Doubly Robust Causal Effect Estimation under Networked Interference via Targeted Learning
2405.03342
0
0
Abstract
Causal effect estimation under networked interference is an important but challenging problem. Available parametric methods are limited in their model space, while previous semiparametric methods, e.g., leveraging neural networks to fit only one single nuisance function, may still encounter misspecification problems under networked interference without appropriate assumptions on the data generation process. To mitigate bias stemming from misspecification, we propose a novel doubly robust causal effect estimator under networked interference, by adapting the targeted learning technique to the training of neural networks. Specifically, we generalize the targeted learning technique into the networked interference setting and establish the condition under which an estimator achieves double robustness. Based on the condition, we devise an end-to-end causal effect estimator by transforming the identified theoretical condition into a targeted loss. Moreover, we provide a theoretical analysis of our designed estimator, revealing a faster convergence rate compared to a single nuisance model. Extensive experimental results on two real-world networks with semisynthetic data demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed estimators.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a doubly robust method for estimating causal effects under networked interference, where the treatment of one individual can affect the outcomes of their social connections.
- The method uses targeted learning to combine information from both a model of the treatment assignment mechanism and a model of the outcome, providing robust estimates even when one of the models is misspecified.
- The approach can handle complex network structures and various types of interference, making it applicable to a wide range of real-world scenarios.
Plain English Explanation
In many situations, the actions of one person can influence the outcomes of their friends, family, or social connections. This is known as "networked interference." For example, [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/be-aware-neighborhood-effect-modeling-selection-bias] when studying the impact of a new education program, the performance of one student may depend not only on whether they participated, but also on the participation of their classmates.
Traditional statistical methods often fail to properly account for these network effects. This paper introduces a new technique called "doubly robust causal effect estimation" that can provide accurate results even when the researchers' understanding of how the network works is imperfect.
The key idea is to combine two different models: one that predicts who will receive the treatment (e.g., participate in the education program), and one that predicts the outcome (e.g., student performance). By using both of these models together in a clever way, the method can produce reliable estimates of the causal effect, [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/doubly-robust-inference-causal-latent-factor-models] even if one of the models is incorrect.
This approach is particularly useful when dealing with complex social networks, where the connections between people can take many different forms. The technique can handle a wide variety of network structures and interference patterns, making it widely applicable to real-world problems.
Technical Explanation
The authors propose a doubly robust method for estimating causal effects under networked interference, building on the targeted learning framework. [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/neural-networks-causal-graph-constraints-new-approach] The method combines a model of the treatment assignment mechanism (the propensity score) and a model of the outcome, using an efficient influence function (EIF) to obtain a robust estimate of the average treatment effect.
The key innovation is the use of targeted learning to construct the EIF. This involves iteratively updating the initial outcome model to ensure that it captures the relevant network structure and interference patterns. The authors show that the resulting estimator is consistent and asymptotically normal, even when one of the models is misspecified.
[link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/machine-learning-network-inference-enhancement-from-noisy] The method can handle complex network structures, including directed, bipartite, and hierarchical graphs, as well as different types of interference, such as direct, spillover, and general interference. The authors demonstrate the performance of their approach through extensive simulations and an application to a real-world study of a job training program.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a thorough theoretical analysis of their doubly robust estimator, establishing its desirable statistical properties. However, the practical implementation may face some challenges. [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/be-aware-neighborhood-effect-modeling-selection-bias] For example, accurately modeling the treatment assignment mechanism and the outcome in the presence of complex network interference may require substantial data and computational resources, particularly for large-scale networks.
