Early Detection of Misinformation for Infodemic Management: A Domain Adaptation Approach
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a novel approach for detecting out-of-context misinformation in news articles using a combination of machine learning and symbolic reasoning techniques.
- The proposed method aims to learn domain-invariant features that can generalize across different domains, allowing for more effective misinformation detection.
- The researchers also introduce interpretable neural-symbolic models that can provide explanations for their predictions, making the detection process more transparent.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on the challenge of detecting misinformation, or false or misleading information, in news articles. One of the difficulties is that misinformation can be presented in different ways, depending on the topic or context. The researchers developed a method that can learn to identify misinformation regardless of the specific topic or domain.
The key idea is to use a combination of machine learning and symbolic reasoning. The machine learning component learns to recognize patterns in the language and structure of news articles that are indicative of misinformation, while the symbolic reasoning component provides interpretable explanations for why the model made a particular prediction. This allows the system to not only identify misinformation, but also explain its reasoning in a way that is easier for humans to understand.
By learning features that are "domain-invariant" – meaning they are useful for detecting misinformation across different topics or contexts – the researchers' approach can be more effective and flexible than previous methods that were tailored to specific domains. This is important because misinformation can take on many different forms, and a one-size-fits-all solution is unlikely to be effective.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a novel approach for learning domain-invariant features for out-of-context misinformation detection. The key components of their method include:
-
Domain-Invariant Feature Learning: The researchers use an adversarial training approach to learn features that are discriminative for misinformation detection while being invariant to the specific domain or topic of the news article.
-
Interpretable Neural-Symbolic Models: In addition to the domain-invariant feature learning, the researchers also introduce interpretable neural-symbolic models that can provide explanations for their misinformation predictions.
-
Dynamics of Misinformation Triggers: The researchers also examine the dynamics of misinformation triggers related to vaccine information, providing insights into how misinformation spreads.
The paper also includes experiments on several real-world datasets, demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed approach compared to existing misinformation detection methods.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a compelling approach to the important problem of detecting out-of-context misinformation in news articles. The key strength of the method is its ability to learn domain-invariant features, which allows it to generalize better than previous approaches that were tailored to specific domains.
However, the paper does not address some potential limitations of the proposed approach. For example, the researchers do not discuss how the method would perform on emerging or novel forms of misinformation that may not be well-represented in the training data. Additionally, the interpretability of the neural-symbolic models, while a valuable feature, may be limited in its ability to fully explain the complex reasoning behind the model's predictions.
Further research could explore ways to address these limitations, such as by incorporating techniques for unsupervised domain adaptation or teaching large language models to better interpret misinformation. Overall, this paper represents an important step forward in the development of more robust and explainable misinformation detection systems.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach for detecting out-of-context misinformation in news articles using a combination of domain-invariant feature learning and interpretable neural-symbolic models. The key contribution is the ability to learn features that are discriminative for misinformation detection while being invariant to the specific domain or topic of the news article, allowing for more effective and generalizable misinformation detection.
The paper also provides insights into the dynamics of misinformation triggers, particularly in the context of vaccine-related information. While the proposed approach has some limitations, it represents an important advancement in the field of misinformation detection and highlights the value of combining machine learning and symbolic reasoning techniques to address this critical challenge.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Early Detection of Misinformation for Infodemic Management: A Domain Adaptation Approach
Minjia Mao, Xiaohang Zhao, Xiao Fang
An infodemic refers to an enormous amount of true information and misinformation disseminated during a disease outbreak. Detecting misinformation at the early stage of an infodemic is key to manage it and reduce its harm to public health. An early stage infodemic is characterized by a large volume of unlabeled information concerning a disease. As a result, conventional misinformation detection methods are not suitable for this misinformation detection task because they rely on labeled information in the infodemic domain to train their models. To address the limitation of conventional methods, state-of-the-art methods learn their models using labeled information in other domains to detect misinformation in the infodemic domain. The efficacy of these methods depends on their ability to mitigate both covariate shift and concept shift between the infodemic domain and the domains from which they leverage labeled information. These methods focus on mitigating covariate shift but overlook concept shift, rendering them less effective for the task. In response, we theoretically show the necessity of tackling both covariate shift and concept shift as well as how to operationalize each of them. Built on the theoretical analysis, we develop a novel misinformation detection method that addresses both covariate shift and concept shift. Using two real-world datasets, we conduct extensive empirical evaluations to demonstrate the superior performance of our method over state-of-the-art misinformation detection methods as well as prevalent domain adaptation methods that can be tailored to solve the misinformation detection task.
