systems. By using a sparse, navigation-guided scene representation and incorporating a temporal enhancement module, SSR is able to achieve state-of-the-art performance while greatly reducing the computational complexity and resource requirements compared to traditional approaches.

The promising results on the nuScenes dataset, along with the substantial improvements in inference and training speed, suggest that SSR could pave the way for more scalable and real-time autonomous driving solutions. As the technology continues to evolve, it will be important to further explore the system's limitations and investigate ways to make it even more robust and reliable for real-world deployment.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🌐

Does End-to-End Autonomous Driving Really Need Perception Tasks?

Peidong Li, Dixiao Cui

End-to-End Autonomous Driving (E2EAD) methods typically rely on supervised perception tasks to extract explicit scene information (e.g., objects, maps). This reliance necessitates expensive annotations and constrains deployment and data scalability in real-time applications. In this paper, we introduce SSR, a novel framework that utilizes only 16 navigation-guided tokens as Sparse Scene Representation, efficiently extracting crucial scene information for E2EAD. Our method eliminates the need for supervised sub-tasks, allowing computational resources to concentrate on essential elements directly related to navigation intent. We further introduce a temporal enhancement module that employs a Bird's-Eye View (BEV) world model, aligning predicted future scenes with actual future scenes through self-supervision. SSR achieves state-of-the-art planning performance on the nuScenes dataset, demonstrating a 27.2% relative reduction in L2 error and a 51.6% decrease in collision rate to the leading E2EAD method, UniAD. Moreover, SSR offers a 10.9$times$ faster inference speed and 13$times$ faster training time. This framework represents a significant leap in real-time autonomous driving systems and paves the way for future scalable deployment. Code will be released at url{https://github.com/PeidongLi/SSR}.

9/30/2024

SparseDrive: End-to-End Autonomous Driving via Sparse Scene Representation

Wenchao Sun, Xuewu Lin, Yining Shi, Chuang Zhang, Haoran Wu, Sifa Zheng

The well-established modular autonomous driving system is decoupled into different standalone tasks, e.g. perception, prediction and planning, suffering from information loss and error accumulation across modules. In contrast, end-to-end paradigms unify multi-tasks into a fully differentiable framework, allowing for optimization in a planning-oriented spirit. Despite the great potential of end-to-end paradigms, both the performance and efficiency of existing methods are not satisfactory, particularly in terms of planning safety. We attribute this to the computationally expensive BEV (bird's eye view) features and the straightforward design for prediction and planning. To this end, we explore the sparse representation and review the task design for end-to-end autonomous driving, proposing a new paradigm named SparseDrive. Concretely, SparseDrive consists of a symmetric sparse perception module and a parallel motion planner. The sparse perception module unifies detection, tracking and online mapping with a symmetric model architecture, learning a fully sparse representation of the driving scene. For motion prediction and planning, we review the great similarity between these two tasks, leading to a parallel design for motion planner. Based on this parallel design, which models planning as a multi-modal problem, we propose a hierarchical planning selection strategy , which incorporates a collision-aware rescore module, to select a rational and safe trajectory as the final planning output. With such effective designs, SparseDrive surpasses previous state-of-the-arts by a large margin in performance of all tasks, while achieving much higher training and inference efficiency. Code will be avaliable at https://github.com/swc-17/SparseDrive for facilitating future research.

6/3/2024

SparseAD: Sparse Query-Centric Paradigm for Efficient End-to-End Autonomous Driving

Diankun Zhang, Guoan Wang, Runwen Zhu, Jianbo Zhao, Xiwu Chen, Siyu Zhang, Jiahao Gong, Qibin Zhou, Wenyuan Zhang, Ningzi Wang, Feiyang Tan, Hangning Zhou, Ziyao Xu, Haotian Yao, Chi Zhang, Xiaojun Liu, Xiaoguang Di, Bin Li

End-to-End paradigms use a unified framework to implement multi-tasks in an autonomous driving system. Despite simplicity and clarity, the performance of end-to-end autonomous driving methods on sub-tasks is still far behind the single-task methods. Meanwhile, the widely used dense BEV features in previous end-to-end methods make it costly to extend to more modalities or tasks. In this paper, we propose a Sparse query-centric paradigm for end-to-end Autonomous Driving (SparseAD), where the sparse queries completely represent the whole driving scenario across space, time and tasks without any dense BEV representation. Concretely, we design a unified sparse architecture for perception tasks including detection, tracking, and online mapping. Moreover, we revisit motion prediction and planning, and devise a more justifiable motion planner framework. On the challenging nuScenes dataset, SparseAD achieves SOTA full-task performance among end-to-end methods and significantly narrows the performance gap between end-to-end paradigms and single-task methods. Codes will be released soon.

4/11/2024

Hierarchical End-to-End Autonomous Driving: Integrating BEV Perception with Deep Reinforcement Learning

Siyi Lu, Lei He, Shengbo Eben Li, Yugong Luo, Jianqiang Wang, Keqiang Li

End-to-end autonomous driving offers a streamlined alternative to the traditional modular pipeline, integrating perception, prediction, and planning within a single framework. While Deep Reinforcement Learning (DRL) has recently gained traction in this domain, existing approaches often overlook the critical connection between feature extraction of DRL and perception. In this paper, we bridge this gap by mapping the DRL feature extraction network directly to the perception phase, enabling clearer interpretation through semantic segmentation. By leveraging Bird's-Eye-View (BEV) representations, we propose a novel DRL-based end-to-end driving framework that utilizes multi-sensor inputs to construct a unified three-dimensional understanding of the environment. This BEV-based system extracts and translates critical environmental features into high-level abstract states for DRL, facilitating more informed control. Extensive experimental evaluations demonstrate that our approach not only enhances interpretability but also significantly outperforms state-of-the-art methods in autonomous driving control tasks, reducing the collision rate by 20%.

9/27/2024