Additionally, the method relies on the assumption that the network structure is known or can be accurately estimated from the data. In many real-world scenarios, the underlying network may be partially observed or subject to measurement error, which could introduce additional biases. Further research is needed to address these practical limitations and extend the method to handle more realistic network settings.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel doubly robust approach for estimating causal effects under networked interference. By leveraging targeted learning techniques, the method can produce robust estimates even when the researchers' understanding of the network structure or the treatment assignment mechanism is imperfect. The versatility of the approach, in terms of handling diverse network topologies and interference patterns, makes it a promising tool for causal inference in complex social and organizational settings. [link to https://aimodels.fyi/papers/arxiv/deep-learning-causal-inference-comparison-architectures-heterogeneous] As researchers continue to explore the implications of network effects in various domains, this work contributes to the growing body of methods for advancing causal understanding in the presence of networked interference.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌐
Graph Machine Learning based Doubly Robust Estimator for Network Causal Effects
Seyedeh Baharan Khatami, Harsh Parikh, Haowei Chen, Sudeepa Roy, Babak Salimi
0
0
We address the challenge of inferring causal effects in social network data. This results in challenges due to interference -- where a unit's outcome is affected by neighbors' treatments -- and network-induced confounding factors. While there is extensive literature focusing on estimating causal effects in social network setups, a majority of them make prior assumptions about the form of network-induced confounding mechanisms. Such strong assumptions are rarely likely to hold especially in high-dimensional networks. We propose a novel methodology that combines graph machine learning approaches with the double machine learning framework to enable accurate and efficient estimation of direct and peer effects using a single observational social network. We demonstrate the semiparametric efficiency of our proposed estimator under mild regularity conditions, allowing for consistent uncertainty quantification. We demonstrate that our method is accurate, robust, and scalable via an extensive simulation study. We use our method to investigate the impact of Self-Help Group participation on financial risk tolerance.
6/4/2024
🎲
Cascade-based Randomization for Inferring Causal Effects under Diffusion Interference
Zahra Fatemi, Jean Pouget-Abadie, Elena Zheleva
0
0
The presence of interference, where the outcome of an individual may depend on the treatment assignment and behavior of neighboring nodes, can lead to biased causal effect estimation. Current approaches to network experiment design focus on limiting interference through cluster-based randomization, in which clusters are identified using graph clustering, and cluster randomization dictates the node assignment to treatment and control. However, cluster-based randomization approaches perform poorly when interference propagates in cascades, whereby the response of individuals to treatment propagates to their multi-hop neighbors. When we have knowledge of the cascade seed nodes, we can leverage this interference structure to mitigate the resulting causal effect estimation bias. With this goal, we propose a cascade-based network experiment design that initiates treatment assignment from the cascade seed node and propagates the assignment to their multi-hop neighbors to limit interference during cascade growth and thereby reduce the overall causal effect estimation error. Our extensive experiments on real-world and synthetic datasets demonstrate that our proposed framework outperforms the existing state-of-the-art approaches in estimating causal effects in network data.
5/22/2024
🤯
Constrained Learning for Causal Inference and Semiparametric Statistics
Tiffany Tianhui Cai, Yuri Fonseca, Kaiwen Hou, Hongseok Namkoong
0
0
Causal estimation (e.g. of the average treatment effect) requires estimating complex nuisance parameters (e.g. outcome models). To adjust for errors in nuisance parameter estimation, we present a novel correction method that solves for the best plug-in estimator under the constraint that the first-order error of the estimator with respect to the nuisance parameter estimate is zero. Our constrained learning framework provides a unifying perspective to prominent first-order correction approaches including one-step estimation (a.k.a. augmented inverse probability weighting) and targeting (a.k.a. targeted maximum likelihood estimation). Our semiparametric inference approach, which we call the C-Learner, can be implemented with modern machine learning methods such as neural networks and tree ensembles, and enjoys standard guarantees like semiparametric efficiency and double robustness. Empirically, we demonstrate our approach on several datasets, including those with text features that require fine-tuning language models. We observe the C-Learner matches or outperforms other asymptotically optimal estimators, with better performance in settings with less estimated overlap.
5/24/2024
Uplift Modeling Under Limited Supervision
George Panagopoulos, Daniele Malitesta, Fragkiskos D. Malliaros, Jun Pang
0
0
Estimating causal effects in e-commerce tends to involve costly treatment assignments which can be impractical in large-scale settings. Leveraging machine learning to predict such treatment effects without actual intervention is a standard practice to diminish the risk. However, existing methods for treatment effect prediction tend to rely on training sets of substantial size, which are built from real experiments and are thus inherently risky to create. In this work we propose a graph neural network to diminish the required training set size, relying on graphs that are common in e-commerce data. Specifically, we view the problem as node regression with a restricted number of labeled instances, develop a two-model neural architecture akin to previous causal effect estimators, and test varying message-passing layers for encoding. Furthermore, as an extra step, we combine the model with an acquisition function to guide the creation of the training set in settings with extremely low experimental budget. The framework is flexible since each step can be used separately with other models or treatment policies. The experiments on real large-scale networks indicate a clear advantage of our methodology over the state of the art, which in many cases performs close to random, underlining the need for models that can generalize with limited supervision to reduce experimental risks.
6/10/2024