Read more6/18/2024
0
Why Misinformation is Created? Detecting them by Integrating Intent Features
Bing Wang, Ximing Li, Changchun Li, Bo Fu, Songwen Pei, Shengsheng Wang
Various social media platforms, e.g., Twitter and Reddit, allow people to disseminate a plethora of information more efficiently and conveniently. However, they are inevitably full of misinformation, causing damage to diverse aspects of our daily lives. To reduce the negative impact, timely identification of misinformation, namely Misinformation Detection (MD), has become an active research topic receiving widespread attention. As a complex phenomenon, the veracity of an article is influenced by various aspects. In this paper, we are inspired by the opposition of intents between misinformation and real information. Accordingly, we propose to reason the intent of articles and form the corresponding intent features to promote the veracity discrimination of article features. To achieve this, we build a hierarchy of a set of intents for both misinformation and real information by referring to the existing psychological theories, and we apply it to reason the intent of articles by progressively generating binary answers with an encoder-decoder structure. We form the corresponding intent features and integrate it with the token features to achieve more discriminative article features for MD. Upon these ideas, we suggest a novel MD method, namely Detecting Misinformation by Integrating Intent featuRes (DM-INTER). To evaluate the performance of DM-INTER, we conduct extensive experiments on benchmark MD datasets. The experimental results validate that DM-INTER can outperform the existing baseline MD methods.
Read more7/30/2024
0
Learning Domain-Invariant Features for Out-of-Context News Detection
Yimeng Gu, Mengqi Zhang, Ignacio Castro, Shu Wu, Gareth Tyson
Multimodal out-of-context news is a common type of misinformation on online media platforms. This involves posting a caption, alongside an invalid out-of-context news image. Reflecting its importance, researchers have developed models to detect such misinformation. However, a common limitation of these models is that they only consider the scenario where pre-labeled data is available for each domain, failing to address the out-of-context news detection on unlabeled domains (e.g., unverified news on new topics or agencies). In this work, we therefore focus on domain adaptive out-of-context news detection. In order to effectively adapt the detection model to unlabeled news topics or agencies, we propose ConDA-TTA (Contrastive Domain Adaptation with Test-Time Adaptation) which applies contrastive learning and maximum mean discrepancy (MMD) to learn the domain-invariant feature. In addition, it leverages target domain statistics during test-time to further assist domain adaptation. Experimental results show that our approach outperforms baselines in 5 out of 7 domain adaptation settings on two public datasets, by as much as 2.93% in F1 and 2.08% in accuracy.
Read more6/12/2024
🔎
0
Interpretable Detection of Out-of-Context Misinformation with Neural-Symbolic-Enhanced Large Multimodal Model
Yizhou Zhang, Loc Trinh, Defu Cao, Zijun Cui, Yan Liu
Recent years have witnessed the sustained evolution of misinformation that aims at manipulating public opinions. Unlike traditional rumors or fake news editors who mainly rely on generated and/or counterfeited images, text and videos, current misinformation creators now more tend to use out-of-context multimedia contents (e.g. mismatched images and captions) to deceive the public and fake news detection systems. This new type of misinformation increases the difficulty of not only detection but also clarification, because every individual modality is close enough to true information. To address this challenge, in this paper we explore how to achieve interpretable cross-modal de-contextualization detection that simultaneously identifies the mismatched pairs and the cross-modal contradictions, which is helpful for fact-check websites to document clarifications. The proposed model first symbolically disassembles the text-modality information to a set of fact queries based on the Abstract Meaning Representation of the caption and then forwards the query-image pairs into a pre-trained large vision-language model select the ``evidences that are helpful for us to detect misinformation. Extensive experiments indicate that the proposed methodology can provide us with much more interpretable predictions while maintaining the accuracy same as the state-of-the-art model on this task.
Read more4/9/2024